2010 Supreme(Cal) 211
High Court Of Calcutta
S.P. Talukdar, Aniruddha Bose, JJ.
Satinath Samanta : Appellant
Versus
P. Pramanick : Respondent
W.P.C.R.C. No. 56(W) of 2008 I N W. P. S.T. No.803 of 2001
Decided On : Feb 26,2010
Amit Moitra, Sumitra Dasgupta, Golam Gous
Deliberate and wilful disobedience of a court order amounts to contempt of court.
Headnote:
CONTEMPT OF COURT - ABSORPTION IN THE POST OF MEDICAL OFFICER - WEST BENGAL STATE HOMEOPATHIC HEALTH SERVICE ACT, 2002 - SECTION 4, 10, 11 - DIRECTION TO ABSORB THE PETITIONER IN THE NEXT AVAILABLE VACANCY - DELIBERATE AND WILFUL DISOBEDIENCE - CONTEMPT ESTABLISHED.
Fact of the Case:
The petitioner, a doctor, sought absorption in the post of Residential Medical Officer and/or Medical Officer at the Calcutta Homeopathic Medical College and Hospital. Despite a court order directing his absorption in the next available vacancy, the authorities failed to do so, claiming that there were no vacancies. The petitioner filed a contempt application alleging wilful disobedience of the court order.
Finding of the Court:
The court found that the authorities had deliberately and wilfully disobeyed the court's order by failing to absorb the petitioner in the next available vacancy. The court noted that the authorities had made certain transfers and shiftings of Medical Officers in order to circumvent the order and avoid absorbing the petitioner.
Issues: 1. Whether the authorities had deliberately and wilfully disobeyed the court's order by failing to absorb the petitioner in the next available vacancy? 2. Whether the authorities' actions amounted to contempt of court?
Ratio Decidendi: The court held that the authorities had committed contempt of court by deliberately and wilfully disobeying its order. The court noted that the authorities had failed to comply with the order in its letter and spirit, and that their actions amounted to circumvention of the order.
Final Decision: The court found the alleged contemnors guilty of contempt and directed them to be present in court 8 weeks from the date of the order.
S.P. Talukdar, J.
1. CLAIMING absorption in the post of Residential Medical Officer and/or Medical Officer, Calcutta, Homeopathic Medical College and Hospital, and praying for quashing the order dated 11th June, 1998, the petitioner filed an application before the learned West Bengal Administrative Tribunal. Learned Tribunal by its judgment and order dated 7th May, 2001 passed in Case No. T.A. 341 of 1998 dismissed the application. Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the said judgment and order of dismissal, an application under Article 226 of the Constitution was filed. The Division Bench of this court by order dated 22nd February, 2005 disposed of the said application with direction upon the concerned authority to absorb the petitioner against next available vacancy in the post of Medical Officer in the Calcutta Homeopathic Medical College and Hospital. This court in the said case being WPST No. 803 of 2001 further held that the petitioner would be entitled to all consequential benefits.
2. ALLEGING inaction and deliberate negligence as well as wilful disobedience to the said order of the Division Bench, an application was filed under Contempt of Court Act.
In the application filed before the learned Tribunal, the petitioner claimed that he was recruited in the Calcutta Homeopathic Medical College and Hospital as Honorary Junior House Surgeon and Physician for a period from 15th October, 1981 to 8th May, 1982 and Honorary Senior House Surgeon and Physician for a period from 11th May, 1982 to 20th October, 1982. Thereafter he worked as Stipendiary Residential House Surgeon from 21st October, 1982 to 7th May, 1983. During such period the petitioner was enjoying stipend according to prescribed rate per month. Though appointed at a consolidated stipend, the respondents gave him promotion in the Cadre of Senior Residential House Surgeon. On 8th May, 1993, the respondent-authorities expressed their inability to keep petitioner in the said post. The petitioner submitted a representation before the authorities. There was no favourable response. Some of the Residential House Staff, thereafter, approached the High Court by filing a writ application being Civil Rule No.1455 (W) of 1986. The said application was disposed of with direction for making payment of salaries who were terminated from the post of Senior Residential House Surgeon. The Honble Court directed absorption of the petitioners as Medical Officers. But the respondent-authorities did not absorb the petitioner as Medical Officer despite being repeatedly approached. The authorities, thus, violated Article 14 and 16 of the Constitution. The petitioners legitimate claim for absorption was, thus, ignored.
3. THE Principal Secretary, Health and Family Welfare Department, Govt. of West Bengal by order dated 11th June, 1998 turned down the claim of the petitioner. Being aggrieved by such arbitrary decision on the part of the respondent-authorities, the petitioner approached the learned Tribunal for redressal of his grievances. The learned Tribunal however, dismissed the claim of the petitioner thereby compelling the petitioner to knock the doors of this court. Having regard to the fact that two other Medical Officers, practically on similar footing, were absorbed, the Division Bench of this court directed absorption of the petitioner as against next available vacancy. Alleging inaction on the part of the authorities and claiming that such authorities had willfully disobeyed the direction of this court, the petitioner approached this court with the instant contempt application seeking redressal of grievances. As against this, the alleged contemnors filed their respective Affidavit-in- Opposition claiming therein that there had been no disobedience of this courts order nor any deliberate negligence on their part.
4. THE petitioner by filing the contempt application alleged that the order of the Division Bench dated 22nd February, 2005 was duly communicated to the Assist