The Court: The appellant above named being aggrieved by the judgment and order of dismissal of its writ petition by the learned Trial Judge dated 10th July 2008 has brought this appeal. By the judgment and order impugned learned Trial Judge upheld the award of the learned 7th Industrial Tribunal dated 30th of May 1992 which was passed in favour of third respondent, viz. Secretary Garden Reach Ship Builders & Engineers Ltd. Staff Association on the issues referred to by the State as follows:

"Whether Card Writers! Record Keepers of the company are entitled to same dearness allowance and other benefits as enjoyed by the Clerks of the company."

2. On the above issue earlier the learned Tribunal had passed an award dated 27th December, 1988 and the same was challenged by writ petition earlier by the appellant above named, and it was set aside by the learned Single Judge of this Court by an Order dated 19th July, 1990 and directed the learned Tribunal to hear the matter de novo observing certain irregularities and lacuna made therein. The appellant being aggrieved by the said portion of the order of remand preferred appeal against the order passed by the learned Single Judge