SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2013 Supreme(Cal) 699

High Court of Judicature at Calcutta
ASIM KUMAR RAY, J.
Dipak Dhar & Others
Versus
Haran Chandra Dhar & Others
Second Appeal No. 493 of 1997
Decided On : 09-10-2013

Important Points

In the absence of evidence as to the interests in the fund to which they were respectively entitled, or as to the shares which they respectively advanced, such persons shall be presumed to be equally interested in the property.

Subject

Property Law - Transfer of Property Act

Act Referred

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE : S.100
TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT : S.45

Headnote

JOINT TRANSFER OF PROPERTY - SECTION 45 OF TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT, 1882 - INTERPRETATION - PRESUMPTION OF EQUAL INTERESTS IN PROPERTY PURCHASED FOR CONSIDERATION FROM A COMMON FUND - CONCURRENT FINDINGS OF FACT BY COURTS BELOW - INTERFERENCE BY HIGH COURT IN SECOND APPEAL.

Fact of the Case:

A suit for partition and declaration of title to the suit property was filed by the plaintiff, Haran Chandra Dhar, claiming equal share in the property purchased jointly with his elder brother, Srimanta Kumar Dhar, since deceased. The defendants/appellants, legal heirs of Srimanta Kumar Dhar, contended that the property was purchased exclusively by Srimanta Kumar Dhar from his own funds and that the plaintiff was a mere benamdar.

Finding of the Court:

The court held that the evidence on record did not conclusively prove that Srimanta Kumar Dhar paid the entire consideration money for the suit property from his own funds. The court also held that the deeds/kobalas standing in the name of Srimanta Kumar Dhar and the plaintiff created a presumption of joint ownership in the absence of evidence to the contrary.

Issues: 1. Whether the courts below erred in considering the deeds starting from the year 1954 to 1966 (exhibited documents) bypassing the legal effect of the rest of the legal evidence on record; 2. Whether Section 45 of the Transfer of Property Act was rightly interpreted taking into account the background of the dispute between the parties.

Ratio Decidendi: 1. The courts below did not err in considering the deeds starting from the year 1954 to 1966 as evidence of joint ownership, as there was no evidence to the contrary. 2. Section 45 of the Transfer of Property Act was rightly interpreted by the courts below, as the evidence on record did not establish that the consideration money was paid from a common fund belonging to the joint purchasers.

Final Decision: The appeal was dismissed, upholding the concurrent findings of fact by the courts below that the plaintiff was entitled to an equal share in the suit property.

Advocates Appeared:
For the Appellants:Sabyasachi Bhattacharya, Chandradoy Roy, Advocates.
For the Respondents:Prabal Kumar Mukherjee, Bhaskar Mukherjee, Ms. Debjani Ghosh, Advocates.

Judgment :

Asim Kumar Ray, J.

This appeal is directed against the judgment and decree dated April 25,1996 passed in Title Appeal No. 17 of 1995 by learned Additional District Judge, 14th Court, Alipore, District-South 24-Parganas thereby affirming the judgment and decree dated September 22, 1994 and November 7, 1994 respectively passed in Title Suit No. 203 of 1983 by learned Assistant District Judge, Second Court, Alipore, District –South 24 – Parganas.

The factual background of the plaintiff/respondent’s case in a nutshell is that the suit property was purchased by the plaintiff/respondent Haran Chandra Dhar and his elder brother Srimanta Kumar Dhar, since deceased jointly in their owner name out of their own money in equal share. The property was developed and rooms were constructed thereon. They were possessing the same jointly till the death of Srimanta Kumar har. Plaintiff/respondent is in occupation of two rooms with kachha vit. Brick built wall and tile shed in separate mess with the defendants. There are two monthly tenants and the rent is realised by the defendant No.1/appellant without showing any account to the plaintiff though repeated demands were made. A dispute arise between the parties as to the peaceful and convenient use and enjoyment of the suit property. The plaintiff asked the defendants to agree with an amicable partition which was refused. So the suit was filed.

The case of the defendants/appellants is that the properties was purchased by Srimanta Kumar Dhar, since deceased out of his self acquired fund. The plaintiff/respondent has no right, title and interest over the suit property. He has never contributed any fund towards purchase of the said property. He had no income at the time of purchase of the property in issue so the question of contribution by the plaintiff/respondent does not arise. The suit property were never a joint property at any point of time. The plaintiff/respondent used to stay in Pakistan (now Bangladesh) and his elder brother, since deceased used to stay in India since 1938. He was an employee of Bata Shoe Company Private Ltd. now Bata Shoe Company (India ) Ltd. till the date of his superannuation in 1979. He was in absolute possession of the suit property since the date of his purchase. On his death the defendants/appellants are in absolute possession of the same. The defendant No. 1/appellant has been realising the rents after the death of her husband, Srimanta Kumar Dhar on behalf of herself and other appellants/defendants. At the time of purchase of the suit property by Srimanta Kumar Dhar, since deceased it was a vacant land. Thereafter several one storied buildings were constructed on the said plot at his own cost and expenses. After construction of the said building tenants were inducted therein. After the death of Srimanta Kumar Dhar/appellant No. 1. /defendant had made substantial development of the said building at her own cost. The respondent /plaintiff was and will is not in possession of the said property. He never enjoyed same except a portion of the land measuring 5 cottahs which was settled by Srimanta Kumar Dhar under his last will and testament. The appellant/defendant are advised to take probate proceedings before appropriate forum to get the letter of administration to the said testamentary will. Appellants/defendants Nos. 1 to 8 being the legal heirs and/or beneficiary of the will of Srimanta Kumar Dhar are the absolute owner of the suit property. The plaintiff/respondent is not entitled to undivided half share in the suit property. He at all material time was and still is a benamdar of Srimanta Kumar Dhar. He is not legally entitled to claim any share of the suit property.

On the aforesaid pleadings of the parties issues were framed by the learned Trial Court. Evidence of the parties were recorded. Plaintiff/respondent Haran Chandra Dhar was examined as his sole witness. On the contrary, defendant No. 1/appellant Usha Rani Dhar widow of Srimanta Kumar Dhar a































1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top