SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

1993 Supreme(Cal) 111

IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Ruma Pal, J.
Ratan Karmakar - Petitioner
Versus
Union of India & Ors. – Respondents
C.O. No. ….(W) of 1993
Decided on : March 11, 1993

Important Points

"Seizure" in the context of the Customs Act has been judicially defined as to "take possession of contrary to the wishes of the owner" and the requirement for the search and seizure to be conducted in the presence of independent witnesses is "the pragmatic requirement of fair play in action" and an imperative condition without which neither search nor the seizure could be sustained.

Subject

Customs Law - SEIZURE

Act Referred

CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE : S.100, S.165
CUSTOMS ACT : S.105, S.106, S.110

Headnote

CUSTOMS ACT - SEIZURE - PROCEDURE - SEARCH AND SEIZURE IN THE PRESENCE OF INDEPENDENT WITNESSES - REQUIREMENT MANDATORY - SECTION 110 READ WITH SECTION 100 OF THE CODE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURE - FAILURE TO COMPLY - SEIZURE UNSUSTAINABLE.

Fact of the Case:

Petitioner challenged the seizure of three bags of broken brass by Customs authorities. He claimed he purchased the brass from dealers in Maida, booked them on the Railways for Nabadwip Dham, and the goods were scheduled to arrive on 14th August 1992. On that date, at 2 O'clock in the morning, the respondent authorities seized the three bags after giving a receipt to the Station Master at Nabadwip Dham. The petitioner complained that despite repeated requests, the respondent authorities refused to release the broken brass.

Finding of the Court:

1. The seizure of the petitioner's consignment could not be sustained. 2. The procedure for effecting a seizure had not been expressly specified in the Customs Act, 1962. 3. Section 105 of the Act provided for searches in general in "any place" and this would cover searches in a conveyance as well. 4. The power in section 106 was in addition to the power conferred under section 105, and the procedure prescribed would be applicable to seizure consequent upon such search under section 110 of the Act. 5. The requirement for the search and seizure to be conducted in the presence of independent witnesses was in the Court's view "the pragmatic requirement of fair play in action" and an imperative condition without which neither search nor the seizure could be sustained. 6. The seizure took place on 14th August 1992 at Nabadwip Dham Railway Station, and the Custom Authorities did not even attempt to comply with the requirements delineated above. 7. The action of the seizing Officer was so irregular that whichever way it was looked at it could not be sustained. 8. The Court found no evidence of any belief having been formed by the Seizing Officer on 14th August 1992 that the goods were liable to confiscation. 9. The inventory prepared on 17th August 1992 was most unsatisfactory, as it did not properly describe the inventoried goods, and the seizing officer had created a situation where a fair adjudication could not be held.

Issues: 1. Whether the seizure of the petitioner's consignment could be sustained? 2. Whether the procedure for effecting a seizure had been expressly specified in the Customs Act, 1962? 3. Whether the requirement for the search and seizure to be conducted in the presence of independent witnesses was mandatory? 4. When did the seizure take place, and whether the Custom Authorities complied with the prescribed procedure?

Ratio Decidendi: 1. The seizure of the petitioner's consignment could not be sustained as the procedure for effecting a seizure had not been expressly specified in the Customs Act, 1962. 2. Section 105 of the Act provided for searches in general in "any place" and this would cover searches in a conveyance as well. 3. The power in section 106 was in addition to the power conferred under section 105, and the procedure prescribed would be applicable to seizure consequent upon such search under section 110 of the Act. 4. The requirement for the search and seizure to be conducted in the presence of independent witnesses was in the Court's view "the pragmatic requirement of fair play in action" and an imperative condition without which neither search nor the seizure could be sustained. 5. The seizure took place on 14th August 1992 at Nabadwip Dham Railway Station, and the Custom Authorities did not even attempt to comply with the requirements delineated above. 6. The action of the seizing Officer was so irregular that whichever way it was looked at it could not be sustained. 7. The Court found no evidence of any belief having been formed by the Seizing Officer on 14th August 1992 that the goods were liable to confiscation. 8. The inventory prepared on 17th August 1992 was most unsatisfactory, as it did not properly describe the inventoried goods, and the seizing officer had created a situation where a fair adjudication could not be held.

Final Decision: The writ application was allowed. The respondent authorities were directed to return the 3 hessian bags and their contents referred to in the letter dated 13.9.92 written by the Officer-in-Charge, Ranaghat Preventive Post to the Station Mater Nabadwip Dham Railway Station forthwith and in any event not later than a week from the date of the order. The respondents were also directed to pay the costs of the application to the petitioner, which were assessed at 30 G.Ms.

Advocates appeared:
Mr. Kamal Krishna Chakrabarti......for the Petitioner
Mr. N. C. Roychowdhury and S. K. Sengupta ......for the Respondents

Judgment :

In this case the petitioner has challenged the seizure of three bags of broken brass by the respondent authorities. According to the petitioner he carries on business of manufacturing brass utensils. He had purchased the broken brass from dealers at Maida on 10th August, 1992 and on 12th August, 1992 booked them on the Railways for Nabadwip Dham. The goods were scheduled to arrive at Nabadwip Dham on l4th August, 1992. On that date at 2 O'clock in the morning the respondent authorities seized the three bags after giving a receipt to the Station Master at Nabadwip Dham. The petitioner's complaint is that in spite of repeated requests the respondent authorities were refusing to release the broken brass to the petitioner.

2. The petitioner has annexed inter alia copies of the two Railway receipts covering the three bags in question. He has also annexed a letter dated 13.9.92, written by the Station Superintendent, Nabadwip Dham in answer to his letter dated 13.9.92. The Station Superintendent in his letter has said that the three bags which had been booked by the petitioner had been seized by the Preventive Post at Ranaghat who had given a letter to the Station Master at Nabadwip Dham for seizing the consignments as they were suspected of being contraband goods. The letter further records "that the consignment was not opened and checked here but reweighed respectively which I recorded in the seized memo and taken away from ASM on duty......... ...".

3. The writ application was moved on 6th January, 1993. The matter was directed to appear on the next Wednesday marked "For Orders". On 18th January, 1993 directions were given for filing of affidavits. The respondent authorities were to file their affidavit-in-opposition within two weeks from date which would mean by 1st February 1993. They did not do so. On 11th February, 1993 the matter appeared in the list. Certain samples of what the respondents claim were contained in the three bags were produced. The samples which were produced included items such as old buttons and buckles etc which appeared to have been manufactured outside the country. The petitioner however, disclaimed that the samples had been taken from his consignments. No affidavit was however, filed by the respondent authorities. The respondent authorities handed over certain documents which showed that in spite of repeated efforts on the part of the respondents' advocate, no instructions had been forthcoming from the respondent authorities. As a last chance time was given to the respondent authorities to file their affidavit-in-opposition by 16th February, 1993. The matter was directed to appear in the list on 24th February, 1993. The respondents affirmed an affidavit only on 22nd February, 1993. No extension had been obtained from this Court and the petitioner rightly refused to accept the copy sought to be served upon him out of time. The matter was drawn to the Court's attention and the petitioner was given the liberty to accept the copy of the affidavit-in-opposition and file his reply without prejudice.

4. There is no explanation forthcoming from the respondent authorities as to why there was such a delay in the preparation of the affidavit which in substance covers about seven pages. Strictly speaking, as no extension of time had been granted by the Court, the affidavit should not be considered. However, in order to do complete justice to the case I allow the respondents to use the affidavit. The respondents, however, will pay the costs for the delay to the petitioner assessed at 20 gms.

5. The respondent authorities have contended that upon the receipt of information the Customs Officers of Ranaghat Preventive Post went to Nabadwip Dham Railway Station on 14th August, 1992. A detention memo was issued to the Station Master for detaining the train for checking under section 106 of the Customs Act, 1962. The train arrived at 02.00 Hours in the night. The Guard Brake Van was opened in the presence of the Gua



























































1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top