SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

IN THE HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA
Soumen Sen, J.
Nawn Estates Pvt. Ltd. - Petitioner
Versus
Maheswary Ispat Ltd. - Respondent
CS No. 132 of 2013
Decided On : 5-9-2013

Important Points

In a summary suit under Order 37 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, based on dishonoured cheques, the allegations in the plaint are deemed admitted if the defendant fails to enter appearance or obtain leave to defend within the stipulated period, and the court has a mandatory duty to pass a decree in favor of the plaintiff.

Subject

Civil Law - Commercial

Act Referred

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE : O.37 R.2(3), O.37 R.2, O.37 R.2(2)
COMPANIES ACT : S.433, S.434
EVIDENCE ACT : S.114
NEGOTIABLE INSTRUMENTS ACT : S.118

Headnote

ORDER 37 - DISHONOURED CHEQUE - SECTIONS 118, 138 - Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 - SUMMARY SUIT - INTERPRETATION OF ORDER 37, RULE 2(2) AND (3) - COURT'S DISCRETION IN PASSING DECREE - PRESUMPTION OF DEBTOR-CREDITOR RELATIONSHIP - APPLICABILITY OF INTEREST ACT - SUMMARY SUIT PROCEDURE AND ITS DISTINCTION FROM REGULAR SUIT - ADMISSION OF ALLEGATIONS IN PLAINT - MANDATORY DUTY OF COURT ON FAILURE TO ENTER APPEARANCE - APPLICABILITY OF PROVISIONS OF ORDER 37 TO SUITS ON NEGOTIABLE INSTRUMENTS - DISTINCTION BETWEEN OPTIONAL AND MANDATORY PRESUMPTIONS UNDER EVIDENCE ACT AND NEGOTIABLE INSTRUMENTS ACT - APPLICABILITY OF INTEREST ACT TO INTEREST RATE AGREED BETWEEN PARTIES.

Fact of the Case:

Plaintiff filed a suit under Order 37 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, based on two dishonoured cheques issued by the defendant towards payment for goods sold and delivered. The defendant did not enter appearance or file a written statement within the stipulated time. The plaintiff adduced evidence to support its claim, including letters, cheques, and legal notices.

Finding of the Court:

The court held that the defendant was aware of the pending proceedings but failed to enter appearance or obtain leave to defend within the prescribed period. The court relied on the presumption of debtor-creditor relationship arising from the issuance of cheques and the defendant's failure to provide a satisfactory explanation for the dishonoured cheques.

Issues: 1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree in a summary suit under Order 37 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, based on dishonoured cheques issued by the defendant. 2. Whether the allegations in the plaint shall be deemed to be admitted due to the defendant's failure to enter appearance or obtain leave to defend. 3. Whether the court can pass a decree without evidence in a summary suit governed by Order 37, Rule 2. 4. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to interest at the agreed rate of 24% per annum on the principal sum.

Ratio Decidendi: 1. Order 37 provides a special summary procedure for suits on negotiable instruments, and the allegations in the plaint are deemed admitted if the defendant fails to enter appearance or obtain leave to defend within the stipulated period. 2. The court has a mandatory duty to pass a decree in a summary suit where the defendant fails to enter appearance or obtain leave to defend, and the decree follows as a matter of course. 3. The presumption of debtor-creditor relationship arising from the issuance of cheques is not dislodged by the defendant's denial of the purchase agreement or the existence of a loan facility. 4. The court has the discretion to determine the appropriate rate of interest in a summary suit, considering the provisions of the Interest Act and the nature of the transaction.

Final Decision: The court decreed the suit in favor of the plaintiff for a sum of Rs. 67,70,000/- with interest at the rate of 10% per annum from April 2011 till realization.

JUDGMENT :

Soumen Sen, J.

1. The suit is filed under Order 37 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. The suit is based on a dishonoured cheque claimed to have been issued by the defendant to the plaintiff towards payment of price of goods sold and delivered. The summon in the prescribed form was issued on 17th April, 2013 giving 10 days time for the defendant to enter appearance and file written statement. The said summon was duly served upon the defendant on July 2, 2013 as it appears from the endorsement made on the reverse of the writ of summons.

2. The defendant is aware of the pending proceeding. The defendant did not enter appearance within the time specified in the writ of summons. The report of the Deputy Registrar dated 30th August, 2013 shows that the defendant has not entered appearance either in person or the advocate dated 29th August, 2013.

3. Although, the plaintiff is not obliged to adduce any evidence and could have claimed a decree on the basis of a strong presumption which is attached to the section by reason of Order 37 Rule 2 (3) of the Code of Civil Procedure, witness was present in Court on September 2, 2013 and adduced evidence on behalf of the said plaintiff.

4. The plaintiff has relied upon and produced the following documents in support of its claim namely :

(i) The letter dated 4th May, 2010.

(ii) The letter dated 19th February, 2011

(iii) The letter dated 15th March, 2011

(iv) Original cheque for a sum of Rs. 35 lakhs, being cheque no. 502036, issued by the defendant in favour of the plaintiff dated 1st November, 2011 along with the intimation notice issued by the Bank of Baroda dated 5th January, 2012 and 9th March, 2012.

(v) Original cheque issued by the defendant in favour of the plaintiff for a sum of Rs. 32,70,000/- being cheque No.502033 dated 7th November, 2011 drawn on Bank of Baroda along with the letter of intimation dated 5th January, 2012 and 9th March, 2012.

(vi) Legal notice dated 17th May, 2012

(vii) Legal notice dated 28th September, 2012

(viii) Letter dated 19th October, 2012 issued by Maheshwary Ispat Ltd.

5. The said documents are marked as Exbt.-A, B, C, D (collectively), E, F and G.

6. The witness has stated that the plaintiff used to procure supply of TMT Bars from the defendants. The plaintiff had entered into the agreement on 4th May, 2010 with the defendant for supply of 1200 MT of TMT Bars. The plaintiff had issued two several cheques being Cheque No.765353 dated 4th May, 2010 for sum of Rs. 35,00,000/- ( Rs. 35 lakhs only) as also post dated Cheque No.210883 dated 19th January, 2011 for a sum of Rs. 32,70,000/- aggregating to Rs. 67,70,000/- drawn in favour of the defendant on State Bank of Hyderabad being part payment in advance of the value of 1200 MT of TMT Bars calculated at the rate of 15,000 per MT inclusive of all taxes to be supplied by the defendant to the plaintiff. The witness has referred to the letter dated 4th May, 2010 being (Exbt. A) and stated that in case of failure to deliver all materials within the agreed period, the defendant would be liable to pay interest on the amount advanced at the rate of 24% per annum for the delayed period. According to the witness the defendant had failed and neglected to supply the said materials and accordingly, in view of the failure to supply, the plaintiff is entitled to refund of the said sum of Rs. 67,70,000/- along with interest at the rate of 24% per annum on the said sum. The plaintiff initially initiated a winding up proceedings after issuing a statutory notice dated April 16, 2012. In reply to notice issued under Sections 433 and 434 of the Companies Act, 1956 and also under the Interest Act dated 16th April, 2012 issued by the plaintiff, the defendant by a letter dated May 17, 2012 denied its liability. The said 4 defendant, however, contended that such money was paid as and by way of accommodation loan and, accordingly, the question of payment of principal and interest against the alleged advance for purchase of 1200 MT of TMT






















1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top