2016 Supreme(Cal) 551
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Jyotirmay Bhattacharya & Ishan Chandra Das, JJ.
Sri Lalan Prashad – Appellant
Versus
Sri Parimal Chandra Das – Respondent
S.A.T. No. 99 of 2016 with CAN No. 5987 of 2016
Decided On : 22-11-2016
Important Points
Subject
Property Law - Landlord and Tenant
Act Referred
TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT : S.106
WEST BENGAL PREMISES TENANCY ACT : S.24, S.22(1), S.25, S.2(g), S.6(4), S.6(1)(e)
Headnote
EJECTMENT SUIT - WEST BENGAL PREMISES TENANCY ACT, 1997 - SECTION 24, 25, 6(4), 2(G) - REASONABLE REQUIREMENT - SUFFICIENCY OF ALTERNATIVE ACCOMMODATION - INTERPRETATION OF PROVISIONS AND THEIR IMPACT ON COURT'S DECISION.
Fact of the Case:
Plaintiff filed an eviction suit against the defendant on the ground of reasonable requirement. The defendant contested the suit, claiming that a new relationship of landlord and tenant was created during the pendency of the suit by way of acceptance of rent by the landlord. The Trial Court dismissed the suit, holding that a new tenancy was created, while the first Appellate Court reversed this decision, relying on the provisions of the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1997.
Finding of the Court:
The High Court held that the findings of the Trial Court were illegal and not justified, as the relationship between landlord and tenant continues under the Premises Tenancy Act until a decree of eviction is passed against the tenant by a court of competent jurisdiction. The Court further held that the first Appellate Court was right in holding that the findings made by the Trial Judge in this regard are illegal and not justified.
Issues: 1. Whether acceptance of rent during the pendency of the suit creates a new relationship of landlord and tenant, thereby defeating the eviction suit? 2. Whether the courts below erred in not considering the plaintiff's reasonable requirement and the sufficiency of alternative accommodation?
Ratio Decidendi: 1. The Court interpreted Section 24 of the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1997, and held that acceptance of rent during the pendency of the suit does not operate as a waiver of the notice to quit given by the landlord to the tenant. 2. The Court also interpreted Section 25 of the Act and held that it has no application in the present case as it deals with a situation where such rent is accepted at a point of time when no proceeding for recovery of possession of the suit premises is pending. 3. The Court further interpreted Section 2(g) of the Act and held that a tenant's liability to pay rent to the landlord continues even during the pendency of the suit, as long as a decree of eviction is not passed by any court of competent jurisdiction. 4. The Court also interpreted Section 6(4) of the Act and held that it contemplates service of notice of suit in case eviction is sought for on any of the grounds as mentioned in Section 6 of the Act, except on the ground mentioned in clause (e) of sub-section (1) of Section 6 of the Act. 5. The Court held that the plaintiff reasonably requires the suit premises for his own use and occupation and for the occupation of the members of his family, and that the plaintiff has no other reasonable suitable alternative accommodation elsewhere.
Final Decision: The High Court dismissed the appeal, holding that no substantial question of law was involved and that the findings of the first Appellate Court were correct.
For the Appellants : Mr. Sujash Ghosh Dostidar and Ms. Sankari Roy.
Jyotirmay Bhattacharya, J.
1. This second appeal is directed against the judgment and decree dated 28th August, 2015 passed by the learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), 6th Court, Alipore in Ejectment Appeal No. 13 of 2014 reversing the judgment and decree dated 31st January, 2014 passed by the learned Civil Judge (Junior Division), 1st Court, Alipore in Ejectment Suit No. 209 of 2004 at the instance of the defendant/appellant.
2. Let us now consider the merit of the appeal to find out as to whether any substantial question of law is involved in this appeal for which the appeal is required to be admitted for hearing under the provision of Order XLI Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure or not.
3. Here is the case where we find that the plaintiff/respondent filed a suit for eviction against the defendant/appellant on the ground of reasonable requirement. The defendant appeared in the said suit and contested the same by filing written statement, denying the allegations made out in the plaint.
4. Learned Trial Judge after considering the pleadings of the parties as well as their evidence though came to the conclusion that the plaintiff being the owner/landlord of the suit premises reasonably requires the suit premises for his own use and occupation and for the occupation of his family members and the plaintiff has no other alternative suitable accommodation elsewhere to satisfy his requirement, but the learned Trial Judge ultimately dismissed the suit by holding that a new relationship of landlord and tenant was created during the pendency of the suit by way of acceptance of rent by the landlord from his tenant during the pendency of the suit.
5. Admittedly the landlord during the pendency of the suit accepted the rent for the period from June 2007 to December 2007 upon grant of receipts. The suit was filed in 2004. The suit was disposed of by passing the judgment on 31st January, 2014. Thus, it appears from the record that rent was realised by the plaintiff/respondent from the defendant/appellant during the pendency of the suit. In this context, the learned Trial Judge held that by payment and acceptance of rent between the parties during the pendency of the suit, a new relationship of landlord and tenant was created between the parties and as such, the suit is not maintainable. Mr. Ghosh Dostidar, learned advocate appearing for the defendant/ appellant has supported this part of the findings of the learned Trial Judge.
6. Learned first Appellate Court, however, reversed such findings of the learned Trial Judge by referring to the provision contained in Section 24 of the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1997. The legality of such findings of the learned first Appellate Court is under challenge in this appeal.
7. Let us now consider as to how far the findings of the learned Trial Judge is acceptable with reference to the provision of the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1997.
8. Let us first of all consider the provision of Section 24 of the said Act which runs as follows:-
“24. Savings as to acceptance of rent. – The withdrawal of rent deposited in the prescribed manner shall not operate as an admission against the person withdrawing it of the correctness of the rent or the rate thereof, the period of default, the amount due or any other fact stated in the application of the tenant for depositing the rent under sub-section (1) of section 22, nor shall it operate as a waiver of any notice to quit given by him to the tenant.”
9. The said provision, thus, makes it clear that acceptance of rent will not operate as waiver of the notice to quit given by him to the tenant. The said provision also makes it clear that even withdrawal of rent shall not operate as an admission against the person withdrawing it of the correctness of the rent or the rate thereof, the period of default, the amount due or any other fact stated in the application of the tenant for depositing the rent under sub-section (1) of section 22. This provision thus