RICHARD GARTH, FIELD
Chundro Marwari – Appellant
Versus
Mohamed Eshak – Respondent
JUDGMENT
Richard Garth, C.J. - In this case one Mohamed Eshak applied to this Court to send for the papers in a case in which one Chundro Marwari has been acquitted by the District Magistrate, for the purpose of having the Magistrate's judgment set aside.
2. Chundro Marwari was convicted on the 12th of August last by Mr. Caspersz, who was the Assistant Magistrate, of criminal breach of trust, upon the prosecution of Mohamed Eshak, who was his employer. An appeal was preferred to the District Magistrate, who, after hearing the case, reversed the conviction and acquitted the prisoner.
3. We were asked to set aside this judgment of the District Magistrate, upon "the ground that, on the very day on which Chundro Marwari was convicted by Mr. Caspersz, Mr. Caspersz was, by an order of the Lieutenant-Governor, made a first class Magistrate, and consequently that the District Magistrate had no jurisdiction to entertain an appeal from his decision.
4. But having now ascertained the true state of the case, I think that there is nothing in this objection. In the first place I have great doubt, whether the mere order of the Lieutenant-Governor, that a Magistrate shall be vested with first class po
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.