IN THE HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
RAJENDRA CHANDRA SINGH SAMANT, ANIL KUMAR SHUKLA, JJ.
Jain Kumar Sahu S/o Charan Sahu - Appellant
Versus
State of Chhattisgarh - Respondent
CRA No. 830 of 2010
Decided On : 01-06-2017
Indian Penal Code,1860 - Section 302 - Criminal Procedure Code,1973 - Sections 161 and 313 - Evidence Act - Section 32 - Offence of murder – Examination of accused – Appeal against convicting - Appellant and had two daughters out of their wedlock. In the night intervening 31-03-2010 and 01-04-2010 at about 1.30 am, appellant went to Kantu Ram Sahu (PW/1), Laxawantin Bai (PW/6) and Netram (PW/8) and informed them that deceased Saraswati Bai has self-immolated and while he was trying to extinguish the fire he also suffered burn injury over his hand. These witnesses went to the house of appellant and found deceased lying on the floor in burnt condition. Deceased was immediately taken to District Hospital - where primary aid was given and looking to her serious condition, she was referred to Medical College Hospital, Raipur and an information (Ex.P/4) thereof was sent to City Kotwali, Mahasamund. On the request of P.S. Kotwali, Mahasamund, deceased was medically examined – Held, case is totally based on the evidence of oral dying declaration and the circumstances co-related. Rest of the witnesses examined by the prosecution are related to investigative procedure and requires no discussion - closely scrutinizing the evidence of prosecution and the defence taken, we are of the considered opinion that the trial Court while convicting and sentencing the appellant has not committed any error of law. Consequently, the appeal preferred by the appellant is bereft of any substance, the same is liable to be and is hereby dismissed. The appellant is reported to be in jail, therefore, no further order etc is needed - Appeal is dismissed
R.C.S. Samant, J.
1. This appeal has been preferred against the judgment of conviction and order of sentence dated 09.11.2010 passed by Sessions Judge, Mahasamund in S.T. No.26/2010 convicting the accused/appellant under Section 302 of IPC and sentencing him to undergo imprisonment for life with fine of Rs.10000/-, plus default stipulation.
2. The prosecution case in brief is that deceased Saraswati Bai was second wife of the appellant and had two daughters out of their wedlock. In the night intervening 31-03-2010 and 01-04-2010 at about 1.30 am, appellant went to Kantu Ram Sahu (PW/1), Laxawantin Bai (PW/6) and Netram (PW/8) and informed them that deceased Saraswati Bai has self-immolated and while he was trying to extinguish the fire he also suffered burn injury over his hand. These witnesses went to the house of appellant and found deceased lying on the floor in burnt condition. Deceased was immediately taken to District Hospital, Mahasamund where primary aid was given and looking to her serious condition, she was referred to Medical College Hospital, Raipur and an information (Ex.P/4) thereof was sent to City Kotwali, Mahasamund. On the request of P.S. Kotwali, Mahasamund, deceased was medically examined vide Ex.P/3 wherein it was reported that deceased had sustained 100 % burn injury. Deceased was brought dead in Dr. B.R. Ambedkar College Hospital, Raipur on 01.04.2010 at 7.00 am. An information Ex.P/17 was immediately dispatched to Police Station, Moudahapara, based on which unnumbered merg Ex.P/15 was recorded on 01.04.2010 at 10.25 (whether it is AM or PM has not been mentioned in the merg). Inquest over the body of deceased was conducted vide Ex.P/18 and dead body was sent for postmortem examination to Ambedkar Hospital, Raipur where Dr. Ulhas Gonnade (PW/9) conducted autopsy on the body of deceased and gave his report Ex.P/20 opining the cause of death to be syncope due to burn injury.
A written complaint Ex.P/10 was lodged by Laxawantin Bai (PW/6). On the basis of merg inquiry and this written complaint, FIR (Ex.P/9) was lodged in Police Station, Tumgaon by Bharti Markam (PW/5) registering the offence under Section 302 IPC against the appellant. Conducting investigation, one panchanama (confession panchanama) Ex.P/1 was prepared in presence of witnesses and same was seized vide seizure memo Ex.P/2. Togendra Singh Thakur (PW/4)-Patwari prepared spot map vide Ex.P/8. One spot map was separately prepared by the Investigating Officer vide Ex.P/11. Some burnt articles were seized from the spot vide seizure memo Ex.P/13 and seized articles were sent for its chemical examination to FSL, Raipur but no report thereof was obtained. Statements of the witnesses were recorded under Section 161 of Cr.P.C. On completion of investigation, appellant was charge-sheeted.
3. Charge under Section 302 of IPC was framed against the appellant. Appellant denied the charge and prayed for trial. Prosecution has examined as many as 12 witnesses. On examination under Section 313 of Cr.P.C., appellant denied all the incriminating circumstances and evidence against him and pleaded innocence and false implication. It was submitted that deceased was mentally retarded and used to quarrel with appellant as he had kept his father with him, which was objected by the deceased and she used to leave him and go to her maternal home very often. In defence, he examined one Vijay Kumar Markandey as DW/1. After affording opportunity for adducing evidence to the parties and hearing arguments, the impugned judgment has been passed convicting and sentencing the appellant as mentioned in para 1 of this judgment.
4. The grounds in this appeal are that the conviction of the appellant by the trial Court is bad in law and not based on legally admissible evidence. The prosecution has failed to prove motive of appellant to commit murder of the deceased. The prosecution witnesses Kantu Ram Sahu (PW/1), Dr. Ghanshyam Chandrakar (PW/2) and Laxawantin Bai (PW/6) are no
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.