High Court Of Delhi
JAI GOPAL GOYAL - Appellant
Versus
BISHEN DAYAL GOYAL - Respondent
C.S.(O.S.) 87 of 1995
Decided On : 08/13/2004
( 1 ) THE brief facts as stated by the plaintiff in the plaint are as follows:-
(A) Though the suit property at C-254, Defence colony, New Delhi was acquired by the defendant in 1968, the plaintiff No. 1 came into possession thereof and started living in the premises as he was jointly with the defendant running the business in the name and style of m/s Steel Trading Company as the defendant was permanently settled in Calcutta.
(B) The plaintiff No. 2 shifted in Delhi in the suit premises in the year 1979 due to losses suffered by him in his business in Rajasthan. In the year 1981-82 M/s steel Trading Company was dissolved and the defendant became the sole proprietor thereof. The plaintiff No. 2 apart from looking after the business of the above firm, was also running his independent business of M/s Kalptaru enterprises from the ground floor of the property in question.
(C) The plaintiff No. 1 was occupying the entire first floor with servant quarter and the plaintiff No. 2 was occupying the entire ground floor as well as the second floor and terrace with the roof above along with the servant quarter and the garage.
(D) In respect of loan taken from M/s Diomond investment and Properties Co. Pvt. Ltd. , Calcutta, the defendant faced recovery proceedings filed by the said company and the suit filed against the defendant was decreed and transferred to Delhi for execution. The plaintiffs agreed to repay the loan amount of Rs. 42 lakhs to the said company for and on behalf of the defendant. During the execution proceedings, the property was put up for auction and the plaintiffs gave their bid and deposited a sum of Rs. 10,00,500/- towards the bid amount. Under the court proceedings, consequently a sum of Rs. 42 lakhs was paid by the plaintiff to the Decree Holder.
(E) The plaintiffs have received the original title deeds of the property from M/s Diamond Investment and properties Co. Pvt. Ltd. in the year 1991 when the loan amount was repaid to the said company and also are in peaceful possession of the suit premises. A loan agreement was executed on 5th July, 1991 between the plaintiffs and the defendant which is exhibited as PW- 1/2, which required the return of Rs. 42 lakhs by the defendant along with a sum of Rs. 23 lakhs towards compensation totaling Rs. 65 lakhs to the plaintiffs within a period of three years and six months from the date of execution of the said agreement, failing which the plaintiffs were to become owners of the first and second floors of the property in question. In 1993, the defendant approached the plaintiff and had expressed his inability to pay the said amount leading to the negotiations between the parties and eventually an agreement dated 18th February, 1994 was reached by which the defendant was to sell the entire house to the plaintiffs for a total consideration of Rs. 1,05,00,000/ -. The said agreement dated 18th February, 1994 is proved and is exhibited as PW-1/3. Consequently, the amount of rs. 65 lakhs payable by the defendant to the plaintiffs was treated as advance and a sum of Rs. 40,00,000/- was to be paid by the plaintiffs to the defendant at the time of execution and registration of the sale deed. The defendant was also to obtain other necessary permissions and no objections. The plaintiffs were always ready and willing to perform their part of contract.
(F) The defendant visited Delhi on 11th December, 1994 and stayed with the plaintiffs and then developed malafide intention and got a notice issued from his counsel to the plaintiffs on 22nd December, 1994 seeking to return the money and vacation of the property. The said notice is exhibited as Exhibit PW-1/4. This notice was replied to on behalf of the plaintiffs. The reply is exhibited as Exhibit PW-1/5. The defendant had also retained the possession of one room on the first floor which was subsequently vacated in the year 1997 and subsequent to the filing of the suit retained possession of a big room on the ground floor w
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.