2003 Supreme(Del) 696
High Court Of Delhi
MANJU BALA - Appellant
Versus
UNION OF INDIA - Respondent
Civil Writ 3336 of 2003
Decided On : 08/04/2003
Aman Lekhi, Siya Ram Shahi
Headnote:Education - Admission — Post Graduate course in Medical Colleges — Petitioner having rank of 1575 in merit list of All India Post Graduate entrance examination — Last candidate admitted having rank 169 in All India Merit List — Petitioner specifically waiving her right to be considered in the State of Rajasthan — Seats, if any available surrendered to State of Rajasthan — Writ petition praying for considering petitioner to be permitted to participate in the second counselling for admissions in Rajasthan assuming that there are some seats lying vacant in the All India Quota — No relief be granted as it would be behind the back of the State Government of Rajasthan.
( 1 ) RELIANCE is being placed on the Orders of the Hon ble Supreme Court in Writ Petition No. 203 of 1998 dated 20/07/1998 entitled as Karandeep Singh and Ors. Versus Union of India and Ors. , and in particular to the following paragraph:
"in the peculiar facts and circumstances of these cases, we direct the director General, Health Services to examine the cases of all these petitioners and unless there are candidates, who have secured marks higher than the petitioner and are interested to persue the Post Graduate courses in the concerned colleges, to grant them admission against the vacant seats available in different medical colleges of the country. The petitioners shall approach the Director General, Health Services within one week from today for a follow up action. "
( 2 ) IT is on this basis that learned counsel for the Petitioner submits that notwithstanding the Petitioner s specific waiver of the right to be considered in the State of Rajasthan, and assuming that there are some seats lying vacant in the All-India Quota, she should be permitted to participate in the second counselling for admissions in Rajasthan.
( 3 ) THE genesis of the system/procedure which is presently in vogue can be found in Anand S. Biji Versus State of Kerela and Others, (1993) 3 Supreme Court Cases 80 which reads as follows:
"the new system, in short, is this: after the examination is over, the results would be published in the order of merit. The selection committee will call 150 candidates a day in the order of merit. A chart will be kept ready and displayed at all relevant places indicating the colleges and subjects wherein the seats are available. Candidates will be called in the order of merit and asked to indicate his/her choice. The slot chosen by him/her then gets closed. This procedure will be gone through until all the seats are filled up. There would be no second or third list. Any seats remaining vacant thereafter will be surrendered to the State government. But this modification will apply to and come into effect only for and from the admissions for the year 1994. It will not apply to the admissions currently underway. In approving the modifications, we have kept in mind the fact that most of the candidates for post-graduate admissions are employed and have the means to come to delhi for a day for counselling. We, accordingly, approve the modifications, mentioned below, as suggested by the Director General of Health Services, New delhi. (1)The All India post-graduate entrance examination will be conducted on second Sunday of January. The candidates will not be required to give any choices at the time of submission of the application form. (2)The results will be announced by the third week of February every year. (3)The merit list will consist of number of candidates equal to the number of seats available for allotment. A waiting list containing not more than 10% of the merit list will also be declared from amongst the successful candidates who have secured more than 50% marks in the competitive examination. (4)The allotment by personal appearance will start from the first of March every year and will continue up to March 15. (5)In the Bulletin of Information the dates for allotment by personal appearance and the venue at Delhi will be notified. The time-schedule for personal appearance will also be notified along with the results in the newspaper. (6)For personal appearance, the candidates will be called in batches of 150 each day in the order of merit. (7)The candidates shall have the right to choose any one of the available seats at his/her rank. The same will be allotted to him/her and the allotment letters will be issued on the next day. (8)In case a candidate is unable to appear in person on a notified date for personal appearance, he/she can send his/her representative with an authority letter for allotment. The allotment made to the authorised representative shall be binding on the candidate. (9)Each candidate sha