SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Judicial Analysis Court Copy Headnote Facts Arguments Court observation
Listen Audio Icon Pause Audio Icon
judgment-img

2001 Supreme(Del) 1796

High Court Of Delhi
CHANDER PARKASH - Appellant
Versus
MINISTRY OF HEALTH, NIRMAN BHAWAN - Respondent
Civil Writ 4444 of 2001
Decided On : 12/21/2001

Advocates Appeared:
V.K.Shali

Headnote:Constitution of India, 1950 - Article 226 — Writ petition — Petitioner is a doctor and has experienced the difficulties, hurdles and obstacles faced by the victims of road accidents and also the inadequate medical facilities available in this country to meet the requirement — Petition tiled pointing out the measures which should be taken to minimise the difficulties — Different measures pointed out by the petitioner — Apex Court in earlier two decisions laid down the guidelines and directions given in respect thereof — 1 nspite of the directions of the Apex Court there is no such improvement in the situation and the casualties due to road-accident are alarming — Law laid down in the judgments of Supreme Court is a law of the land and authority is bound to comply with the same — The Copies of two judgments of the Supreme Court be circulated in the Government and Private Hospitals — Petition disposed of.

       Held:

       However, one cannot lose sight of the fact that inspire of directions contained in the aforesaid two judgment of the Apex Court, there is not much improvement in the situation and the casualties due to road accidents, because of not providing adequate medical treatment in time, are of alarming magnitude. However, we may mention that some of the suggestions given by the petitioner are worthy of appropriate consideration. While we do not cotsfwefti upon the suggestions regarding tapping the sources of revenue for free medical treatment as that may require appropriate legislative action, the feasibility of the approach suggested by the petitioner and recorded in paras A to G needs to be examined.

A. K. SIKRI

( 1 ) DR. Chander Prakash, MBBS, MS (Surgery) (hereinafter REFERRED TO to as the petitioner ) appears to be a public spirited person belonging to medical fraternity. Being a Surgeon himself, he has experienced the difficulties, obstacles and hurdies including inefficient and inadequate medical services, being faced by the victims of road accidents in the country. Due to non-availability of timely medical first aid and further treatment millions of such victims die on roads or face permanent disability leading to loss of vocation and hardships to family, this unhappy experience has disturbed the petitioner who addressed letter dated 29/06/2001 to Hon ble the Chief Justice pointing out the various defects in the system and the measures which should be taken to minimise such fatalities.

( 2 ) THIS letter was treated as writ petition in the category of Public Interest Litigation and notice was issued to the respondents. Mr. V. K. Shali appeared for the Govt. of NCT of Delhi.

( 3 ) IN this petition, the petitioner has highlighted that even after 52 years of independence our country has not been able to develop organised trauma services and disaster management medical services. The petitioner emphasises the fact that the first half hour is the crucial time 5. and if during this period proper first aid/treatment is given, many lives can be saved. He also states that the Government policies were designed and directed for the medical treatment accordingly. However, in the year 2001, 80% of health care is in private sector and 20% in government sector. So there is an urgent need to have concrete and effective trauma services giving private sector a pivotal role. He also highlights the fact that modem medical treatment is very expensive because modern diagnostic equipments, gadgets, implants and medical treatment is very costly. It will be Herculean task for anybody to think of providing these medical treatment free of cost and it is not possible by any government to provide free 4. medical treatment. He further states that it is the duty of the State, being a welfare state to dire guarantee the health of the citizen. It cannot be denied that majority of people in road accident being padestrians and cyclists are from poor economic strata. There is an urgent need of a mechanism to provide free health care to these unfortunate victims. Most of the time they reach hospitals as unknown persons. In view of the aforesaid dismal state of affairs the petitioner goes on to suggest certain measures which are required to be taken for providing medical treatment to the road accident victims. These suggestions are as under:

1. Certain untapped sources of revenue should be utilised for free medical treatment to people in the country, namely, (a) amount collected by the Insurance Company as a third party insurance component which is approximately Rs. 206 crores from the State of Delhi only. 25% of the above i. e. approximately 50% should be converted to corpse account every year for the treatment of road accident victims in Delhi to start and then similarly implement it in the whole country.

2. Appropriate authorities should develop the mechanism to provide free treatment to all the road accident victims and reimburse the cost to health institutions willing to provide the complete treatment from the funds so collected.

3. In case funds collected as third party insurance are not enough, an additional amount can be charged from the vehicle meant only for treatment of road accident victims, he suggests that if such persons are charged at the rate of Rs. 200. 00 per vehicle as additional amount, the sum collected would be about Rs. 70 crores in Delhi alone.

4. Mobilisation of additional sources for corpse may be considered from the following sources: (i) Some share of sale tax and excise on auto vehicles and automobile parts. (ii) Share from the sale of petrol/diesel. (iii)Some share from road tax. (iv) Share from compounding of challans of vehi































Click Here to Read the rest of this document

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
Judicial Analysis

SupremeToday

SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
logo-black

An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers

Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance

qr

Scan Me!

India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!

For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :

whatsapp-icon Back to top