High Court Of Delhi
ASHOK RAI - Appellant
Versus
KAILASH NATH AND ASSOCIATES - Respondent
Decided On : 07/17/1998
( 1 ) THIS order will govern the disposal of I. A. No. 2742/97.
( 2 ) SUIT was filed, inter alia, alleging that the plaintiff, Vikram Rai and Smt. Jyotsna Sahni are the heirs of Smt. Vimla Balwant Rai who died intestate on 28th September, 1988. Defendant No. 1 is a registered firm carrying on the business of builders and developers of properties and defendants 2 and 3 are the partners thereof. Defendants 4 to 6 are the sons of Late Basheshar Nath and brothers of said Smt. Vimla Balwant Rai. Defendants 1 to 3, on the one hand, and Defendants 4 to 6, on the other hand, entered into a building and development agreement on 2nd May, 1971 with regard to property situated at 9, Barakhamba Road, New Delhi owned by defendants 4 to 6. In a letter dated 2nd May,1971 defendant No. 1 had culled out the terms of contract for development of the said plot and construction of a multi-storey building thereon. Under the said agreement it was, inter alia, stated that out of the total saleable area of the multi-storey building 31. 5% would belong to defendants 4 to 6 while the remaining 68. 5% to defendants 1 to 3 on different floors. By the letter dated 17th March, 1980 defendants 4 to 6 requested defendants 1 to 3 enter into an agreement of sale on one flat to said Smt. Vimla Balwant Rai. Defendants 4 to 6 subsequently, wrote to defendant No. 1 to allot 1282. 5 sq. m. of gross area in the building. It is alleged that an agreement of sale was entered into between said Smt. Vimla Balwant Rai and defendant No. 2 on 19th March, 1980 and it was agreed that a flat on the third floor of the building admeasuing 1100 sq. ft. carpet area would be allotted to her for a consideration of Rs. 2. 80 lakhs. Thereafter, amount of Rs. 2. 75 lakhs was paid by Smt. Vimla Balwant Rai vide Cheque No. 0567771 dated 2nd April, 1984 after adjusting the advance amount of Rs. 5,000. 00 already paid in the past. Since defendant No. 1 did not hand over possession of the flat, the plaintiff wrote a letter on 28th November, 1992 to the defendant asking them to hand over possession of the flat without any further delay. In reply to this letter, defendant no. 1 wrote to the plaintiff on 21 st December, 1992 denying that they had agreed to sell 1100 sq. ft. or that by any subsequent letter the gross area was increased to 1282 sq. ft. It was asserted that under the agreement dated 19th March, 1980 a flat of only 900 sq. ft. was agreed to be sold to Smt. Vimla Balwant Rai.
( 3 ) IN the said letter plaintiff was asked to send death certifictes of Smt. Vimla Balwant Rai and Balwant Rai, proforma affidavits and indemnity bonds from all the three legal heirs and no objection certificate from the land owners. It was further stated in the letter that flat No. 301 on the third floor had been allotted to the plaintiff and possession thereof would be delivered after NDMC granted the completion/occupation certificates. It is alleged that certain changes were made in the aforesaid agreement in the hand of defendant No. 2 himself whereby carpet area of 900 sq. ft. was raised to 1100 sq. ft. Plaintiff on behalf of himself and his said brother and sister kept on pursuing the defendants 1 to 3 to hand over possession of flat No. 301 for which full consideration was already paid but they kept on evading the issue on one pretext or the other. In the meanwhile plaintiff submitted the death certificates of his mother and father, his indeminity bond and affidavit as demanded in the said letter dated 21st December, 1992. on the date of the filing of the suit indemnify bonds and affidavits of the brother and sister of the plaintiff have been despatched to defendant No. 1. It is further alleged that the plaintiff got a legal notice dated 8th May, 1995 served on defendant No. 1 calling upon it to hand over possession of flat No. 301 within a fortnight of the receipt of the notice. Plaintiff thereafter got yet another legal notice dated 29th May,1996 served on the defendants. It is stated
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.