SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

1980 Supreme(Del) 144

High Court Of Delhi
A. B. Rohtagi, J.
SHER SINGH GUPTA - Appellant
Versus
PREM CHAND - Respondent
SECOND APPEAL 42 of 1980
Decided On : 05/08/1980

Subject

Rent Control - NON-PAYMENT OF RENT

Headnote

Dehli Rent Connrol Act, 1958 - Sub-section 14 (1) (a) and 15 (7) cheque is not a legal tender payment by cheque is a conditional payment. A creditor is not bound to accept it. But if he accepts and the cheque is honoured it will be an effective discharge of the debt. On its encashment the tenant will be deemed to have paid or deposited the amount on the date on which the cheque was handed over.

       Without striking out the defense it is not possible to order eviction on the ground of non-payment of rent.

Advocates Appeared:
M.L.BHARGAV, R.K.AGARWAL

Avadh Bihari Rohatgi J.

( 1 ) THIS is an appeal from the order of the Rent Control Tribunal, dated 27th September, 1979.

( 2 ) THE appellant Sher Singh Gupta was a tenant of the ground floor of house No. 11311/1 situated on plot No. 23, Block No. 14-A, W. E. A. Karol Bagh, New Delhi. He took these premises on rent on 7th September, 1949 from Roshan Lal. Roshan Lal was at that time managing this property. On Bhagwat Sarup claimed that he was the owner of the property. Between Roshan Lal and Bhagwat Sarup litigation ensued. Finally the High Court held that Bhagwat Sarup was the owner. The appeal of Roshan Lal to the Supreme Court was dismissed. Therefore, the appellant became the tenant of Bhagwat Sarup.

( 3 ) BHAGWAT Sarup launched ejectment proceedings against the tenant under the Delhi and Ajmer Rent Control Act, 1952. The subordinate judge in the suit for ejectment made an order of eviction. On appeal the Additional District Judge set aside the order of eviction. But the tenant was not satisfied. He preferred a revision in the High Court. On 17th September, 1969 the revision petition filed by the tenant was dismissed. S. N. Andley J. held that there exists a relationship of landlord and tenant between Gupta and Bhagwat Sarup. This was one finding. The other finding was that the agreed rate of rent was Rs. 67. 50 per month. This judgment set the controversy finally at rest as regards the relationship of landlord and tenant and the rate of rent. This judgment operates as resjudicata between the parties.

( 4 ) ON 20th February, 1967 the respondents, Prem Chand and Yashpal, sons of Bhagwat Sarup (Bhagwat Sarup had died in the meanwhile) brought anpplication for ejectment against the tenant under Section 14 of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958. Three grounds of ejectment were alleged. One was non-payment of rent. The second was that the premises were required by the landlords and that they had no other suitable accomodation. By a subsequent amendment a third ground of second default in the payment of rent was added. But counsel for the landlords state that they do not press the ground of second default before me. I am therefore concerned only with two questions. One is whether the tenant is liable to ejectment on the ground of non-payment of rent. Second whether he is liable to ejectment on the ground that the premises are bonafide required by the landlords for themselves and their faimly.

( 5 ) THE Additional Controller by order dated 20th July, 1976 ordered the eviction of the tenant. He held that the tenant was liable to eviction on the ground of non-payment of rent under Section 14 (1) (e) of the Act. On the ground of personal requirement he dismissed the case of the landlords. Both parties went to the tribunal. The tenant appealed. The landlords crossobjected. Both failed. The tribunal held that the tenant was liable to eviction on the ground of non-payment of rent. He dismissed the appeal of the tenant. He also found that the landlords did not require the premises for their own use and that the accomodation of the four room set which was already in their possession was reasonably suitable for their residence. So he dismissed the ground of bona fide requirement which was taken by the landlords in cross-objections. From the decision of the Tribunal the tenant has filed the present appeal. The landlords have again filed cross-objections on the ground that the premises are required bonafide for themselves and the members of their family dependent on them.

( 6 ) FIRST I take up the appeal of the tenant. Before the application for ejectment was filed in February, 1967 a notice of demand dated 15th, October, 1966 was served on the tenant. In this notice the tenant was required to pay arrears of rent from March 1, 1964, to 31st December, 1966 at the rate of Rs. 67. 50 per month. As regards the period preceding this, namely, from 1st August, 1959 to 29th February, 1964 a sum of Rs. 12. 50 per month was demanded being the balance of






























1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top