2013 Supreme(Del) 1627
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
S. MURALIDHAR, J.
TELEFONAKTIEBOLAGET LM ERICSSON (PUBL) - Plaintiff
versus
MERCURY ELECTRONICS & ANR - Defendants
CS (OS) No. 442 of 2013
Decision on: December 6, 2013
Act Referred
INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS IMPORTED GOODS ENFORCEMENT RULES : .
MEDIATION AND CONCILIATION RULES : R.20(c)
Headnote
Section 151 CPC - Application for permission to file affidavits and claim chart mapping in a sealed envelope - Summary of the acts and sections referenced and discussed by the court: The court discussed Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure 1908 (‘CPC’) and the requirements for filing affidavits and claim chart mapping in a patent infringement case. The court also referred to the European Telecommunications Standards Institute (‘ETSI’) standards and the Unified Access Services Licence (‘UASL’) agreement, which mandate compliance with internationally accredited agency standards for telecom equipment.
Fact of the Case:
The Plaintiff, Ericsson, filed an application seeking permission to file affidavits and claim chart mapping in a sealed envelope in a patent infringement case against Mercury Electronics and Micromax Informatics Limited. The Defendants were accused of infringing Ericsson’s patents related to AMR, 3G, and EDGE technology.
Finding of the Court:
The Court allowed Ericsson to file the affidavit and claim chart mapping, emphasizing that the documents were based on the material already on record. The Court also clarified that the order did not express an opinion on the merits of the contentions of either party and reserved the Defendants' right to challenge the documents at the appropriate stage of the suit.
Issues: The main issue was whether Ericsson's plaint, along with the documents filed, met the requirement of construing the claims under the suit patents and explaining how the ETSI standard was achieved using the suit patents.
Ratio Decidendi: The Court held that the plaint, along with the documents filed, satisfied the requirement of explaining the claims under the suit patents and how the ETSI standard was achieved using the suit patents. It permitted Ericsson to file the affidavit and claim chart mapping, emphasizing that the documents were based on the material already on record.
Final Decision: The application was disposed of with the permission granted to Ericsson to file the affidavit and claim chart mapping in a sealed envelope, with the clarification that the order did not express an opinion on the merits of the contentions of either party and reserved the Defendants' right to challenge the documents at the appropriate stage of the suit.
Mr. T.R. Andhyarujina, Mr. C.S. Vaidyanathan and Mr. Neeraj Kishan Kaul, Senior Advocates with Ms. Pratibha M. Singh, Ms. Saya Choudhary Kapur, Ms. Archana Sahdeva, Mr. Ashutosh Kumar and Mr. Prashant Kumar, Advocates.
Mr. Amit Sibal with Mr. Sunil Dalal, Mr. A.J. Sai Deepak, Mr. Maanav Kumar, Mr. Aditya Kutty, Mr. Rajiv Choudhary, Advocate for D-2.
IA No. 15542 of 2013 (u/S 151 CPC)
1. This is an application under Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure 1908 (‘CPC’) filed by the Plaintiff, Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson (Publ) [‘Ericsson’], seeking permission to file affidavits of Mr. Harish Sharma and Mr. Max Olofsson along with the claim chart mapping in a sealed envelope. The further prayers are that the said affidavits and the claim chart mapping should be kept in a safe custody and to only permit joint inspection of the documents by the parties and their counsel.
2. The background to this application is that the aforementioned suit has been filed by Ericsson against Mercury Electronics (Defendant No. 1) (‘Mercury’) and Micromax Informatics Limited (Defendant No. 2) (‘Micromax’) seeking permanent injunction to restrain the Defendants from manufacturing, importing, selling, offering for sale, advertising products which include telephone instruments, mobile handsets, tablets, handheld devices etc. as well as the models mentioned in Annexure A to the plaint and any future or other devices or models, which include the Adaptive Multi-Rate (‘AMR’), 3G and EDGE technology/devices/ apparatus as patented by Ericsson in the suit patents so as to result in infringement of the said suit patents. Ericsson has also prayed for a decree of damages in the sum of Rs. 100 crores against Micromax and a direction to Micromax to render sales accounts for the years 2008-2012 for the mobile devices (Handsets, tablets etc.) that incorporated the Plaintiff’s patented technology. Ericsson further seeks delivery up of infringing components/elements etc. from Mercury and Micromax.
3. Ericsson states that it is the owner of a huge portfolio of patents especially in 2G and 3G technologies and this has led to compatibility and uniformity of standards across the world. Ericsson claims that there are more than 100 licensees who pay royalty for the use of its patents. As per the Ericsson’s assessment, it holds 1/3rd of the patents essential for 2G technology (standards) and 25% of the patents essential for 3G technology (standards).
4. As far as the present suit is concerned, Ericsson is seeking permanent injunction to restrain Mercury and Micromax from infringing the following Indian patents owned by it:
* AMR Patents:
-IN203034
-IN203036
-IN234157
-IN203686
-IN213723
* 3G Patents:
-IN229632
-IN240471
* EDGE Patent:
-IN241747
5. Para 17 of the plaint contains the titles of the AMR patents, 3G patents and EDGE patents. Para 18 of the plaint states that all the suit patents are essential patents as they correspond to the standards issued by the European Telecommunications Standards Institute (‘ETSI’) related to 2G and 3G technologies. It is stated that the Department of Telecommunications (‘DoT’) has recognized ETSI standards as approved for GSM, WCDMA/UMTS network and equipment providers. Ericsson refers to the clauses of the Unified Access Services Licence (‘UASL’) agreement, which every telecom service providers enters into with the DoT, which mandate that the subscriber terminals employed in the network shall be of a type/model certified by an internationally accredited agency which includes ETSI and that only such category of a subscriber unit as has been granted such a certificate shall be brought into and operated within India under the Agreement. In para 19, a reference has been made to a letter dated 3rd October 2008 issued by the Wireless Planning & Coordination Wing, Ministry of Communication & Information Technology, DoT which has also adopted ETSI and other international standards for GSM/WCDMA network equipment. Consequently, mobile devices like handsets, tablets etc., which are imported into India, require to be compliant with standards issued by ETSI and other internationally accredited agencies. The relevant portion of the letter states as under:
“I am directed to state that while issuing import license in respect of GSM/CDMA network equipment, Clause 2.2 (d) (i) of UASL Agreement shal