SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2015 Supreme(Del) 1014

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
RAJIV SHAKDHER, J.
U.N. Bachawat (Rtd. Justice) & Another – Petitioners
Versus
Chief Post Master General & Others – Respondents
W.P. (C) No. 3712 of 2015
Decided On : 30.6.2015

Subject

Banking and Finance Law - Nomination and Succession

Act Referred

CONSTITUTION OF INDIA : Art.226
GOVERNMENT SAVINGS BANKS ACT : S.4, S.5
LIFE INSURANCE ACT : S.391, S.39
MARRIED WOMENS PROPERTY ACT : S.6
SENIOR CITIZENS SAVINGS SCHEME RULES : R.6

Headnote

Senior Citizens Savings Scheme Rules, 2004 - Rule 6 - Government Savings Bank Act, 1873 - Section 4, 5 - Life Insurance Act, 1938 - Section 391 - Money deposited - Death of Deceased - Claim by heir - Scope of - Money deposited by deceased - Claim of Petitioner no.1 has been denied - Respondent no.3 held that amount can only be claimed by her nominee/petitioner no.2 - Receipt of money by the nominee, after the death of the person who maintained the account would discharge the liability of the concerned post office - It will not oust the right of those who are beneficiaries of the sums as deposited, whether under the law of succession or otherwise - Nominee retains the money for the benefit of those persons who are entitled to it either by virtue of a testament, such as a Will and / or on account of law of survivorship as in the case of intestate succession - Held, petitioners are right in saying that the moneys lying credited in the aforementioned accounts should be paid in accordance with the request made in the two communications, both of which, are dated 23.01.2012.

Advocate Appeared:
For the Petitioner:Mr. P.D. Gupta, Mr. R.K. Seewal, Mr. G.C. Rawal and Mr. V.K. Gupta, Advocates.
For the Respondents:Mr. Prasanta Varma, Mr. Sushil Kumar Pandey and Ms. Pratibha Varma, Advocates.

JUDGMENT

RAJIV SHAKDHER, J.

1. Petitioner no. 1 has approached the court with the instant petition to lay claim to the money lying deposited in two accounts opened by his late wife Ms Vimala Devi Bachawat with the Alaknanda Post Office, New Delhi, represented by Respondent no. 3. Petitioner no. 1 claim is based on a will dated 15.01.2008, executed by late Ms. Vimala Devi Bachawat, in his favour.

1.1 Respondent no. 3, however, has refused to entertain the claim based on an opinion received from its head office at Kalkaji i.e. respondent no. 2, to the effect, that the money lying deposited in the two accounts of Ms Vimala Devi Bachawat can only be claimed by her nominee i.e. petitioner no. 2.

1.2 The reasoning advanced by respondent no. 2 appears to be that the will executed in favour of petitioner no. 1 cannot supersede the nomination made by the deceased in favour of petitioner no. 2. The rejection of petitioner no. 1 request made vide application dated 23/31.01.2012 was communicated via a letter dated 07.03.2012, issued by respondent no. 2.

2. Therefore, the only question which arises for consideration is as to whether petitioner no. 1 can lay claim to the money lying in the two accounts maintained by his deceased wife with respondent no. 2, on the basis of the will dated 15.01.2008?

3. Before I proceed further, it may be useful to detail out certain broad facts which have led to the filing of the present petition.

3.1 Late Ms Vimala Devi Bachawat opened a Savings Bank (SB) account bearing no. 1142281 and a Senior Citizens’ Saving Scheme (SCSS) account bearing no. 100964. The initial deposit made in the SB account was a sum of Rs. 1000/- whereas that, in the SCSS account was a sum of Rs. 4.50 lacs. The deposit, in the SB account, was made on 16.10.2006, while the deposit in the SCSS account, was made on 18.10.2006.

3.2 In accordance with the mandate issued and as per the facility available under the rules/scheme, which governed the SCSS account, the interest accrued was, automatically, transferred to the SB account. The rules which govern the SCSS account are titled as Senior Citizens Savings Scheme Rules, 2004 (in short the 2004 Rules).

3.3 Pertinently, late Ms. Vimala Devi Bachawat, chose petitioner no. 2, who is her grand-son, as a nominee qua the aforementioned accounts.

3.4 As per the scheme/rules applicable to the SCSS account, no withdrawal could be made from the said account for a period of five (5) years. Therefore, the lock-in period, in respect of the SCSS account, could have come to an end only in October, 2011.

3.5 Unfortunately, Ms Vimala Devi Bachawat expired on 25.04.2011. It appears though, that prior to her death, she had, as indicated above, executed a will in favour of petitioner no. 1 i.e. her husband. By virtue of the said will, she has not only superseded her earlier will but, has also, bequeathed, all her movable and immovable assets to petitioner no. 1, which includes specifically the proceeds lying deposited in the two accounts referred to above with the Alaknanda Post Office, New Delhi i.e. respondent no. 3.

3.6 The factum of, the death of late Ms Vimala Devi Bachawat was communicated by petitioner no. 2 to respondent no. 2 vide communication dated 23.01.2012. In the said communication petitioner no.2 clearly stated that with the execution of the will dated 15.01.2008, petitioner no. 1 had become the sole beneficiary of the estate of the deceased, “inspite of any nomination” made in that behalf. A specific request was made that a cheque for the amount standing to the credit of the deceased, along with accrued interest, be issued in favour of petitioner no.1. The letter was accompanied by the following documents:

(i) Duly filled in Claim Form.

(ii) Annexure I (Letter of Indemnity).

(iii) Annexure II (Affidavit).

(iv) Annexure III (Letter of Disclaimer on Affidavit).

(v) Copy of Death Certificate of Ms Vimala Devi Bachawat.

(vi) Copy of Will dated 15.01.2008 of Ms Vimala Devi Bachawat.

(vii) Passbook






































































1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top