SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2012 Supreme(Del) 2970

DELHI HIGH COURT
Veena Birbal, J.
Raj Singh - Appellant
Versus
Pushpa Aggarwal & Anr. - Resopndent
FAO 400/2012
Decided On : 12-09-2012

Important Points

For seeking an interim injunction, the plaintiff must establish a prima facie case, balance of convenience, and irreparable loss. Delay in filing the suit and raising allegations after a significant period may raise doubts about the credibility of the claim.

Subject

Civil Law - Interim Injunction

Act Referred

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE : S.151, O.39 R.1, O.39 R.2

Headnote

Interim Injunction - Sale Deed - Order 39 Rule 1 and 2, Section 151 CPC - [Order 39 Rule 1 and 2, Section 151 CPC] - The court dismissed the application for the grant of interim injunction, considering the appellant's failure to establish a prima facie case and balance of convenience in his favor. The court found that the appellant's delay in filing the suit and alleging that the sale deed was executed under the influence of liquor after more than three years raised doubts about the credibility of the claim.

Fact of the Case:

The appellant filed a suit for declaration/cancellation of a sale deed and permanent injunction against the respondent, alleging that the sale deed was executed under the influence of liquor and without consideration. The trial court dismissed the application for interim injunction, and the appellant appealed against this decision.

Finding of the Court:

The court found that the appellant failed to establish a prima facie case and balance of convenience in his favor, especially considering the delay in filing the suit and the timing of the allegations regarding the influence of liquor on the sale deed.

Issues: Validity of the sale deed, Allegations of execution under the influence of liquor, Grant of interim injunction

Ratio Decidendi: The court held that for seeking an interim injunction, the plaintiff is required to show a prima facie case, balance of convenience, and irreparable loss. The delay in filing the suit and alleging influence of liquor after more than three years raised doubts about the credibility of the claim.

Final Decision: The appeal against the dismissal of the application for interim injunction was dismissed, and the court clarified that the decision had no bearing on the merits of the case.

Through :Mr. R.S. Tomar, Mr. Sumit Tomar, Advocates
Through : None

JUDGMENT :

Veena Birbal, J.


CM No. 15992/2012 (exemption)

Exemption as prayed is allowed, subject to just exceptions.

Application stands disposed of.

FAO No. 400/2012

1. Present is an appeal against impugned order dated 03.08.2012 passed by learned ADJ (North-West), Delhi whereby the application of the appellant under Order 39 Rule 1 and 2 read with Section 151 CPC for the grant of interim injunction thereby restraining the respondents from selling/transferring or creating any third party interest in the suit property i.e. land measuring 13 Bighas 14 Biswas situated in the Revenue Estate of village Nizampur, Delhi which was subject matter of sale deed dated 17.09.2003, has been dismissed.

2. The appellant herein i.e. plaintiff before the learned trial court has filed a suit for declaration/cancellation of sale deed dated 17.02.2003 and permanent injunction against the respondent/defendant alleging therein that the appellant/plaintiff is a permanent resident of village Nizampur and in all he has got 42 Bighas 15 Biswas of land. It is alleged that appellant came in contact with one Tara Chand who is the husband of respondent no. 1 and father of respondent no. 2 in the house of his friend Raghubir Singh. There they used to consume liquor together. It is further alleged that the said Tara Chand had taken the advantage of bad habit of consuming liquor of the appellant/plaintiff. It is alleged that on 17.09.2003 said Tara Chand had taken the appellant to the office of Sub-Registrar wherein some documents were got signed from him. It is alleged that the appellant/plaintiff also took his pass port size photographs and his identity card and the appellant/plaintiff was also made to consume liquor on the way. It is further alleged that the respondent no. 1/defendant no. 1 had got signed a sale deed in respect of agricultural land of appellant/plaintiff measuring 13 Bighas 14 Biswas in the aforesaid land for a consideration of Rs. 12.75 lakhs in favour of his wife i.e. respondent no.1and a Special Power of Attorney was also got signed from him in favour of respondent no. 2/defendant no. 2 on the said date. It is alleged that the appellant/plaintiff had come to know of the same only on 07.11.2011 when he had received a copy of Khatoni from Halka Patwari and came to know that the land bearing khasra no.59/7 min.(2-06), 59/15 min. (1-16), 59/14 min, 59/16 min, 59/17 min and 59/25 min each measuring (2-08) has been mutated in the name of respondent no. 1/defendant no. 1 on 27.05.2004. Thereafter, the appellant/plaintiff obtained necessary documents from the said office and filed the aforesaid suit. Along with the suit an application under Order 39 Rule 1 and 2 CPC was filed seeking interim injunction against the respondents from restraining them by selling/transferring or creating third party interest in the suit property i.e. land measuring 13 Bighas 14 Biswas which was the subject matter of the sale deed.

3. Respondents had filed a written statement before the learned trial court denying the allegations made therein. The respondents/defendants have taken the stand that the suit filed by the appellant/plaintiff is time barred. It is further alleged that the sale deed was duly executed by the appellant/plaintiff in favour of the respondent no. 1/defendant no. 1 for consideration. NOC from the competent authority was also obtained. It is alleged that the appellant/plaintiff had also associated himself at the time of mutation of aforesaid property in favour of respondent no1/defendant no.1 and also signed certain necessary documents and a frivolous suit has been filed and the appellant/plaintiff is also not entitled for interim injunction as is prayed. After hearing the parties, the learned ADJ dismissed the application for the grant of interim injunction vide impugned order dated 03.08.2012.

4. Learned counsel appearing for the appellant/plaintiff has contended that the alleged sale deed dated 17.09.2002 was got executed through appellant/plaintiff in










1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top