IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
GITA MITTAL, C. HARI SHANKAR, JJ.
Arjun Prakash – Appellant
Versus
Shyam Sahani & Ors. – Respondents
FAO(OS) 210 of 2017 & CM Nos.25124, 33236 of 2017, 1097 of 2018
Decided On : 01-08-2018
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
1. This appeal, at the instance of Defendant No. 4 in CS(OS) 1134/2008, is directed against para 4 of the order, dated 26th May, 2017, and para 5 of the consequent order, dated 30th May, 2017, passed by the learned Single Judge in IA 6909/2017, filed by the Defendant No. 4 in the aforementioned civil suit.
2. The plaintiff, and Defendants 1 to 4 in CS (OS) 1134/2008, are all descendants, to a greater or lesser degree, of Niamat Sahni. Niamat Sahni had one son and daughter. The plaintiff in CS (OS) 1134/2008, who is the appellant before us, is her son Shyam Sahni. The daughter of Niamat Sahni, Usha Prakash, died before the filing of CS (OS) 1134/2008. Defendants Nos 1 to 4, in CS (OS) 1134/2008, are Usha Prakash’s husband Sarabjit Prakash, and her three sons, Sanjeev Prakash, Rajeev Prakash and Arjun Prakash, who is the appellant before us.
3. The remaining defendants in the suit are purchasers of various portions of the suit property.
4. A tabular representation depicting the status of the various parties in CS 1134/2008 may be presented thus:
Name
Status in CS(OS)1134/2008
Status in the present appeal
Relationship Status
Shyam Sahni
Plaintiff
Respondent No. 1
S/o Niamat Sahni
Sarabjit Prakash
Defendant No. 1
Deceased
H/o D/o Niamat Sahni (Usha Prakash)
Sanjeev Prakash
Defendant No. 2
Respondent No. 2
S/o Sarabjit Prakash
Rajeev Prakash
Defendant No. 3
Respondent No. 3
S/o Sarabjit Prakash
Arjun Prakash
Defendant No. 4
Appellant
S/o Sarabjit Prakash
Douglas James Breckenridge
Defendant No. 5
Respondent No. 4
Buyer from Usha Prakash
Jhilmil Saxena Breckenridge
Defendant No. 6
Respondent No. 5
Buyer from Usha Prakash
Arif Sahid Khan
Defendant No. 7
Deceased
Buyer from Usha Prakash
Anish Wig
Defendant No. 8
Respondent No. 9
Buyer from Usha Prakash
Farida Abdulla Khan
Not a party (wife of Defendant No. 7)
Respondent No. 6
W/o Arif Sahid Khan
Ali Nawaz Khan
Not a party (son of Defendant No. 7)
Respondent No. 7
W/o Arif Sahid Khan
Abid Khan
Not a party (son of Defendant No. 7)
Respondent No. 8
W/o Arif Sahid Khan
5. For ease of reference, allusion, to the various parties, would be as per their status, as plaintiffs or defendants, in CS (OS) 1134/2008.
6. Though the issue in controversy is extremely limited, it is necessary, in order to adjudicate thereon, to walk, once again, the path followed by the suit, in the proceedings before the learned Single Judge.
7. The property at No 68, Friends Colony (West), New Delhi (hereinafter referred to as “the suit property”), was constructed, by Niamat Sahni, out of her own funds and resources, on 3000 square yard freehold plot, also purchased by her. On 3rd January, 2002 a General Power of Attorney was allegedly executed, by Niamat Sahni, entitling her daughter Usha Prakash to create third party rights in respect of the suit property. On the basis thereof, Usha Prakash executed sale deeds, favouring Defendants Nos. 5 to 8, in respect of various portions of the suit property, with
(i) Sale Deed, dated 21st March, 2002, having been executed in favour of Defendant No. 4 in respect of Flat Private D on the second floor,
(ii) Sale Deed dated 7th August, 2002, in favour of Defendant Nos. 5 and 6 in respect of Flat Private A on the second floor,
(iii) Sale Deed dated 15th September, 2003, in favour of Defendant No. 7 in respect of terrace rights over Flat Private D,
(iv) Sale Deed dated 7th October, 2003, in favour of her husband, Defendant No. 1 in respect of the first floor of the suit property and
(v) Sale Deed dated 11th January, 2005, in favour of Defendant No. 4 in respect of Flat Private B.
8. Defendant No. 4 further executed Sale Deed, dated 15th September, 2003, in respect of Flat Private D in favour of Defendant No. 7.
9. On 28th April, 200
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.