2019 Supreme(Del) 1926
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
PRATHIBA M. SINGH, J.
Initiating Officer, Acit Benami Prohibition — Appellant
Versus
Appellate Tribunal Under Prohibition Of Benami Property Transactions Act, 1988 And Others — Respondent
Writ Petition (Civil) No. 9841 of 2019; Civil Miscellaneous Application No. 40695 of 2019
Decided on : 13-09-2019
Important Points
Subject
Administrative Law - Tribunals and Appellate Authorities
Act Referred
INCOME TAX ACT : S.260(a), S.260(a)(1)
PROHIBITION OF BENAMI PROPERTY TRANSACTIONS ACT : S.26, S.49, S.26(1), S.24(5), S.2(9)
Headnote
Benami Property Transactions Act - Challenge to Appellate Tribunal's order - Section 26 - Section 49 - Section 46 - The court discussed the provisions of Section 26, Section 49, and Section 46 of the Benami Property Transactions Act. It highlighted the time-bound adjudication process and the limitations on the Appellate Tribunal's jurisdiction. The court emphasized the distinction between interim orders and final orders in the context of appealability and the requirement of substantial questions of law for appeal to the High Court.
Fact of the Case:
The writ petition challenged the order of the Appellate Tribunal for Prohibition of Benami Property Transactions Act, which stayed the operation of a show-cause notice issued under Section 26(1) of the Benami Act. The petitioner sought a writ petition as the efficacious remedy, while the respondent argued for an appeal to the High Court.
Finding of the Court:
The court found that the show-cause notice did not constitute 'an order' passed by the Adjudicating Authority, raising doubts on the Appellate Tribunal's jurisdiction. It directed the Adjudicating Authority to proceed with the adjudication process in accordance with the timelines prescribed under Section 26 of the Act.
Issues: The issues involved the appealability of the show-cause notice, the jurisdiction of the Appellate Tribunal, and the appropriate remedy for challenging interim orders.
Ratio Decidendi: The court emphasized the time-bound adjudication process, the distinction between interim and final orders for appealability, and the requirement of substantial questions of law for appeal to the High Court.
Final Decision: The court issued notice to the respondents, suspended the interim order of the Appellate Tribunal, and directed the Adjudicating Authority to proceed with the adjudication process, subject to the outcome of the writ petition.
Advocate Appeared:
Raghvendra Singh, Adv., Vipul Agrawal, Adv., Rajiv Nayar, Adv., Saurabh Seth, Adv., Arshdeep Singh, Adv., Manik Dogra, Adv.
JUDGMENT :
Prathiba M. Singh, J.
CM APPL. 40696/2019 (exemption)
1. Allowed, subject to all just exceptions. Application is disposed of.
W.P.(C) 9841/2019 and CM APPL. 40695/2019
2. The present writ petition has been filed challenging the order dated 26th July, 2019 passed by the Appellate Tribunal for Prohibition of Benami Property Transactions Act ('Appellate Tribunal'). The challenge raised is that no appeal could have been filed before the Appellate Tribunal against the show-cause notice issued by the adjudicating authority under Section 26 of the Prohibition of Benami Property Transactions Act, 1988 ('Benami Act') as the said provision does not permit such an appeal challenging a show-cause notice.
3. Mr. Raghvendra Singh, ld. Sr. Standing Counsel submits that the impugned order of the Tribunal, in effect, has stopped the Adjudicating Authority from proceeding further in the matter inasmuch as the operation of the show cause notice dated 21st June, 2019 has itself been stayed.
4. On the other hand, Mr. Rajiv Nayar, ld. Sr. Counsel for Respondent No. 2, submits that he has a preliminary objection as to the maintainability of the present petition. He submits that under Section 49 of the Benami Act, an appeal against an order of the Appellate Tribunal would lie to the High Court, and not a writ petition. He relies upon the judgment in M.C. Mittal v Central Bank of India, (1996) 36 DRJ 315 (DB) to argue that the order would have to be appealed against and no writ would lie. He further submits that the issue has been substantively decided in favour of his client by a judgment in a writ petition filed by the Respondent No.2 before this Court under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 ('PMLA Act'). He further submits that the matter has reached the Supreme Court, where a status quo order has been passed.
5. In rejoinder, Mr. Raghvendra Singh, Sr. Standing Counsel submits that a writ petition is the only efficacious remedy, as under Section 49, only such appeals where substantial questions of law are raised can been entertained, and in the present writ petition, the Petitioner is challenging an interim order of the Appellate Tribunal, which would not be appealable under Section 49. He relies upon a judgment rendered in Rajesh Agarwal HUF Vs. CIT, Ghaziabad, 2014 51 Taxmann.com 26 (Allahabad).
6. The issues raised in the present writ petition would require adjudication by this Court. The judgment of this Court dated 9th April, 2015 in CRL. M.C. 5508/2014 arose out of a petition under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure against proceedings initiated under the PMLA Act.
7. The present show-cause notice dated 21st June 2019, has been issued under Section 26(1) of the Benami Act. Vide the said notice, Respondent No. 2 and 3 have been directed to file their replies along with documents and evidence. The operative portion of the show cause notice reads as under:-
"NOTICE TO SHOW CAUSE UNDER SECTION 26(1)
"Whereas initiating officer has passed an order under section 24(4) in respect of properties indicated in the said order. He has provisionally attached properties under THE PROHIBITION OF BENAMI PROPERTY TRASACTIONS ACT 1988 and has made reference under section 24(5) of the said Act for confirmation of the said Provisional Attachment Order.
I.O. has held the properties to be Benami Properties Involved in benami transactions within the meaning of section 2(9) of THE PROHIBITION OF BENAMI PROPERTY TRASACTIONS ACT 1988.
You are hereby called upon to furnish such Documents, particulars or evidences/as is considered necessary to prove your claim that the property is not Benami property under the Act and is not covered by/Involved in the benami transactions within the meaning of section 2(9) of the Act.
You are given this show cause notice to explain as to why all or any of such properties should not be declared to be Benami Properties involved in benami transactions under THE PROHIBITION OF BENAMI PROPERTY TRASACTIONS ACT 1988, and why th