SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2006 (2) CPR 124
CHHATTISGARH STATE CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION, RAIPUR
V.K. Agarwal, President; Smt. Veena Misra and R.S. Awasthi, Members
Ajimuddin—Appellant
versus
The New India Insurance Co. Ltd.—Respondent
Appeal No. 168/2005
Decided on 10-4-2006

Important Points

IMPORTANT POINT
As GIC has recommended settlement of accident claim of the transferee owner notwithstanding the fact that the policy was not got transferred by him in his favour, the insurance co. has no valid ground to repudiate claim on ground of non-transfer of policy.

Subject

Insurance Law - Motor Insurance

Act Referred

CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT : S.15

Headnote

Consumer Protection Act, 1986 — Section 15 — Appeal against repudiation of complaint by D.F. — Insurance Company repudiated claim on ground that complainant did not get policy transferred in his favour — GIC having issued circular to settle claim irrespective of policy being not transferred — Appeal allowed.

       Held: In view of the above it is clear that GIC has recommended settlement of claim of the transferee owner notwithstanding the fact that the policy was not got transferred by him in his favour. This being so, it is clear that the complainant/appellant was entitled to the benefit under the policy, Accordingly, his claim deserves to be settled in accordance with the said instructions of the Tariff Advisory Committee. Consequently it appears that repudiation of the claim of the complainant/appellant by the respondent/insurer was not justified. Accordingly, the complainant is entitled to get compensation under the policy.(Para 8)

       Since the surveyor has assessed the loss due to damage to the vehicle at Rs.44,353/- (rounded to Rs 44,500/-), we consider it just and proper to award compensation to the above extent.(Para 9)

       Result : Appeal allowed.

Advocates:
Counsel for the parties:
For the Appellant :Sri Ashutosh Singh, Advocate.
For the Respondent:Shri P.K. Paul, Advocate.

ORDER

V.K. Agarwal, President — This appeal under section 15 of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986, is directed against the order Dt. 15.03,2005 in complaint No. 221/2004 by District Consumer Disputes Redressal Forum Raipur (hereinafter called the “District Forum” for short) dismissing the complaint.

2. Indisputably, the complainants truck No.C.G.-15-1110 was comprehensively insured by the respondent insurer covering the risk thereof from 16.4.2002 to 15.04.2003. It is also not in dispute that during the currency of the said policy, the said vehicle met with an accident on 09.03.2003 and got damaged. Intimation was given by the complainant/appellant to the respondent/insurer upon which the latter appointed surveyor to conduct spot survey. The final surveyor Shri S.K Sharma was also appointed, who as per his report dt. 30.5.2003 assessed the loss to the truck at Rs, 44,353/-. It is further not in dispute that respondent insurer repudiated the claim of the complainant/appellant by their letter Dt. 27.2.2004 on the ground that the complainant/appellant did not have insurable interest inasmuch as the said policy was obtained by Devendra Singh from whom the complainant/appellant purchased the vehicle, but had failed to get the policy transferred in his name.

3. The complainant/ appellant felt aggrieved by the repudiation of his claim, and approached the District Forum, where he filed the complaint.

4. The complaint was resisted by the insurer mainly on the ground that the insurance policy was issued in favour of the original owner Devendra Singh and though complainant purchased the truck, he did not intimate the transfer of the vehicle in his favour by Devendra Singh and thus had no insurable interest therein.

5. The ground as above for repudiation of the complainants claim found favour with District Forum, which held that as there was no agreement between the parties inasmuch as the complainant had not got his name recorded in the policy, he was not entitled to benefit under the policy.

6. Learned counsel for the parties were heard and record perused.

7. Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that GIC has issued specific instructions regarding settlement of claim in case of transfer of policy. It was submitted that as per the said instructions the transfer of policy in favour of the purchaser the complainant/appellant should be treated as automatic. It appears that the Tariff Advisory Committee issued a circular regarding automatic transfer of the policy to the new owner/purchaser of the vehicle. In the said circular the decision of Supreme Court in Complete Insulations (P) Ltd. v. New India Assurance Co. Ltd.1 was referred to. In the said circular it was stated that for policies issued as per revised Motor Tariff, own damage claim which fall within the purview of GR 10 provisions may be settled in full subject to the other terms and conditions of the policy.

8. In view of the above it is clear that GIC has recommended settlement of claim of the transferee owner notwithstanding the fact that the policy was not got transferred by him in his favour. This being so, it is clear that the complainant/appellant was entitled to the benefit under the policy. Accordingly, his claim deserves to be settled in accordance with the said instructions of the Tariff Advisory Committee. Consequently it appears that repudiation of the claim of the complainant/appellant by the respondent/insurer was not justified. Accordingly, the complainant is entitled to get compensation under the policy.

9. Since the surveyor has assessed the loss due to damage to the vehicle at Rs.44,353/- (rounded to Rs 44,500/-), we consider it just and proper to award compensation to the above extent.

10. Accordingly, this appeal is allowed. The impugned order dismissing the complaint is set aside. It is directed that the respondent/insurer shall pay to the complainant/appellant a sum of Rs. 44,500/- (Rupees forty four thousand five hundered only) with interest payable thereon @ 9%








1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top