SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

NATIONAL CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION, NEW DELHI
K. S. Chaudhari, Presiding Member
Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., Through:
Chief Manager —Petitioner
versus
Mushtaq Khan & Anr. —Respondents
Revision Petition No.3618 of 2013
(From the order dated 03.07.2013 in Appeal No.2170 of 2011 of the U. P. State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Lucknow )
Decided on 21.11.2014

Important Points

IMPORTANT POINT
Complainant is not entitled to any claim regarding damages when neither registration certificate nor insurance policy was transferred in name of complainant.

Subject

Insurance Law - Motor Insurance

Act Referred

CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT : S.15, S.17, S.19, S.21

Headnote

Consumer Protection Act, 1986—Sections 15 , 17 , 19 and 21—Insurance—Total loss of vehicle in accident—After purchase of old vehicle by complainant, vehicle continued in name of seller and neither registration certificate nor insurance policy was transferred in name of complainant till accident—Complainant was not entitled to any claim regarding damages to vehicle and petitioner has not committed any deficiency in repudiating claim—District Forum committed error in allowing complaint and State Commission further committed error in dismissing appeal—Impugned orders set aside and complaint dismissed. (Paras 6 to 8)

       Result: Revision Petition allowed.

       

Counsel for the Parties:
For the Petitioner:Mr. Kishore Rawat & Mr. Mayank Sharma, Advocates.
For the Respondent No.1:Mr. Pankaj Kr. Singh, Advocate.
For the Respondent No.2:Mr. R. Narayanan, Advocate.

ORDER

K. S. Chaudhari, Presiding Member—This revision petition has been filed by the petitioner against the order dated 03.07.2013 passed by the U. P. State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Lucknow (in short, ‘the State Commission’) in Appeal No.2170 of 2011 – Oriental Ins. Co. Ltd. Vs. Mushtaq Khan & Anr. by which, while dismissing appeal, order of District Forum allowing complaint was upheld.

2. Brief facts of the case are that vehicle registered in the name of Smt. Malti Devi was sold by OP No.1/Respondent No.2 which was insured with OP No.2/petitioner for a period of one year for a sum of Rs.3,64,500/-. On account of non-payment of installments by the owner, vehicle was possessed by OP No.1 and sold to the complainant, but vehicle was not transferred in the name of complainant due to carelessness of OP No.1. On 4.1.2008, vehicle was damaged in accident. Intimation was given to OP No.2, who appointed surveyor. Estimate of repair was about Rs.6,62,869/- and in such circumstances, vehicle fell under the category of total loss. Complainant lodged complaint before OP, but payment was not made. Alleging deficiency on the part of OP, complainant filed complaint before District forum. OP No.1 resisted complaint and submitted that transfer of vehicle after sale was responsibility of purchaser and after sale of vehicle; OP had no concern with the complainant and prayed for dismissal of complaint. OP No.2 & 3 did not appear before District forum and they were proceeded exparte. Learned District Forum after hearing the parties allowed complaint and directed OP No.2 & 3 to pay Rs.3,64,500/- with 9% p. a. interest and further awarded Rs.1,000/- as litigation expenses. Appeal filed by OP was dismissed by learned State Commission vide impugned order against which, this revision petition has been filed along with application for condonation of delay.

3. Heard learned Counsel for the petitioner finally at admission stage and perused record.

4. As there is delay of only 3 days in filing revision petition, delay is condoned.

5. Learned Counsel for the petitioner submitted that as neither vehicle nor policy was transferred in the name of complainant, petitioner rightly repudiated claim, but leaned District Forum committed error in allowing complaint and learned State Commission further committed error in dismissing appeal; hence, revision petition be allowed and impugned order be set aside. On the other hand, learned Counsel for the Respondent No.1 submitted that order passed by leaned State Commission is in accordance with law; hence, revision petition be dismissed.

6. It is admitted case of the parties that after purchase of old vehicle by the complainant, on 7.11.2007 vehicle continued in the name of seller and neither registration certificate nor insurance policy was transferred in the name of complainant till accident on 4.1.2008.

7. Learned Counsel for the petitioner submitted that as vehicle as well as insurance policy not transferred in the name of complainant at the time of accident, petitioner was not liable to make any payment towards claim. In support of his contention he has placed reliance on judgment delivered by me reported in Sandeep Gupta Vs. United India Insurance Co. Ltd. & Anr., I (2014) CPJ 493 (NC) in which it was held that if transferee fails to inform Insurance Co. about transfer of registration certificate in his name and policy is not transferred in his name, Insurance Company cannot be held liable to pay claim in case of own damage of vehicle. Same view has been taken by me in New India Assurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Ashok Thakur, I (2014) CPJ 128 (NC). Learned Counsel for the respondent placed reliance on judgment of this Commission in Shri Narayan Singh Vs. New India Assurance Co. Ltd, IV (2007) CPJ 289 (NC) on which State Commission has also placed reliance in which it was observed that benefits under policy automatically accrue to new owner on transfer of vehicle. In the aforesaid case, accident occurred on 2.8.1








1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top