SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

NATIONAL CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION
Ajit Bharihoke, P.M. and Rekha Gupta, Member
MOHAMMAD ISHAKBHAI TIMBIWALA GULISTAN SOCIETY - Appellant
Versus
TATA AIG GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED - Respondent
Revision Petition No. 4540 of 2013(Against the Order dated 14.08.2013 in Appeal No. 3332 of 2012 of the State Commission Gujarat)
Decided on : 11-09-2015

Important Points

Failure to transfer the insurance policy within the stipulated period can result in the repudiation of an insurance claim, as there is no privity of contract between the parties without the transfer.

Subject

Insurance Law - Insurance Claim Disputes

Act Referred

CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT : S.2(1)(g), S.21(b)
MOTOR VEHICLES ACT : S.157(2)

Headnote

Insurance Claim - Transfer of Vehicle Ownership - Section 157 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, GR 17 of Indian Motor Tariff - Section 157, GR 17

Fact of the Case:

The petitioner purchased a truck with an insurance policy, but the insurance claim was repudiated by the respondent insurance company on the ground that the policy was not transferred to the petitioner's name within 14 days of the transfer of ownership.

Finding of the Court:

The State Commission dismissed the complaint, stating that there was no privity of contract between the parties due to the failure to transfer the insurance policy in the petitioner's name within the stipulated period.

Issues: The main issue was whether the insurance claim could be repudiated based on the failure to transfer the insurance policy within 14 days of the transfer of ownership.

Ratio Decidendi: The court held that as per Section 157 (2) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 and GR 17 of the Indian Motor Tariff, the petitioner was required to apply for the transfer of the insurance policy within 14 days of the transfer of the vehicle, regardless of any damage occurring during that period.

Final Decision: The revision petition was dismissed, affirming the State Commission's decision to dismiss the complaint.

Advocates Appeared:
Sagar Pathan, Advocate, for the Appellant; Anjali Bansal, Advocate, for the Respondent

ORDER

Justice Ajit Bharihoke, Presiding Member - This revision is directed against the order of the State Commission Gujarat dated 14.08.2013 in Appeal No. 332/12 whereby the State Commission allowed the appeal of the respondent insurance company, set aside the order of the District Forum Godhra and dismissed the complaint.

2. Briefly stated the facts relevant for the disposal of the revision petition are that Shri Kanubhai Bariya being the registered owner of truck no. GJ-17-Y-2112 purchased an insurance policy for the said truck from the respondent opposite party on declared IDV of Rs. 4,53,971/-. The policy was effective from 29.09.2009 till 28.09.2010.

3. That during the currency of the insurance policy, the petitioner complainant allegedly purchased the said truck from the original owner on 21.05.2010 and on the same day, he got the registration transferred in his name. The subject truck on 01.06.2010 was burnt to ashes in a fire accident. Intimation was given to the insurance company and insurance claim was submitted by the petitioner. The insurance company appointed a surveyor who conducted the survey. However on 13.08.2010 the respondent insurance company sent a repudiation letter on the ground that insurance was not got transferred by the petitioner in his name despite of transfer of registration of vehicle in his favour on 21.05.2010. Being aggrieved of the repudiation of insurance claim, the petitioner filed a consumer complaint.

4. The respondent opposite party in the written statement admitted that the truck in question was insured by virtue of a policy issued in favour of the original owner Shri Kanubhai Bariya for the period w.e.f. 29.09.2009 to 28.09.2010. The factum of fire accident resulting in loss to the truck was not denied. According to the opposite party, the insurance claim of the petitioner was rightly repudiated because the petitioner had not got the insurance policy transferred in his name and there was no privity of contract between the petitioner and the insurance company.

5. The District forum on consideration of the pleadings of the parties and the evidence was of the view that as per rules particularly GR 17, the transferee of the insured vehicle is required to intimate the transfer of vehicle to the insurance company and get the insurance transferred in his name within 14 days of the transfer of vehicle and as the accident resulting in total loss of the truck took place within 12 days of the transfer of vehicle in favour of the complainant, there was no justification on the part of the insurance company to repudiate the claim. Thus holding insurance company to be deficient in service, the District Forum allowed the complaint and ordered as under;

"It is hereby ordered to the opponent that he has to pay the amount of the Total Loss Rs. 4,57,971/- damaged to the vehicle of the complainant to the complainant with 9% simple yearly interest from the date of the rejection of the claim of the complainant i.e. 13.08.2010.

The opponent has to pay the amount of Rs. 10,000/- against the mentally and physically harassment to the complainant and also has to pay the amount of Rs. 1000/- against the expenses of this application."

6. Being aggrieved of the order of the District Forum, the respondent opposite party approached the State Commission in appeal and the State commission vide impugned order took the view that as per GR 17 after the transfer of vehicle in favour of the petitioner, the petitioner complainant was required to move an application for transfer of insurance in his name within 14 days irrespective of the loss caused to the truck in fire accident before the expiry of said period and since no such application was moved within the stipulated period of 14 days, the insurance company was justified in repudiating the claim. The State Commission thus allowed the appeal and dismissed the complaint. Being aggrieved of the dismissal of complaint, the petitioner has preferred this revision.

7. Learned Sagar Path

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top