SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

NATIONAL CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION
Ajit Bharihoke, Presiding Member and Rekha Gupta, Member
UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO. LTD. - Appellants
Versus
SURENDER KUMAR - Respondents
Revision Petition No. 2176 of 2015 (from Order dated 26.5.2015 in Appeal No. 150 of 2015 of Haryana State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Panchkula).
Decided on : 13-04-2016

Important Points

The main legal point established in the judgment is that the Insurance Company is not obligated to indemnify the subsequent purchaser for the damage caused to the vehicle unless the insurance policy is transferred in the name of the subsequent purchaser.

Subject

Insurance Law - Motor Vehicles Act

Act Referred

CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT : S.2(1)(g), S.21(b)

Headnote

Insurance - Motor Vehicles Act - Section 157 - GR17 of Indian Motor Tariff Regulations - The court discussed the applicability of Section 157 of the Motor Vehicles Act and GR17 of Indian Motor Tariff Regulations in the context of transfer of insurance policy in case of sale of the vehicle. The court highlighted the legal provisions and their interpretations, emphasizing that the Insurance Company is not obligated to indemnify the subsequent purchaser for the damage caused to the vehicle unless the insurance policy is transferred in the name of the subsequent purchaser.

Fact of the Case:

The respondent filed a consumer complaint alleging that his insured vehicle was stolen and the insurance claim was repudiated by the petitioner Insurance Company. The District Forum allowed the complaint and directed the petitioner to pay the insured amount of the vehicle along with interest, litigation charges, and to transfer the R.C. The State Commission upheld the decision, leading to the filing of the revision petition.

Finding of the Court:

The court found that the Fora below had allowed the complaint based on an incorrect appreciation of Section 157(2) of the Motor Vehicles Act and GR17 of Indian Motor Tariff Regulations. The court concluded that the impugned orders of the Fora below were not sustainable and allowed the revision petition, setting aside the impugned orders and dismissing the complaint.

Issues: The key issue was whether the benefit of deemed transfer of insurance policy along with the transfer of the vehicle in favor of the purchaser is available to the subsequent purchaser, especially in the case of 'Own Damage' claim.

Ratio Decidendi: The court held that the Insurance Company is not obligated to indemnify the subsequent purchaser for the damage caused to the vehicle unless the subsequent purchaser has got the insurance policy transferred in his name. The court emphasized the requirements of Section 157 of the Motor Vehicles Act and GR17 of Indian Motor Tariff Regulations in relation to the transfer of insurance policy in case of sale of the vehicle.

Final Decision: The court allowed the revision petition, set aside the impugned orders, and dismissed the complaint.

Advocates Appeared:
Mr. V.S. Chopra, Advocate, for the Petitioner; Mr. C.M. Sharma, Advocate with Respondent in person, for the Respondent

ORDER

Mr. Justice Ajit Bharihoke, Presiding Member. - This revision is directed against the order of the State Commission, Haryana dated 26.5.2015 whereby the State Commission dismissed the appeal preferred by the petitioner Insurance Company against the order of the District Forum.

2. Briefly stated, the facts relevant for the disposal of the revision petition are that respondent filed a consumer complaint in District Forum, Bhiwani alleging that he had purchased one Bolero Jeep bearing registration No. HR12-K-0440 and got the same registered in his name in the office of the Registering Authority (M.V) Charkhi Dadri. The said jeep was insured with the petitioner Insurance Company vide cover No. 901970 valid from 30.5.2011 to 29.5.2012. It is the case of the complainant that aforesaid Bolero jeep was stolen on 3.3.2012. The matter was reported to the police vide FIR No. 87 dated 4.3.2012 Police Station Goverdhan, District Mathura. The theft was also intimated to the petitioner Insurance Company. The police could not trace the vehicle. The respondent complainant, therefore, submitted the insurance claim, which was repudiated. Being aggrieved of tire repudiation of the claim, the respondent raised the consumer dispute.

3. The petitioner on being served with the notice filed a written statement alleging that respondent-complainant Surender Kumar is not a consumer. According to the opposite party, the complainant is not the insured. Actually, the subject vehicle was earlier owned by one Mukesh who had purchased the insurance policy: The complainant Surender Kumar who claims to have purchased the subject vehicle from the previous owner/insured thereof did not get the insurance policy transferred in his name. As the complainant did not have insurable interest in the subject vehicle, the Insurance Company was justified in repudiating the claim.

4. The District Forum on consideration of the pleadings and evidence allowed the complaint and directed the petitioner as under:

"1. To pay the insured amount of the vehicle in question along with interest @ 12% per annum from the date of filing of this complaint till its realization.

2. To pay Rs. 2,200 as litigation charges.

3. The complainant is directed to hand over the letter of subrogation and keys to the company and also directed to get the R.C. transferred.

The compliance of the order shall be made within 45 days from the date of receipt of certified copy of the order."

5. The petitioner being aggrieved of the order of the District Forum approached the State Commission in appeal and the State Commission while concurring with the finding of the District Forum relying on the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the matter of Mallamtna (Dead) by L.R.s. v. National Insurance Co. Ltd. & Ors., X II (2014) CPJ 9 (SC), dismissed the appeal. This has led to the filing of the revision petition.

6. Learned Counsel for the petitioner has contended that impugned orders of the Fora below are not sustainable as the orders have been passed in utter disregard of Section 157 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 as also GR 17 of the Indian Motor Tariff Regulations and the law laid down by the Supreme Court in the matter of Complete Insulation Pvt. Ltd. v. New India Assurance Co. Ltd., (1996) 1 SCC 221.

7. Learned Counsel for the respondent on the contrary has argued in support of the impugned order and submitted that Fora below have rightly allowed tire complaint in view of the judgment of the Supreme Court in the matter of Mallamma (Dead) by L.R.s. (supra).

8. The question which needs determination is whether the benefit of deemed transfer of insurance policy along with transfer of the vehicle in favour of the purchaser is available to the subsequent purchaser even in the case of "Own Damage" claim.

9. In order to appreciate the contention of the parties, it would be useful to have a look on Section 157 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 which reads as under:

"Transfer of Certificate of Insurance: (1) Where a person in w

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top