NATIONAL CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION, NEW DELHI
R.K. Agrawal, President and Dr. S.M. Kantikar, Member
Kamlesh Kumari and Anr. – Complainants
versus
M/s. Ireo Grace Realtech Private
Limited and Ors. – Opp. Parties
Consumer Case No.2170 of 2019
Decided on 27.1.2022
Consumer Protection Act, 1986 – S.21(a)(i)[Consumer Protection Act, 2019 – S.58(1)(a)(i)] – Real Estate – Services – Complaint has been filed for alleged delay in handing over possession of Flat – one-sided and unreasonable clauses in the Apartment Buyer’s Agreement – Whether the Apartment Buyers are entitled for refund of the amount deposited with Delay Compensation – All the contentions have been dealt by the Court in “Ireo Grace Realtech Pvt. Ltd. vs. Abhishek Khanna & Ors.” [Civil Appeal No. 5785 / 2019 & other connected Appeals], therefore, Opposite Party Developer is directed to pay Delay Compensation in the form of simple interest @9% p.a. on amount deposited by the Complainants for the period of delay which has occurred from 27.11.2018 till the date of offer of possession was made to the Complainants – Complaints disposed off. [Para 12].
Held: Respectfully following the principle laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of “IREO Grace Realtech Pvt. Ltd. (supra)”, the present Consumer Complaint stands disposed off in following terms:-
(i) The Complainants are directed to take possession of the Unit No. CD-A9-11-1102 which falls in Phase I of the Project, where the construction has been completed and Notice of Possession was sent on 11.06.2019 after the issuance of Occupation Certificate on 31.05.2019.
(ii) The Opposite Party Developer is directed to pay Delay Compensation in the form of simple interest @9% p.a. on amount deposited by the Complainants for the period of delay which has occurred from 27.11.2018 till the date of offer of possession was made to the Complainants.
(iii) The Opposite Party Developer shall work out the Delay Compensation after making adjustment of the outstanding charges payable by the Complainants and make payment of the Compensation to the Complainants within four weeks from today;
(iv) After adjusting the Delay Compensation, if any amount remains payable by the Complainants, then the Complainants will make the payment of the shortfall to the Opposite Party Developer within four weeks from today.
(v) The Opposite Party Developer shall deliver the possession of the Unit/Apartment No. CD-A9-11-1102 to the Complainants within eight weeks from today.
Result: Disposed off with directions.
ORDER
1. The present Consumer Complaint has been filed under Section 21(a)(i) of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 (for short “the Act”) by the Complainants, against the Opposite Party No.1 M/s. Ireo Grace Realtech Private Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Developer’), Opposite Party No. 2 Precision Realtors Private Limited, Opposite Party No.3 Blue planet Infra developers Pvt. Ltd., Opposite Party No. 4 Madeira Conbuild Private Limited and Opposite Party No. 5 M/s. Global Estate, for refunding of money as the Opposite Party Developer failed to hand-over the possession of the Flat booked by them in the Project launched by the Developer in the name and style of “The Corridor “, within stipulated period.
2. According to the Complainants, the facts of the case are that in response to the Applications invited by the Opposite Party No. 1 Developer for allotment of flats in their upcoming Project, “The Corridors” (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Project’) located at Golf Course Extension Road, Sector-67-A, Tehsil & District Gurgaon, Haryana, the Complainants booked a residential flat in the Project by paying earnest money of Rs.16,00,000/- vide receipt No. 13211580 dated 16.03.2013. The Complainants were allotted Unit No. CD-A9-11-1102 having super area of 1892.21 sq. ft. on 07.08.2013. Apartment Buyer’s Agreement (hereinafter referred as the Agreement) was executed between the Parties. As per Clause 13.3 of the Agreement, the possession of the Unit was to be handed over within a period of 42 months from the date of approval of the building plans. Clause 13.3 of the Agreement reads as under:
“Subject to Force Majeure, as defined herein and further subject to the allottee having complied with all its obligations under the terms and conditions of this Agreement and not having defaulted under any provision(s) of this Agreement including but not limited to the timely payment of all dues and charges including the total Sale Consideration, registration charges, stamp duty and other charges and also subject to the Allottee having complied with all formalities or documentation as prescribed by the Company, the Company proposes to offer the possession of the said Apartment to the Allottee within a period of 42 (Forty Two) months from the date of approval of the Building Plans and/or fulfillment of the preconditions imposed thereunder (“Commitment period”). The Allottee further agrees and understands that the Company shall additionally be entitled to a period of 180 days (“Grace period”), after the expiry of the said Commitment Period to allow for unforeseen delays beyond the reasonable control of the Company.”
3. The Complainants made payment of Rs.2,11,87,810.59/- (Rupees Two Crore Eleven Lacs Eighty Seven Thousand Eight Hundred Ten & Paisa Fifty Nine only) on different dates upto December 2016 against a total cost of Rs.2,12,45,590.76ps., as per demand of the Opposite Party Developer, despite that the Opposite Party Developer could not complete the construction work at the Project within stipulated period and failed to deliver the possession of the Unit. The Opposite Party Developer sent Notice of Possession letter on 11.06.2019. However, after visiting the site, the Complainant found the Unite in not a habitable condition. Alleging deficiency in service and Unfair Trade Practice on the part of the Opposite Party Developer, the Complainants have filed the present Complaint with following prayer:-
“a. Directing the Opposite Parties to pay/refund a sum of Rs.2,11,87,810.59/- (Rupees Two crores eleven lacs eighty seven thousand eight hundred and paisa fifty nine only), paid by the Complainant towards the Unit No. CD-A9-11-1102 (Eleventh floor), Tower-A9 in Group Housing Colony situated at Sector-67A, in the revenue Estate of Village Dhumsapur and Maidwas, Tehsil & District Gurgaon, Haryana known by the Project Name as “The Corridors’;
b. Direct the Opposite Parties to pay interest @ 18% per annum on the total amount paid by the compla
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.