1988 Supreme(Guj) 36
Gujarat High Court
Judgename :P.R.GOKULAKRISHNAN, R.J.SHAH
NARANBHAI LALLUBHAI PATEL - Appellant
Versus
B.S.OZA - Respondent
S.C.A. 3893 of 1987
Decided On : 03/07/1988
Headnote:
Petitioner wants to quash and set aside Town Planning Scheme prepared by respondent for town - Various grievances are made including mala fides on part of authority in preparing such a preliminary scheme deals with submission of preliminary scheme to Government - Deals with power of Government to sanction or refuse to sanction scheme - As per Government in respect of preliminary scheme will take action within a period of two months from date of its receipt either for sanctioning same or refusing to sanction or for making such modifications as in its opinion necessary - Visualises notification sanctioning preliminary scheme or final scheme - Such a notification has to be there for a period of one month and in certain cases it may be extended for a further period not exceeding three months at a time - Held, Counsel appearing for the petitioner brings to our notice that objections have been submitted to the State Government as early as on by the respondent of that no order has been passed; nor any hearing has been given to the party concerned - Petitioner herein is also at liberty to put his objection before the State Government - Court direct State Government to take action and issue appropriate notification as expeditiously as possible keeping in mind provisions contained - directions given by us nothing survives in this Special Civil Application and accordingly same is rejected at this stage - It is always open to petitioner to file appropriate Special Civil Application after notification in respect of preliminary scheme before it becomes part - Order may be communicated to Government at cost of petitioner – Application is rejected
( 1 ) ALL the Advocates representing the various parties herein are agreeable to dispose of this petition finally.
( 2 ) IN this Special Civil Application petitioner wants to quash and set aside the Town Planning Scheme No- 2 prepared by respondent No. 1 for the town of Unjha. Various grievances are made including mala fides on the part of the authority in preparing such a preliminary scheme. Section 64 of the Act deals with submission of preliminary scheme to the Government. Section 65 of the Act deals with the power of the Government to sanction or refuse to sanction the scheme. As per Sec. 65 (1) (a) the Government in respect of the preliminary scheme will take action within a period of two months from the date of its receipt either for sanctioning the same or refusing to sanction or for making such modifications as in its opinion necessary. Section 65 visualises notification sanctioning the preliminary scheme or the final scheme. Such a notification has to be there for a period of one month and in certain cases it may be extended for a further period not exceeding three months at a time. Section 65 (3) makes it clear that on and after the date fixed in such notification the preliminary scheme or the final scheme as the case may be shall have effect as if it were enacted in this Act.
( 3 ) READING the abovesaid provisions in the Act it is clear that a preliminary scheme subsequent to the period mentioned in the notification becomes a part of the Act itself. The petitioner herein has time enough to question such sanctioning of the preliminary scheme before it becomes a part of the enactment. As it is this Special Civil Application is premature and accordingly the same has to be rejected.
( 4 ) MR. Jani the learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner brings to our notice that objections have been submitted to the State Government as early as on 20-6-1987 by the respondent No. 2 and inspite of that no order has been passed; nor any hearing has been given to the party concerned. The petitioner herein is also at liberty to put his objection before the State Government. Section 65 (1) (a) makes it incumbent upon the State Government to come out with a notification within a period of two months from the date of the receipt of the scheme. Inspite of the fact that the preliminary scheme has been sent to the Government and the objections have been filed as early as on 20 no action has been taken by the State Government according to the learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner uptill this date. Hence we direct the State Government to take action and issue appropriate notification as expeditiously as possible keeping in mind the provisions contained in Sec. 65 of the Act. In view of the abovesaid directions given by us nothing survives in this Special Civil Application and accordingly the same is rejected at this stage. It is always open to the petitioner to file appropriate Special Civil Application after the notification in respect of the preliminary scheme before it becomes part of the Act.
( 5 ) THIS order may be communicated to the Government at the cost of the petitioner.
( 6 ) RULE is discharged with no order as to costs. Rule discharged.
.