SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

1996 Supreme(Guj) 373

Gujarat High Court
Judgename :J.N.Bhatt
Savitaben Jayantilal Shah - Appellant
Versus
Kiritkumar Bhalchandra - Respondent
C.R.A. 1078 of 1996
Decided On : 08/06/1996

Subject

Eviction - Rent Arrears and Alternative Accommodation

Act Referred

BOMBAY RENTS, HOTEL AND LODGING HOUSE RATES CONTROL ACT : S.12(3), S.13(1)

Headnote

(a) Bombay Rents Hotel & Lodging House Rates Control Act, 1947 - Sec. 12(3)(a) & (b) - Protection to tenant - Admissibility - Condition stipulated under must be fulfilled - Provision imposes restriction on the landlords right to recover possession - However if tenant neglects or fails to pay the arrears of rent within stipulated period of one month in absence of any dispute with regard standard rent or permitted increases after service of notice under Sec. 12(2) and when rent is monthly payable - Court is obliged to pass decree for possession.

       Sec. 12 of the Bombay Rent Act is a substantive section giving protection to the tenant against ejectments. It does not in positive terms create any new rights in the tenants. As such, the provisions of Sec. 12 are really restriction upon the general law to the extent it restricts the general law against the interest of the landlord. It could be safely said that the provisions of Sec. 12 afford protection to the tenant. It creates a restriction on the landlords right to recovery of possession. It imposes restrain upon a landlords desire to earn higher rent and prevent him from recovering possession of his premises just for that purpose. Obviously, therefore, the Court is debarred from passing of decree for possession in favour of the landlord so long as the tenant pays or is ready and willing to pay standard rent and permitted increases and observe the conditions laid down in Sec. 12(1).

       [Para 5]

       It is true that all the aforesaid conditions must exist. If the tenant neglects to pay the arrears of rent within the stipulated period of one month in absence of dispute of standard rent or permitted increases after the service of notice under Sec. 12(2) and when the rent is payable by month and on fulfilment of the aforesaid conditions, the court is obliged to pass the decree for possession.

       [Para 7]

       (b) Words & Phrases - `First date of hearing under Sec. 12(3)(b) under Bombay Rent Act, 1947 - Meaning of - It is the date of framing of issue if matter not heard earlier.

       It is a settled proposition of law that the date of framing of issue is the date of first hearing if the matter is not earlier heard.

       [Para 10]

       (c) Bombay Rent, Hotel & Lodging, House Rates Control Act, 1947 - Sec. 13(1)(i) - Restricted to residential premises in order to provide roof over the head of the tenant - Such right of tenant is also not lost on mere acquisition of another residence unless the factum of suitable alternative accommodation is established.

       Sec. 13(1)(1) of the Bombay Rent Act is designed to see that the tenant should not have more than one residential premises. The Legislature has rightly in its wisdom anticipated further shortage of residential premises and increasing need for such accommodation. By giving a right to the landlord to resort to the provisions of Sec. 13(1)(1), the Legislature intended that if the existing tenant vacates the premises, the same could be available to another needy person waiting in queue to have a roof over his head. It could be taken by way of judicial notice that this is a country where millions of people are struggling for suitable residential accommodation. It is in this context, the provisions of Sec. 13(1)(1) have been devised and designed. No person should be allowed to raise a plea that the tenancy rights cannot be lost merely on acquisition of or allotment of another residence. Sec. 13(1)(1) provides only in case of residential premises. The underlying purport and purpose in enacting such a healthy and wholesome provision is to see that the tenant should not stick to the premises, lock the premises or hand it over to a third person alleging his intention to return after a lapse of a number of years. If such a plea is permitted, it will defeat or frustrate the purpose and object of Sec. 13(1)(1).

       [Para 12]

Advocates Appeared: M.B.GANDHI, PRANAV G.DESAI

J. N. BHATT, J.

( 1 ) THE petitioners have challenged the judgment and decree of eviction passed by the Appellate Bench of the Small Causes Court, at Ahmedabad, in Civil Appeal no. 11/87 passed, on 26-4-96, setting aside the judgment and decree passed in HRP Suit no. 928/82, and directing the petitioner to hand over the vacant and peaceful possession of the demise premises, by filing this revision under Sec. 29 (2) of the Bombay Rents, hotels and Lodging House Rates Control Act, 1947 (Bombay Rent Act ).

( 2 ) THE respondent is the original plaintiff and landlord of the demise premise consisting of one room and kitchen situated on the ground floor of bungalow No. 50 in jitendra Park Co-operative Housing Society Limited, Narayannagar Road, Paldi, ahmedabad, who instituted the above suit for recovery of arrears of rent and vacant possession of the demise premises on the following grounds : (1) Non-payment of rent; (2) Acquisition of suitable alternative accommodation; (3) Sub-tenancy or assignment of tenancy rights; and (4) Nuisance and annoyance. The respondent is the original plaintiff who acquired bungalow No. 50 on 5-6-80, wherein, original defendant No. 1-Savitaben was a sitting tenant at the rate of Rs. 80 per month. Originally, her husband Jayantilal Shah was the tenant and after his death savitaben was accepted as tenant and she continued as tenant even after the purchase of the property by the respondent-landlord.

( 3 ) THE respondent-original-plaintiff, inter alia contended in the plaint that original defendant No. 1, Savitaben, was in arrears of rent from 5-6-80 and in spite of various demands and even a notice, no payment was made. It was also contended that defendant no. 1, Savitaben, and her son had constructed a large bungalow in Champapuri, Co-op. Housing Society Limited near Prabhudas Thakkar College, Paldi, Ahmedabad and they had gone to reside in the said bungalow. Thus, it was the contention of the plaintiff-landlord that the tenant has acquired suitable alternative accommodation. The plaintiff also pleaded that the original defendant Savitaben, has unlawfully sublet or assigned the interest of the suit premises to defendant Nos. 2 and 3. It was also the case of the plaintiff-landlord that the sub-tenants were guilty of conduct amounting to nuisance and annoyance. The defendants jointly submitted written statement Ex. 8 wherein they denied all the allegations made in the plaint. It was also contended that agreed rent of Rs. 80 per month in excessive and standard rent should be fixed. The grounds stated for eviction in the plaint are denied.

( 4 ) THE Trial Court, in view of the facts and circumstances and the pleading between the parties raised issues at Ex. 23. On examination and facts and circumstances and the evidence on record, the Trial Court dismissed the suit for possession holding that there was no case for eviction. The issue of standard rent was not pressed. However, the Trial court fixed the agreed rent of Rs. 80 per month, inclusive of all taxes per month. The refusal of decree for possession and dismissal of suit for eviction by the judgment and decree of the Trial Court dated 22-12-86 were challenged by the respondent-landlord by filing Civil Appeal No. 11/87 before the Appellate Bench of the small Causes court at Ahmedabad which came to be allowed on 26-4-96 and the judgment and decree recorded in the HRP Suit No. 928/82 came to be quashed and set aside. The petitioners herein and original defendants were directed to hand over vacant and peaceful possession of the suit premises to the plaintiff and to pay an amount of Rs. 80 per month way of mesne profit. Being aggrieved by the said judgment and decree passed in appeal, the original defendants have no validity by filing this revision invoking the aids of the provisions of Sec. 29 (2) of the Bombay Rent Act. The learned Advocate for the petitioners-original defendants has seriously criticised the judgment and decree passed by the Appellate Bench.


























1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top