HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT
C. K. BUCH, J.
MISRIKHAN DILAVARKHAN PATHAN
Versus
STATE OF GUJARAT
Special Civil Application 12386 Of 2007
Decided On : FEBRUARY 5, 2008
Registeration of Birth and Death Act, 1969 - Sections 13(3), 14, 15 and 30 - Gujarat Secondary Education Regulation, 1974 - Regulation 12(A)(6) - Gujarat Secondary Education Act, 1972 - Section 54 - Constitution of India - Article 226 - On basis of original birth certificate - In the case petitioner on direction of the Court approach Judicial Magistrate First Class (JMFC) for correction of his date of birth in School Register but same was rejected by JMFC holding that he has no jurisdiction to do so under Provision of Regulations, 1974 - Court observed that in the present case there was no dispute as to the genuineness of the date of birth in view of original certificate issued by Local Self Government, therefore on production of original certificate the JMFC ought to have complied with the direction given by Court or at least ought to have observed that there is no need to issue a formal direction - However, JMFC took a technical view and rejected the application - In fact in view of original certificate issued to petitioners by Local Self Government, there was no controversy to be decided by JMFC and he rightly refused to exercise its jurisdiction. The petitioner was, therefore, left with only remedy to seek relief through petition to the Court - Having considered the submissions advanced at Bar and the documents submitted with petition along with affidavit allowed the present petition with appropriate direction to concerned authorities for needful - Held, such inconsistency because it is the experience of the society that various authorities on different occasions demands both the certificates viz., the original birth certificate, as well as, one of the School Leaving Certificates where the student has studied, because such certificates contain relevant details of an individual - The Respondents No. 2 and 3 now shall issue necessary directions to the concerned school that the register of the school having date of birth be corrected by making necessary changes in the date of birth and place of birth, and on demand shall issue a fresh School Leaving Certificate with the correct date of birth and place of birth - Petition Allowed.
( 1 ) LEAVE to amend the relief clause, more particularly, the date of birth from 29/03/1983 to 29/02/1993, reflected in prayer clause 12 (A ). Necessary amendment shall be carried out forthwith.
( 2 ) THE petitioner-Misrikhan Dilavarkhan pathan has prayed for appropriate writ, order or direction to direct the respondents and more particularly to direct the respondent No. 4 to issue school leaving certificate stating correct date of birth as 18/08/1982 instead of 29/02/1993.
( 3 ) IT is submitted by the petitioner that when he was admitted in the primary school for the first time, somebody who had been to the school, mentioned the incorrect date of birth and the place of birth. The petitioner was born on 18/08/1982 at bhartiya Arogyanidhi Hospital, Gorsheri, patan, but as per the school leaving certificate, the date of birth is shown to be 29/02/1983 and the birth place is shown as village Dasaj of Tal. Siddhpur.
( 4 ) THE birth date certificate of the petitioner is produced at Annexure - A and as such there is no controversy qua the 'contents mentioned in the birth date certificate issued by the Sub-Registrar, birth and Death Registration, Patan nagarpalika. It is relevant to note that the birth date certificate of the petitioner was issued on 20/08/1982, the date on which the birth of the petitioner was registered. So, it is possible to observe that there is no dispute as to the genuineness of the certificate and contents thereof.
4. 1 The petitioner has attempted to see that his birth date in the school leaving register get corrected by the competent authority, but the date on which the petitioner approached the competent authority, he was not student. Not only that but the competent authority had entered the date of birth on the strength of the school leaving certificate issued by the school in which the petitioner was lastly studying. It is the say of the petitioner that difference as to the date of birth in the original birth certificate and school leaving certificate may result into serious prejudice and inconvenience to him and therefore he had approached the competent authority with the original birth certificate to see that competent authority gets correct mainly the date of birth in the school register.
4. 2 As the petitioner could not succeed, the petitioner has approached this Court by filing a writ petition being Special Civil application NO. 6381 of 2004 invoking writ jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. The Court after hearing the leamed Advocate for the petitioner and learned Asst. Government pleader for the respondent-State of Gujarat relegated the petitioner to approach the learned Judicial Magistrate First Class in view of the observations made by this Court while deciding Letters Patent Appeal no. 699 of 2003 filed by Minor Jagdishbhai prabhatbhai Gohil through Father and guardian on 11/08/2003.
( 5 ) THIS Court (Coram: K. S. Jhaveri, J.)while rejecting the earlier petition filed by the present petitioner being Special Civil application No. 6381 of 2004 decided on 08/10/2004 ordered that in view of the above facts and circumstances, the appropriate remedy for the petitioner is to 5 approach the Judicial Magistrate, First class, for redressal of his grievance and this direction was given in the background of paragraph 4 of the decision delivered by the Letters Patent Bench. The said paragraph no. 4 is reproduced as under :
4. We have considered the submissions advanced at the Bar and the documents forming part of the petition. We have also heard Mr. M. R. Mengde, learned Assistant government Pleader appearing for the respondents. From the record of the case, it is evident that the son of appellant has left secondary School after passing examination of Standard 10. Therefore, in view of Regulation 12-A Gujarat Secondary education Regulations, 1974, school record could not have been corrected after the son of appellant had left the school. The only remedy of
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.