2019 Supreme(Guj) 567
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R.P. DHOLARIA, J.
Rajesh Bhogilal Darji - Appellant
Versus
State of Gujarat - Respondent
R/Criminal Appeal No. 943 of 2003
Decided On : 28-01-2019
Subject
Criminal Law - Cruelty and Harassment
Act Referred
INDIAN PENAL CODE : S.498(a), S.306
Headnote
Indian Penal Code, 1860 – section 498-A, section 306 – Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 – section 313 – Cruelty and harassment – Appellant accused has been convicted and sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for one year and to pay fine – Whether deceased had committed suicide due to harassment and cruelty by appellant or not – Held,
No dying declaration was recorded either by police or by Executive Magistrate before any relative only decisive oral evidence of her parents and brother is available on record – Evidence is hearsay in nature parents and brother of deceased have admitted, nothing is turning out involving appellant with crime as parents as well as brother of deceased have clearly admitted that they have neither stated before police nor in complaint as regards to demand of money by appellant from deceased and for not fulfilling demand by deceased, appellant used to beat deceased and harassing her, due to which, she consumed poisonous substance – Trial Court has wrongfully convicted appellant basing its findings upon presumptions merely – Appeal allowed – [Para 19 & 20]
Facts of the Case:
Appellant accused has been convicted and sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for one year and to pay fine – Whether deceased had committed suicide due to harassment and cruelty by appellant or not.
Findings of the court:
No dying declaration was recorded either by police or by Executive Magistrate before any relative only decisive oral evidence of her parents and brother is available on record – Evidence is hearsay in nature parents and brother of deceased have admitted, nothing is turning out involving appellant with crime as parents as well as brother of deceased have clearly admitted that they have neither stated before police nor in complaint as regards to demand of money by appellant from deceased and for not fulfilling demand by deceased, appellant used to beat deceased and harassing her, due to which, she consumed poisonous substance – Trial Court has wrongfully convicted appellant basing its findings upon presumptions merely.
Result: Appeal allowed
Advocate Appeared:
For the Appellant : Mr. Ashish M Dagli
For the Respondent: Ms. CM Shah, App
JUDGMENT :
1. The present appeal is preferred by the appellant – original accused against the judgment and order dated 1.8.2003 passed by learned Additional Sessions & Fast Track Judge, Modasa in Sessions Case No.93 of 2001 whereby the appellant accused has been convicted and sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for one year and to pay fine of Rs.1000/-, in default, to undergo simple imprisonment for three months for the offence under section 498-A of Indian Penal Code and also ordered to undergo rigorous imprisonment for five years and to pay fine of Rs.2000/-, in default, to undergo simple imprisonment for six months for the offence under section 306 of Indian Penal Code.
2. The short facts giving rise to the present case are that the marriage of Jyotsnaben was solemnized before five years from the date of the alleged incident. It is the case of the prosecution that the appellant accused was beating Jyotsnaben for trivial issues. It is alleged that mother-in-law and father-in-law were also instigating their son. It is alleged that on the date of lodging the FIR, Jyotsnaben consumed the poisonous substance and thereafter, she died. Ultimately, the complaint came to be lodged against the accused.
3. In pursuance of the complaint, the Investigating Officer carried out the investigation and filed the chargesheet against the accused. The charge was framed against the accused. The accused pleaded not guilty to the charge and claimed to be tried.
3.1 In order to bring home the guilt, the prosecution has examined witnesses and also produced documentary evidences.
3.2 At the end of the trial, after recording the statements of the accused under section 313 of the Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 and hearing the arguments on behalf of the prosecution and the defence, learned trial Court delivered the judgment and order, as stated above.
4. Being aggrieved by the same, the appellant has preferred the aforesaid Criminal Appeal before this Court.
5. By way of preferring the present appeal, the appellant – original accused has mainly contended that learned trial Court has failed to appreciate the evidence on record and wrongly recorded the order of conviction. It is further contended that learned trial Judge has not appreciated the evidence on record in its proper perspective and in fact, there was no appreciation of evidence so far and hence, the impugned judgment and order of conviction is required to be reversed, as such.
6. Mr.Viral Vyas, learned advocate for Mr.Ashish Dagli, learned advocate for the appellant – original accused has taken this Court through the entire judgment and record and argued that since none of the independent witnesses has supported the case of the prosecution involving the present accused with the crime in question and that parents of the accused were already acquitted by the learned trial Court. He submitted that evidence of parents and brother of the deceased is also hearsay in nature and also not taking case of the prosecution any further to link the accused with the crime in question. He submitted that whatever the parents and brother of the deceased have deposed during the course of examination-in-chief, the same has been clearly admitted by them in the cross examination that they have not stated before the police while giving the statement under section 161 and therefore, their improvements and involving in very grave offence of demanding money etc. came to be disproved in their evidence itself. He further submitted that as admitted by the father of the deceased, the marriage span is clearly established of more than 7 years and the deceased had also male child who is residing along with the present accused at present and no concrete, clinching and connecting evidence is available except hearsay contradictory theory and therefore, benefit of doubt is required to be granted to the present appellant accused.
7. On the other-hand, Ms.Shah, learned APP has supported the judgment rendered by learned trial Court so fa