SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2026 Supreme(Guj) 1505

IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
BHARGAV D. KARIA, NIRZAR S. DESAI, JJ.
 
The PR. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Rajkot 1 - Appellant
Versus 
M/S DML Exim Pvt. Ltd. - Respondent 
R/Tax Appeal No. 115 of 2021 With R/Tax Appeal No. 116 of 2021
Decided On : 21-10-2026

Important Points

Expenses for hedging currency and contract cancellations in export business are not speculative losses. Commission paid to non-residents for services outside India is not taxable in India, precluding TDS disallowance. Section 14A disallowances require the Assessing Officer to record satisfaction before invoking Rule 8D.

Subject

Taxation - Direct Tax / Income Tax

Act Referred

Headnote

(A) Income Tax Act, 1961 - Sections 40(a)(ia), 43(5), 195, 9, and 14A read with Rule 8D - Disallowance of expenses - TDS on payments to non-residents - Speculative loss vs. Business loss - Interest disallowance - Legal principles regarding the nature of export-related expenses and the necessity of recording satisfaction for disallowances.

(B) Section 40(a)(ia) read with Section 195 - Non-deduction of tax at source - Commission paid to non-resident agents for services rendered outside India, where the recipient has no business connection in India, is not taxable in India under Section 9. Consequently, the obligation to deduct tax under Section 195 does not arise, and any disallowance under Section 40(a)(ia) is not permissible. (Paras 9, 18)

(C) Section 43(5) - Speculative loss - Losses incurred due to contract cancellation charges in the course of business or losses arising from forward contracts entered into for hedging foreign exchange fluctuations while implementing export contracts are incidental to the business and do not constitute "speculative transactions" under Section 43(5). (Paras 11, 20)

(D) Section 14A read with Rule 8D - Recording of satisfaction - A precondition for applying the method under Rule 8D for disallowing expenses is that the Assessing Officer must record satisfaction as to the correctness of the claim of the assessee in respect of the expenditure in relation to income which does not form part of the total income. In the absence of such recording or material linking interest expenditure to exempt income, disallowance is unsustainable. (Paras 13, 22)

Facts of the case:
An assessee engaged in trading agricultural products and power generation faced several disallowances during assessment: (i) contract cancellation charges paid to foreign parties, (ii) commission paid to non-resident agents without TDS, (iii) foreign exchange fluctuation losses on dollar bookings, and (iv) interest expenses under Section 14A. The CIT(A) and the Tribunal deleted these disallowances, treating the first three as business-related and the latter as procedurally flawed.

Findings of Court:
The court upheld the concurrent findings of the CIT(A) and the Tribunal. It held that the contract cancellation and hedging losses were incidental to the business and not speculative. It further held that since the foreign commission was not taxable in India, no TDS was required, and for the Section 14A disallowance, the mandatory requirement of recording satisfaction by the Assessing Officer was not met.

Issues: (i) Whether contract cancellation charges and hedging losses are speculative in nature; (ii) Whether TDS is mandatory on commission payments to non-residents for services rendered outside India; and (iii) Whether disallowances under Section 14A can be made without recording satisfaction under the Act.

Ratio Decidendi: Expenses incurred in the regular course of business, including hedging losses to prevent currency fluctuation during exports, are business expenditures and not speculative losses. Taxation of non-residents is governed by Section 9; if the income is not taxable in India, Section 195 does not apply. Procedurally, Rule 8D cannot be invoked for disallowance under Section 14A unless the Assessing Officer records a specific satisfaction regarding the incorrectness of the assessee's claim.

Result: Appeals dismissed.

Legal Category Hierarchy

  • tax law
    • income tax
      • business expenditure (Para 16)
      • tax deduction at source (tds) (Para 8, 18)
      • speculative business loss (Para 5, 20)
      • exempt income disallowance (Para 12, 22)
  • practice and procedure
    • judicial review (Para 15, 17, 23)

Advocates Appeared:
For the Appellant : Maunil G. Yajnik.
For the Respondent: Mr B.S. Soparkar.

Table of Contents

1. Appeal against the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal order concerning disallowances of contract cancellation charges, foreign commission payments, foreign exchange fluctuations, and section 14A expenditure disallowance. (Para 2 , 4 , 8 , 10 , 12 )

2. Revenue contested the deletion of disallowances for business expenses, arguing payments constituted speculation losses, required TDS deduction on foreign payments, or were non-deductible under section 14A. (Para 2 , 5 , 8 , 10 , 12 )

3. The court found concurrent findings of fact established contract charges were business-related, foreign commission payments non-taxable in India, currency hedging incidental to business, and no satisfaction recorded for section 14A. (Para 7 , 9 , 11 , 13 , 15 , 16 , 18 , 20 , 22 )

4. Contract cancellation charges incidental to business and foreign commission payments for services rendered outside India without business connection in India do not attract section 40(a)(ia) disallowance. (Para 9 , 10 , 18 )

5. The appeals filed by the Revenue are dismissed as no substantial questions of law arise from the concurrent factual findings verified by the lower authorities. (Para 17 , 19 , 21 , 22 , 23 , 24 )

6. Are contract cancellation charges incurred due to non-fulfillment of export contracts considered speculative losses?

No, if these charges arise from settling export contracts at lower prices due to failure to meet contractual obligations during the regular course of business, they are not speculative losses under section 43(5) but are allowable business expenditure. (Para 7 , 16 )

7. Is an assessee liable for TDS disallowance under section 40(a)(ia) for commission paid to a non-resident for export facilitation services rendered outside India?

No, since the commission is not fees for technical services and is not taxable in India due to the absence of a business connection for the non-resident, the assessee is not obligated to deduct TDS under section 195. (Para 9 , 18 )

8. Can forward currency contracts entered into by an exporter to hedge against exchange fluctuations be treated as speculative transactions?

No, when forward contracts are used to hedge against foreign exchange risk inherent in export business, they are considered incidental to the regular course of business and not speculative under section 43(5). (Para 11 , 20 )

9. Is the recording of satisfaction by the Assessing Officer a condition precedent for invoking section 14A read with Rule 8D?

Yes, it is mandatory for the Assessing Officer to record satisfaction that the assessee's claim regarding absence of expenditure related to exempt income is incorrect before invoking the disallowance provisions under section 14A and Rule 8D. (Para 13 , 22 )

ORDER :

BHARGAV D. KARIA, J.

1.Heard learned Senior Standing Counsel Mr. Maunil G. Yajnik for the appellant and learned advocate Mr. B. S. Soparkar for the opponent.

2.These appeals are filed under Section 260A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (for short, ‘the Act’), by the appellant-Revenue, proposing the following substantial questions of law arising out of the impugned common order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Rajkot Bench, Rajkot (for short “The Tribunal”) in ITA No.360/RJT/2015 for AY 2011-12 and in ITA No.27/RJT/2016 for AY 2012-13, filed by the Revenue being aggrieved by the order passed by the CIT (Appeals).

TAX APPEAL NO. 115 OF 2021

[A] "Whether the Appellate Tribunal has erred in law and on facts in confirming the order of CIT(A) deleting disallowance of Rs. 21,60,87,454/- made under Section 40(a)(ia) of the Act without appreciating the fact that the assessee failed to deduct tax at source on payments made to foreign agents?"

[B] "Whether the Appellate Tribunal has erred in law and on facts in confirming the order of CIT(A) deleting disallowance of Rs. 10,04,33,270/- made on account of contract cancellation charges despite the fact that the same were not genuine?"

TAX APPEAL NO. 116 OF 2021

[A] "Whether the Appellate Tribunal has erred in law and on facts in confirming the order of CIT(A) deleting disallowance of Rs.2,80,05,500/- made on account of contract cancellation charges despite the fact that transaction was speculative in nature and not a part and parcel of the export business of the assessee?

[B] "Whether the Appellate Tribunal has erred in law and on facts in confirming the order of CIT(A) deleting disallowance of Rs.9,73,33,826/- made under Section 40(a)(ia) of the Act without appreciating the fact that the assessee failed to deduct tax at source on payments made to foreign agents?"

[C] "Whether the Appellate Tribunal has erred in law and on facts in deleting the disallowance of loss of Rs.46,28,828/- by holding that loss on fluctuation of foreign exchange is not speculative under section 43(5) of the Act and the same is incidental to the assessee's business?"

[D] "Whether the Appellate Tribunal has erred in law and on facts in deleting the disallowance of Rs.6,02,976/-made under section 14A r.w. Rule 8D?"

3.For the sake of convenience, Tax Appeal No. 116 of 2021 is treated as the lead matter.

4.The assessee is a Private Limited Company engaged in the business of trading of agricultural products, building construction, and generation of power/energy. For Assessment Year 2012-13, the assessee file the return of income on 08.09.2012, declaring income at Rs.23,96,84,200/-. During the course of assessment proceedings, the Assessing Officer found that an amount of Rs.2,80,05,500/- was paid by the assessee as contract cancellation charges to various foreign parties for non-fulfillment of the contractual terms and conditions, resulting in settlement of contracts at a price which is lower than the predetermined price as a result of which the assessee had to make such payment.

5.The Assessing Officer, however, held that cancellation of transaction caused on account of non-delivery within the specific time and the surplus or deficit so generated, leading to payment or receipt of money, acquired the colour of speculation profit/loss. It was observed by the Assessing Officer that the transaction was arranged in such a way as to reduce the profit and, after invoking the provisions of Section 73(1) pertaining to loss of speculation business or activity, it was held by the Assessing Officer that such amount paid by the assessee would partake the character of loss of speculation business or activity and, therefore, the same could not have been set-off against the profit generated from regular business and accordingly, the cancellation charges of Rs.2,80,05,500/- was disallowed as speculation loss.

6.The CIT (Appeals), however, allowed the appeal filed by the assessee, deleting such disallowance.

7.Being aggrieved, the Revenue prefer

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top