IN THE HIGH COURT OF GAUHATI
Brojendra Prasad Katakey, J.
Shri Kashi Nath Gogoi and Ors. – Appellants
Vs.
Sri Thambahadur Dorjee and Ors. – Respondent
R.S.A. No. 38 of 2000
Decided On: 24.09.2008
Limitation Act - Section 146 – Criminal Procedure Code - Suit is barred by limitation - Appreciation of evidences on record – Evidence - Being aggrieved plaintiff/appellants preferred Title which has, however been dismissed vide judgment passed by learned first Appellate Court affirming judgment and decree passed by learned trial Court by upholding findings recorded by learned Court below, hence present appeal – Held, Suit in the instant case has been filed by appellant/plaintiffs on within months from date of passing of final order by learned Magistrate declaring possession in favor of respondent/defendant Declaration of such possession in a proceeding under Section 145, Cr PC in favor of respondent/defendant as noticed above is subject to order that may be passed by a competent civil Court for eviction of party in whose favor declaration has been made – Therefore for purpose of Article65 of Limitation Act period for which land was under order of attachment cannot be counted so also for purpose of adverse possession - Both Courts below inspire of pleadings noticed above and materials available on records of 145, Cr PC proceeding before them did not consider legal effect of order of attachment passed under Section 146(1), Cr PC as well as issuance of notice prohibiting parties from entering on to land and enforcement of same by police while deciding issue relating to limitation and adverse possession - Appeal allowed
B.P. Katakey, J.
1. This appeal by the plaintiffs in Title Suit No. 146/91 is against the judgment dated 10.9.1999 and decree dated 29.9.1999 passed by the learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), Kamrup, Guwahati in Title Appeal No. 37/97 dismissing the appeal and upholding the judgment dated 31.5.1997 and decree dated 12.7.1997 drawn by the learned Civil Judge (Junior Division) No. 1, Kamrup, Guwahati in Title Suit No. 146/91 dismissing the suit.
2. The appellant Nos. 1 and 2 and also the predecessor in interest of the appellant No. 3(a) to 3(d) filed Title Suit No. 146/91 in the Court of the learned Civil Judge (Junior Division) No. 1 (Now Munsiff), Guwahati praying for declaration of right, title, interest and recovery of Khas possession in respect of land measuring 4 Kathas 17-3/4 Lechas covered by Dag No. 101(new)/25 (old) of F.S. Grant No. 1 (new)/27 (old) of village Baruabari Mouza Panbari in the district of Kamrup, Assam, more fully described in Schedule-B to the plaint, contending inter alia, that the plaintiff Nos. 1 and 2 purchased a plot of land measuring 1 Bigha 4 Kathas 3-1/2 Lechas of land in Dag No. 2(old)/99 (new), 25(old)/101 (new) of the said F.S. Grant by a registered sale deed No. 718 of 1979 on 24.1.1979 for a valuable consideration, the possession of which was delivered by the vendor to them. It has further been contended that the plaintiffs thereafter got their names mutated in respect of the said land and constructed ordinary thatched house. The respondent/defendant No. 1, who is an employee of the Defence Air Force Department posted at Digaru near Sonapur, without having any right, title and interest over the land, along with some other associates with a move to grab the 'A' Schedule land measuring 1 Bigha 4 Kathas 3-1/3 Lechas created disturbance to the peaceful possession for which a proceeding under Section 107, Cr PC was initiated and during pendency of which on 4.9.1979 the respondent/defendant No. 1 trespassed into the 'B' Schedule land, which is a part of the 'A' Schedule land and dispossessed the plaintiffs from the land for which the plaintiff No. 2 brought a proceeding under Section 145, Cr PC before the Executive Magistrate as first party, in which the land ('B' Schedule land) with two small thatched houses were attached by the order of the learned Magistrate, which proceeding, however, was disposed of on 19.11.1990 by declaring possession of the respondent/defendant No, 1. The plaintiffs thereafter brought a suit for declaration of right, title, interest and for recovery of Khas possession in respect of the 'B' Schedule land. The respondent/defendant No. 1 contested the suit by filing written statement, amongst others, raising the plea of maintainability of the suit for non-joinder and mis-joinder of parties and also contending that he has been possessing the land in question since 1970 continuously against its' original owner by constructing dwelling house, planting valuable trees and during his long possession nobody came to the land to claim right, title and interest and he is in peaceful possession of the same. The defendant has, therefore, taken the plea of adverse possession and also contended that the suit is barred by limitation having not brought within 12 years from such adverse possession.
3. The learned trial Court on the basis of the pleadings of the parties, framed the following issues for determination:
(1) Whether the plaintiff has right, title and interest over the suit land?
(2) Whether the suit is barred by limitation?
(3) Whether the suit is barred by adverse possession of the defendant?
(4) Whether the suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary parties?
(5) To what relief if any the plaintiff may be entitled under law and equity?
4. The learned Munsiff upon appreciation of evidences on record, both oral and documentary, dismissed the suit filed by the plaintiff vide judgment dated 31.5.1997 by holding that the respondent/defendant No. 1 could prove adverse possession and t
Dukhan Ram and Ors. v. Ram Nanda Singh and Ors. AIR 1961 Pat 425
Pentapati Venkatratnam and Ors. v. Karri Venkatanarasaymma and Ors. AIR 1964 AP 109
Shanti Kumar Panda v. Shakuntata Devi (2004) 1 SCC 438
Ram Kumar Agarwal v. Thawar Das AIR 1999 SC 3248
Sajjan Singh Bhairun Singh v. Sajjan Singh Jagannath Singh and Anr. AIR 1969 Raj 82
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.