1970 Supreme(Gau) 12
GAUHATI HIGH COURT
R.S.Bindra, J.
Nitya Sadhu Jamatia -Appellant
Versus
Chandra Dayal Jamatia -Respondent
First Appeal No. 18 of 1964
Decided On : 07-02-1970
Important Points
Subject
Civil Law - Parties and Impleading
Act Referred
Headnote
PARTITION SUIT - NON-JOINDER OF PARTIES - CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE, 1908 - ORDER 1, RULE 9 AND RULE 10(2) - EFFECT OF NON-JOINDER - POWER OF COURT TO BRING NECESSARY PARTIES ON RECORD - DISMISSAL OF SUIT FOR NON-JOINDER - LEGALITY.
Fact of the Case:
Plaintiffs filed a suit for possession by partition of their share in the land covered by jote No. 75. The defendants Nos. 1 and 2 admitted that the land under jote No. 75 had been jointly acquired by them and the plaintiffs, but alleged that partition by metes and bounds had been effected between the joint owners more than 10 years before the institution of the suit. The trial Court dismissed the suit on the ground that the plaintiffs had admitted in the plaint that final partition had been effected between them and the defendants Nos. 1 and 2 and that the suit was not properly constituted due to non-joinder of necessary parties.
Finding of the Court:
The High Court held that the trial Court erred in holding that the plaintiffs had admitted in the plaint that final partition had been effected between them and the defendants Nos. 1 and 2. The Court further held that the trial Court should have given an opportunity to the plaintiffs to implead those persons in the suit to whom some parts of the land covered by jote No. 75, according to the statement of Nitya Sadhu Jamatia plaintiff, had been sold, or to straightway implead those persons as parties on its own initiative.
Issues: 1. Whether the plaintiffs have got any cause of action in this suit? 2. Is the suit bad for defect of parties? 3. Is the suit properly valued and stamped? 4. Whether the plaintiffs have got any right, title or possession in the suit lands? 5. Are the suit lands liable to be partitioned between the parties? If so, what would be the share of the plaintiffs in those lands. 6. What relief, are the plaintiffs entitled to get?
Ratio Decidendi: 1. A suit cannot be dismissed on the basis merely of non-joinder of parties. 2. The Court has the power to bring on the record any person who is a necessary party to the suit and in whose absence it is not possible for the Court to effectually and completely adjudicate upon and settle all the questions involved in the suit.
Final Decision: The High Court allowed the appeal, set aside the judgment and decree of the trial Court, and remanded the case to the trial Court with the direction that it should be entered at its old number and an opportunity given to the plaintiffs to bring on the record such persons to whom any of them may have sold some parcels of the land covered by jote No. 75.
N.C.Roy, R.Ghosh
2. The suit was founded on the allegations that the lands described in Schedule 1 of the plaint had been acquired jointly by the plaintiffs and the defendants Nos. 1 and 2 from the Government of Tripura as jotedars against the payment of certain amount. The acquired land was covered by jote No. 75 and its area was mentioned as approximately 5 drones though actually it turned out to be about 30 drones within the boundaries given in the relevant order of the Government. For sometime after the acquisition, it was alleged further, the plaintiffs, who are 10 in number, and defendants Nos. 1 and 2 continued in joint possession of the entire area but subsequently for the sake of convenient enjoyment they entered into different parcels of the land. The description of the area under the possession of the plaintiffs was given in Schedule 2 of the plaint while that in occupation of the defendants Nos. 1 and 2 was set out in Schedule 3 of the plaint. Sometime before the institution of the suit, it was pleaded, disputes cropped up between the plaintiffs and the defendants Nos. 1 and 2 and the latter initiated proceedings under Section 107, Criminal Procedure Code against the former in collusion with the other defendants. The defendants Nos. 1 and 2, it was alleged further, were out to dispossess the plaintiffs from the lands mentioned in Schedule 2 of the plaint, and so it was considered inevitable that the entire area jointly owned should be partitioned and the plaintiffs made secure in possession of the land which falls to their share. The plaintiffs claimed 10/12th share in the joint land covered by jote No. 75 and alleged that the remaining 2/12th share belongs to defendants Nos. 1 and 2. The total number of the defendants in the suit was 63. Different sets of the defendants filed separate written statements. In the written statement filed by defendants Nos. 1 and 2, if was admitted that to begin with the land under jote No. 75 had been jointly acquired by them and the plaintiffs, but it was alleged that partition by metes and bounds had been effected between the joint owners more than 10 years before the institution of the suit. On that basis it was claimed that the suit for possession by partition was not maintainable. Another objection taken was that the plaintiffs had sold their share of the land to a large number of persons and since quite a few of them had not been impleaded, the suit for partition was not properly constituted.
3. The trial Court settled the following issues between the parties:-
(1) Whether the plaintiffs have got any cause of action in this suit?
(2) Is the suit bad for defect of parties?
(3) Is the suit properly valued and stamped?
(4) Whether the plaintiffs have got any right, title or possession in the suit lands?
(5) Are the suit lands liable to be partitioned between the parties? If so, what would be the share of the plaintiffs in those lands.
(6) What relief, are the plaintiffs entitled to get?
Issues Nos. (1) and (2) were decided against the plaintiffs and issue No. (3) in their favour. Issues Nos. (4) and (5) were decided against the plaintiffs but for reasons, which are not comprehensible. In consequence of the findings on issues Nos. 1, 2, 4 and 5 the suit of the plaintiffs was dismissed with costs.
4. Issue No. (1) was decided against the plaintiffs on the finding that plaintiffs and defendants Nos. 1 and 2 had partitioned the property by metes and bounds and so they were no longer joint owners of the land covered by jote No. 75. This finding was based almost exclusively on the basis .of what is mentioned in the plaint. I have critically examined the plaint but have not been able to spell out therefrom that the plaintiffs had admitted that the