SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

1991 Supreme(Gau) 51

GAUHATI HIGH COURT
SRIVASTAVA AND SANGMA, J.
C.Lalrutlungi -Appellant
Versus
Thanpari -Respondent
First Appeal No. 19 of 1986
Decided On : 19-03-1991

Important Points

The main legal point established in the judgment is the interpretation of the provisions of the will and Mizo Customary Law to determine the extent of the widow's right to the property, leading to the finding of a limited life interest and the entitlement of the sons of the deceased's brothers to inherit the property.

Subject

Property Law - Inheritance and Will Disputes

Headnote

Inheritance - Property Dispute - Will - Mizo Customary Law - [2, 5, 9] - The court considered the provisions of the will, particularly clauses 2, 5, and 9, to determine the extent of the right bequeathed to the widow. It concluded that the widow had only a limited life interest in the property, and on her death, the property was to be inherited by the sons of the testator's brothers.

Fact of the Case:

The dispute arose over the inheritance of a residential property and compound bequeathed by the deceased to his widow. The widow transferred the property to the appellant, leading to a claim by the sons of the deceased's brothers. The court had to determine the extent of the widow's right to the property under the will and Mizo Customary Law.

Finding of the Court:

The court found that the widow had only a limited life interest in the property, and on her death, the property was to be inherited by the sons of the deceased's brothers. The court held that the widow's transfer of the property to the appellant was not valid, and the sons of the deceased's brothers were entitled to inherit the property.

Issues: The main issue was whether the widow had absolute ownership rights to the property or only a limited life interest, as per the provisions of the will and Mizo Customary Law.

Ratio Decidendi: The court's decision was based on the interpretation of the provisions of the will, particularly clauses 2, 5, and 9, which indicated the testator's intention to grant the widow a limited life interest in the property. The court also considered Mizo Customary Law of Inheritance to support its finding.

Final Decision: The appeal was dismissed, and the court held that the widow's transfer of the property to the appellant was not valid. The property was to be inherited by the sons of the deceased's brothers.

Advocates Appeared:
R. C. Thanga, Sri D. K. Das

Judgement

SRIVASTAVA, J.:- This appeal is directed against the judgment and order dated 14-3-1986 passed by the learned District Council Court, Aizawal.

2. Briefly, the undisputed facts in this appeal are that one Saia (Saikapthianga) had properties including the residential house with compound in dispute at Aizawal. Saia died on 20-3-1961 leaving his wife Khawkungi. Saia had no issue. On 12-1-1961 Saia had executed a will and bequeathed his various properties to different persons. The residential house with compound in dispute was bequeathed to Khawkungi. Saia had two brothers Biaka and Nagila. Some money was bequeathed to one son of Biaka and one son of Nagila. Biaka had predeceased Khaw-kungi. The appellant herein is the daughter of Saias sister Lali. The respondent herein Thanpari is the widow of Biaka who died in 1983. Khawkungi had made transfer by gift of the house with compound on 24-5-1985 to the appellant. Khawkungi had died on 23-6-1985.

3. The appellants case was that she had been adopted as daughter by Saia and had looked after Saia and Khawkungi in their old age. After the death of Saia the properties left by him had been distributed in accordance with the provision in the will and Khawkungi his widow had obtained heirship Certificate in respect of the house with compound in dispute and had been in her possession. On 24-5-1985 Khawkungi had transferred her properties in favour of the appellant and accordingly the appellants name was record-ed in place of Khawkungi in respect of the residential house and compound in dispute. Thanpari, respondent claimed heirship certificate and filed an application before the Additional Subordinate District Council Court, Aizawal on the ground that Saia had not given the properties in dispute absolutely to Khawkungi that after her death the pro-perty as to devolve on his aforesaid brothers Biaka and Nagila and as such the claim was -filed on behalf of the sons of Biaka by their mother Thanpari. The sons of Nagila did not make any claim. The claim was resisted by the appellant who pleaded that the properties in dispute had become the absolute property to Khawkungi under the will and she had trans-ferred the same to the appellant and as such the appellant was the owner and in possession of the property. The learned Magistrate, Additional Subordinate District Council Court, Aizawal by judgment dated 9-12-1985 held that Khanwkungi on the strength of heirship certificate No. 50 of 1961 exactly according to the will granted to her had rightly transferred the property to the present appellant and that the sons of Biaka could not have any claim which was accordingly not accepted. In appeal, the learned District Council Court, Aizawal by judgment and order dated 14-3-1986 impugned in this appeal held that in view of the provisions in paras 2, 5 and 9 of will, Khawkungi could not transfer the property in dispute to the ap-pellant and that after her death, the property was to be inherited by the sons of Biaka and Nagila. The appeal was accordingly allowed.

4. Aggrieved, Smti. Lalrutlungi has come in appeal and Shri R. C. Thanga, learned counsel appearing on her behalf has submit-ted that the view taken by the learned District Council Court in appeal was erroneous in that under the will Khawkungi had inherited the property and had become its absolute owner and her right was recognised by issue of heirship certificate on the basis of which her name had been recorded and as such she had made the necessary competence to make the transfer in favour of the appellant. The view taken by the learned District Council Court in appeal that Khawkungi had no right to transfer was erroneous. Shri D. K. Das, learned counsel for the respondent, on the other hand, has contended that under the provision of the will itself as has been held by the learned District Council Court below entire property bequeathed to Khawkungi on her death was to go to the sons of Biaka and Nagila and as such the impugned judgment an
















1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top