SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

1998 Supreme(Gau) 246

GAUHATI HIGH COURT
J.N.Sarma, J.
Abdul Hussain -Appellant
Versus
On The Death of Musstt Aftabjan Bibi Her Legal Heirs -Respondent
Second Appeal No. 40 of 1993
Decided On : 21-08-1998

Important Points

A suit for declaration of fraudulent deed is maintainable even if the plaintiff is an alien friend and the Power of Attorney is executed and authenticated in Bangladesh.

Subject

Civil Law - Property Law

Act Referred

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE : S.83
EVIDENCE ACT : S.85
FOREIGN EXCHANGE REGULATION ACT : S.31(1), S.31
LIMITATION ACT : Art.59

Headnote

FOREIGN EXCHANGE REGULATION ACT, 1973 - SECTION 31 - SUIT FOR DECLARATION OF FRAUDULENT DEED - MAINTAINABILITY - POWER OF ATTORNEY EXECUTED IN BANGLADESH - VALIDITY - SECTION 85 OF THE EVIDENCE ACT - APPLICABILITY.

Fact of the Case:

A suit was filed for a declaration that a deed of sale in favor of the defendants was fraudulent and not executed by the plaintiff. The plaintiff, a Bangladeshi citizen, had a property in India and came to know about the forgery in 1987. She filed the suit through a Constituted Attorney on the strength of a Power of Attorney executed and authenticated in Bangladesh.

Finding of the Court:

The lower courts found that the deed of sale was not executed by the plaintiff and that the suit was filed within three years from the date of knowledge of the creation of the document. The court also held that the Power of Attorney executed in Bangladesh was valid and that the suit was maintainable.

Issues: 1. Whether the suit was barred by limitation? 2. Whether the suit filed by a Constituted Attorney on the strength of a Power of Attorney executed and authenticated in Bangladesh was maintainable? 3. Whether the Power of Attorney was valid even after the death of the executor? 4. Whether the substituted heirs of the plaintiff, who were aliens, could maintain the suit? 5. Whether the Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973 barred the suit?

Ratio Decidendi: 1. The suit was not barred by limitation as it was filed within three years from the date of knowledge of the creation of the document. 2. The suit filed by a Constituted Attorney on the strength of a Power of Attorney executed and authenticated in Bangladesh was maintainable as section 85 of the Evidence Act applies equally to documents authenticated by Notaries Public of other countries. 3. The Power of Attorney was valid even after the death of the executor as section 83 of the Code of Civil Procedure allows alien friends to sue in any Court otherwise competent to try the suit. 4. The substituted heirs of the plaintiff, who were aliens, could maintain the suit as section 83 of the Code of Civil Procedure allows alien friends to sue in any Court otherwise competent to try the suit. 5. The Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973 did not bar the suit as there is no provision in the Act which makes transaction void or says that no title in the property passes to the purchaser in case there is contravention of section 31 (-1) by non-obtaining permission of Reserve Bank.

Final Decision: The second appeal was dismissed with cost throughout.

Advocates Appeared:
P.K.Roy, N.M.Lahiri, D.Majumdar, N.Choudhary

A suit was filed being Title Suit No. 42 of 1993 by one Aftabuddin through her Constituted Attorney Md Afazuddin. The suit was for a declaration that a deed of sale dated 7.5.74 in favour of the defendants registered on 14.5.74 before the Sub Registrar, Bhangarpar, District Cachar is a fraudulent deed and it was not executed by the plaintiff. The plaintiff, a Bangladeshi citizen had some property in India and in paragraphs 4 and 5 of the plaint it is stated as follows :

“4. That during the 2nd quarter of 1987, the plaintiff received information from her cousin-brother Md Afasuddin that he had come to definitely know on 4.5.1987 of a forged document having been fabricated by the principal-defendant falsely showing purchase of certain lands from the plaintiff. The plaintiff was very much purturbed by the information for which to square out the matters, the plaintiff obtained passport and Visa and came to India i.e. at her paternal home on 16.11.87 and stayed for about one and 1 half month.

5. That from the certified copy of the forged document it transpired that though the forgery had been committed purportedly on 7.5.1974 and 14.5.1974 but its information was received by the plaintiff only during May, 1987 and full details of the same were known to the plaintiff only on 16.11.1987 as aforesaid for which the suit is within the period of limitation as per section 56 of the Limitation Act, 1963.”

2. So it is the definite case of the plaintiff that she had the knowledge about the forgery only on 16.11.87 when she came to India by taking Visa and the suit was filed through the Constituted Attorney on 19.9.88. Article 59 of the Limitation Act provides a period of 3 years to cancel or set aside instrument or decree and the time begins to run when the facts entitling the plaintiff to have the instrument or decree cancel led has become known to the plaintiff. It is the finding of facts of the lower appellate Court, inter alia, as follows :

(i) That there was no land of the plaintiff within the jurisdiction of the Sub Registrar where the deed was registered.

(ii) The entire records lead the Court believe that the original deed of Ext 3 was not executed by Aftabjan Bibi. It was done fraudulently.

(iii) A suit was filed within three years from the date of knowledge of the creation of the document, Ext 3.

3. The learned Munsiff in his judgment in Title Suit No.91 of 1988 found that Ext 3 was not executed .by Aftabjan Bibi. It was a fraudulent deed. The plaintiff came to know of the deed of sale only in the year 1987 and in view oj” that it was held that the suit is not barred by limitation. So the first contention of Shri Lahiri, learned Advocate for the appellant that the suit is barred by limitation has no legs to stand upon in view of the concurrent finding of the Courts below.

4. The next contention of Shri Lahiri is that a suit has been filed by a Constituted Attorney on the strength of a Power of Attorney executed and authenticated in Bangladesh and the executor is residing in Bangladesh so the suit is not maintainable. The Power of Attorney is in the record and I have looked to it and-1 find that it was duly authenticated by a Notary Public in Bangladesh. Further this was accepted by the Deputy Commissioner, Cachar at Silchar after necessary stamp duty was paid at Cachar. The substantial question of law as formulated in this case is whether the Power of Attorney on the basis of which the plaintiff filed the suit can be regarded as valid document even-after the death of the executor. Before we proceed further one thing should be borne in mind that after the death of the original plaintiff her heirs who are the residents in Bangladesh were brought on record. The question whether these heirs who are definitely aliens and filed a suit in India with regard to the properties situated here is maintainable.

Section 83 of the Code of Civil Procedure is a direct answer to it. Section 83 of the Coe of Civil Procedure provides as follows :

“83. When alien


























1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top