SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2019 Supreme(Gau) 846

IN THE HIGH COURT OF GAUHATI
MIR ALFAZ ALI, J.
Chander Pal @ Chandra Pal — Appellant
Versus
Union Of India – Respondent
Criminal Appeal No. 106 of 2018
Decided on : 07-08-2019

Important Points

The judgment established the importance of fair investigation, the credibility of evidence, and compliance with legal requirements for search and seizure under the NDPS Act.

Subject

Criminal Law - NDPS Act Violation

Act Referred

CONSTITUTION OF INDIA : Art.21
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE : S.100(4)
NARCOTIC DRUGS AND PSYCHOTROPIC SUBSTANCES ACT : S.21(c), S.29

Headnote

NDPS - Prosecution of contraband articles under section 21(c)/29 of the NDPS Act - Section 100 (4) of the Cr.P.C. - The court discussed the non-examination of independent witnesses, the credibility of police officials' evidence, and the requirement of fair investigation under the NDPS Act.

Fact of the Case:

The appellants were found guilty of carrying contraband articles at the Guwahati Railway Station. The prosecution case relied on the search and seizure conducted by the Narcotic Control Bureau (NCB) team.

Finding of the Court:

The court found that the non-examination of independent witnesses and the involvement of the investigating officer as the complainant vitiated the prosecution case. The court emphasized the importance of fair investigation and the credibility of evidence in such cases.

Issues: Non-examination of independent witnesses, involvement of the investigating officer as the complainant, and compliance with legal requirements for search and seizure.

Ratio Decidendi: The court held that the non-examination of independent witnesses and the involvement of the investigating officer as the complainant affected the credibility of the prosecution case. The court also emphasized the requirement of fair investigation and compliance with legal provisions for search and seizure.

Final Decision: The conviction and sentence of the appellants were set aside, and both appeals were allowed. The appellants were directed to be set at liberty forthwith.

Advocates:
Advocate Appeared:
Mr N. Ahmed, Adv., S.C. Keyal, Adv.

JUDGMENT :

Mir Alfaz Ali, J.

Both these appeals arise out of the judgment and order dated 18-11-2017 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Kamrup (Metro), Guwahati in NDPS Case No. 7/2015. By the said judgment, the appellants were held guilty of offence punishable under section 21(c)/29 of the NDPS Act and sentenced to rigorous imprisonment for 12 years and fine of Rs. 1 lakh each with default stipulation.

2. Prosecution case in brief is that a secret information was received by PW-1, Intelligence Officer of the Narcotic Control Bureau (NCB) about the movement of two persons at the Guwahati Railway Station who were carrying heroine. The information was reduced to writing and was sent to the higher authority. To pursue the information, a team was constituted under the leadership of PW-1 and they arrived at the Guwahati Railway Station on that day at about 6.45 am. They also requested two persons to be witness to the search and seizure. The NCB team started to search the persons as per the information received. After few moments, they noticed two persons, one carrying a suitcase and the other a trolley bag, were standing at the platform no. 1 of the Guwahati Railway Station as mentioned in the secret information. On being asked by the NCB team, they introduced themselves to be Chander Paul and Shiv Kumar Verma. The NCB team conducted a search in presence of the independent witnesses and upon such search, colored powder suspected to be brown sugar was recovered from both the suitcase and the trolly bag. A small quantity of the said powder from the suitcase and the trolly bag was tested by the drug testing kits, which gave positive test for narcotic drugs. Accordingly, they seized the said brown colour powder by Ext. 4, took sample in duplicate from each of the packets, which were sent for forensic examination and the forensic examination report gave positive test for morphine. The total quantity of contraband seized was 3.540 kg. Accordingly, prosecution was launched against both the appellants.

3. In course of trial, prosecution examined five witnesses and on appreciation of evidence, learned trial court convicted both the appellants and awarded sentence as indicated above.

4. Learned counsel for the appellants assailed the impugned judgment basically on the ground that independent witnesses present at the time of search and seizure have not been examined and the trolley bag and the suit case containing the contraband articles were not seized from the possession of the appellants, inasmuch as, the trolly bag and suit case were not produced before the court. Learned counsel also contended that the trial stood vitiated as the investigation was done by the complainant himself.

5. Ext. 4, the seizure memo, shows that the contraband articles were seized in presence of two independent witnesses, namely, Ajit Das and Pranjal Baruah. It is also in the deposition of PW-1, the seizing officer as well as the PW-3, the investigating officer, that the said two persons, who were found in the Railway platform agreed to be witness to the search and seizure and they were present at the time of search and seizure. Evidently none of the independent witnesses was examined by the prosecution.

6. Learned counsel for the appellants placing reliance on a decision of this Court in Md Ayub Vs State of Assam, (1998) 1 GauLT 313 submits, that non-examination of the independent witness cast a serious doubt on the prosecution case, and therefore, no conviction can be based on the basis of such evidence, when the vital independent witnesses are withheld.

7. Learned Standing Counsel for the NCB submits that when the PW-1, PW-3 and PW-5, responsible officers of the NCB have clearly deposed regarding search and seizure of the contraband articles of commercial quantity from the possession of the appellants and the forensic examination report gave positive test for morphine, mere non-examination of the independent seizure witnesses cannot throw the prosecution

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top