2007 Supreme(Ker) 539
Judges : J.B.KOSHY,A.K.BASHEER,K.P.BALACHANDRAN
Bharathi, Thiruvananthapuram - Appellant
Versus
S.Vinod, Thiruvananthapuram - Respondent
Case No : R.C.Rev.No.101 of 2004
Decided On : 10/03/2007
Advocates Appeared :
For the Petitioners : Nagaraj Narayanan, Nair Ajay Krishnan, Saijo Hassan, Sabu Sreedharan, Advocates. For the Respondent: J. Harikumar, Advocate.
Subject
Landlord-Tenant Disputes - Eviction Proceedings
Act Referred
Headnote
Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965 - Sections 11(1) Proviso II, 15 - Opining that the dicta laid down in Parthakumar v. Ajith Viswanathan and in Narayan Murti v. Thankamma Sebastian are manifestly at variance regarding interpretation of second proviso to S.11 (1) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965 (Act 2 of 1965) a Division Bench of this Court referred this matter to the Full Bench. S.11 (1) and second proviso to S.11 (1) of the Act - Held, In view of S.15, Court only hold that since, in the earlier proceedings under S.11 (2), it was held that there is no landlord-tenant relationship and no rent was paid, subsequent petition under S.11 (2) is barred - Without prejudice to the right of the parties to approach the Civil Court, Court set aside the order of eviction passed under S.11 (2) as it is hit by the principles of res judicata adopted in S.15 of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act - R.C.R. Allowed.
J.B. Koshy, J.
Opining that the dicta laid down in Parthakumar v. Ajith Viswanathan (2006 (2) KLT 250 FB) and in Narayan Murti v. Thankamma Sebastian (2005 (3) KLT 102 DB) are manifestly at variance regarding interpretation of second proviso to section 11 (1) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965 (Act 2 of 1965) for short ‘the Act’ a Division Bench of this Court referred this matter to the Full Bench. Section 11 (1) and second proviso to section 11 (1) of the Act reads as follows:
“11. Eviction of tenants:- (1) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in any other law or contract a tenant shall not be evicted, whether in execution of a decree or otherwise, except in accordance with the provisions of this Act:
xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxxxx
Provided further that where the tenant denies the title of the landlord or claims right of permanent tenancy, the Rent Control Court shall decide whether the denial or claim is bona fide and if it records a finding to that effect, the landlord shall be entitled to sue for eviction of the tenant in a Civil Court and such Court may pass a decree for eviction on any of the grounds mentioned in this section, notwithstanding that the court finds that such denial does not involve forfeiture of the lease or that the claim is unfounded.”
2. The Full Bench in Parthakumar’s case held that existence of landlord-tenant relationship is inevitable for the special tribunal to exercise its jurisdiction. Once the rent control court is satisfied that the contention regarding denial of title or claim for permanent tenancy is bona fide, the claims regarding title has to be decided finally by the civil court. That is a zone or area where civil court must entertain jurisdiction. The Full Bench also held that proprietary title of the person claiming eviction is irrelevant to decide the jurisdiction. The Full Bench held as follows:
“16. …. The Special Tribunals are constituted only to resolve the limited disputes relating to eviction falling under S.11 of the Act. Existence of landlord-tenant relationship between the contestants is sine qua non for Ss.11 (2) to 11 (8) to operate and for the Special Tribunals to have jurisdiction. Only when the landlord-tenant relationship in respect of the building exists, does and can the Special Tribunal have jurisdiction to consider a claim for eviction. Summary and expeditious procedure to prescribed for eviction only in cases where the landlord-tenant relationship exists and the dispute regarding eviction is between the landlord and the tenant. Existence of landlord-tenant relationship between the claimant/landlord and respondent/tenant is thus essential, to confer jurisdiction on the Rent Control Authorities.”
“18. The legislature was conscious of the fact that there could be disputes as to whether there exists landlord-tenant relationship. A person who is proceeded against as a tenant may have to raise a contention that there is no landlord-tenant relationship and that he is not a tenant. The landlord claiming eviction must have title to evict. If he has no title to evict and such a contention is raised, the jurisdiction to decide that dispute rightly vests in civil courts following exhaustive procedure and not in the Special Tribunals constituted to decide a limited category of disputes following summary procedure. Therefore, where existence of landlord-tenant relationship, i.e., title of the landlord to claim eviction against the person proceeded against, is itself seriously disputed, certainly the Special Tribunals must take their hands off the dispute and leave the parties to resolve their disputes before the regular civil courts constituted. The Tribunals following summary procedures cannot usurp the powers and jurisdiction of the civil courts to decide such disputes regarding title. Such substantial disputes regarding title are uplands and out of bounds for the statutory special tribunals. That is the zone or area where the civil court must e