SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2004 Supreme(Ker) 16

Judges : CYRIAC JOSEPH,K.PADMANABHAN NAIR
State of Kerala - Appellant
Versus
Abdul Sathar - Respondent
Case No : WA. No.2135 of 2003
Decided On : 01/15/2004
Advocates Appeared :
For the Petitioners: V.K. Beeran, Addl. Advocate General. For the Respondents: R1, M. Sasindran, T.P. Eldho, K.T. Sankaran, A. Meena, R. Rajesh Kormath, Sanjana R. Nair, K.S. Jaykar, R2, K. Ramakumar, Saritha Varma, Advocates.

Important Points

The prohibition contained in Section 5B of the Kerala Education Act is against the sale, mortgage, lease, pledge, charge or transfer of possession of any land appurtenant to a Government School vested with a local authority and that the said prohibition cannot apply to the use of the playground of a government school for conducting a football tournament for a few days with the permission of the authority concerned.

Subject

Civil Law - Administrative Law

Act Referred

KERALA EDUCATION ACT : S.5(b), S.5(a)

Headnote

Permission - Football Tournament - Kerala Education Act, Section 5B, Rule 15 of Chapter IV - The court directed the appellants to permit the first respondent to organize and conduct the All India Sevens Foot Ball Tournament in the playground of the G.M.U.P. School, Cherur between 20.1.2004 and 1.3.2004. The tournament shall not be conducted before 6.30 p.m. The organizers shall ensure that no damage is caused to the buildings and other properties of the school. After the tournament, the playground shall be restored to its original position by the first respondent. The first shall deposit with the third appellant – Headmaster, a sum of Rs.1,55,000/- before the start of the tournament. The said amount can be utilized by the third appellant in accordance with law for the construction of the Stage-cum-class room as proposed by the Parent Teacher Association or for other educational purposes of the school. On completion of the tournament, the first respondent shall contribute 60% of the profit to the school as promised. If the teachers and the students of the school request, they shall be given free passes to watch the tournament. The District Collector, Malappuram and the Superintendent of Police, Malappuram are directed to take all necessary steps to maintain law and order and to effectively prevent breach of peace and commission of offences during or in connection with the football tournament. This order granting permission to the first respondent to conduct the football tournament in the playground of the G.M.U.P. School, Cherur shall not be treated as a precedent and any request for permission in future can be considered by the competent authority in accordance with law and in the light of the prevailing circumstances. The impugned judgment will stand modified to the above extent. The Registry is directed to immediately send a copy of this judgment to the District Collector and the Superintendent of Police for information and compliance.

Fact of the Case:

The first respondent, Secretary of the Diamond Arts and Sports Club, sought permission to conduct the 4th All India Sevens Football Tournament at the ground belonging to the G.M.U.P. School, Cherur. The Headmaster refused permission citing an order of the High Court that school premises cannot be used for any purpose other than educational purposes. The first respondent filed a writ petition seeking permission to conduct the tournament.

Finding of the Court:

The court directed the appellants to permit the first respondent to organize and conduct the All India Sevens Foot Ball Tournament in the playground of the G.M.U.P. School, Cherur between 20.1.2004 and 1.3.2004. The tournament shall not be conducted before 6.30 p.m. The organizers shall ensure that no damage is caused to the buildings and other properties of the school. After the tournament, the playground shall be restored to its original position by the first respondent. The first shall deposit with the third appellant – Headmaster, a sum of Rs.1,55,000/- before the start of the tournament. The said amount can be utilized by the third appellant in accordance with law for the construction of the Stage-cum-class room as proposed by the Parent Teacher Association or for other educational purposes of the school. On completion of the tournament, the first respondent shall contribute 60% of the profit to the school as promised. If the teachers and the students of the school request, they shall be given free passes to watch the tournament. The District Collector, Malappuram and the Superintendent of Police, Malappuram are directed to take all necessary steps to maintain law and order and to effectively prevent breach of peace and commission of offences during or in connection with the football tournament. This order granting permission to the first respondent to conduct the football tournament in the playground of the G.M.U.P. School, Cherur shall not be treated as a precedent and any request for permission in future can be considered by the competent authority in accordance with law and in the light of the prevailing circumstances. The impugned judgment will stand modified to the above extent. The Registry is directed to immediately send a copy of this judgment to the District Collector and the Superintendent of Police for information and compliance.

Issues: The main issue was whether the first respondent should be granted permission to conduct the 4th All India Sevens Football Tournament at the ground belonging to the G.M.U.P. School, Cherur.

Ratio Decidendi: The court held that the prohibition contained in Section 5B of the Kerala Education Act is against the sale, mortgage, lease, pledge, charge or transfer of possession of any land appurtenant to a Government School vested with a local authority and that the said prohibition cannot apply to the use of the playground of a government school for conducting a football tournament for a few days with the permission of the authority concerned. The court also directed the District Collector, Malappuram and the Superintendent of Police, Malappuram to take all necessary steps to maintain law and order and to effectively prevent breach of peace and commission of offences during or in connection with the football tournament.

Final Decision: The court directed the appellants to permit the first respondent to organize and conduct the All India Sevens Foot Ball Tournament in the playground of the G.M.U.P. School, Cherur between 20.1.2004 and 1.3.2004. The tournament shall not be conducted before 6.30 p.m. The organizers shall ensure that no damage is caused to the buildings and other properties of the school. After the tournament, the playground shall be restored to its original position by the first respondent. The first shall deposit with the third appellant – Headmaster, a sum of Rs.1,55,000/- before the start of the tournament. The said amount can be utilized by the third appellant in accordance with law for the construction of the Stage-cum-class room as proposed by the Parent Teacher Association or for other educational purposes of the school. On completion of the tournament, the first respondent shall contribute 60% of the profit to the school as promised. If the teachers and the students of the school request, they shall be given free passes to watch the tournament. The District Collector, Malappuram and the Superintendent of Police, Malappuram are directed to take all necessary steps to maintain law and order and to effectively prevent breach of peace and commission of offences during or in connection with the football tournament. This order granting permission to the first respondent to conduct the football tournament in the playground of the G.M.U.P. School, Cherur shall not be treated as a precedent and any request for permission in future can be considered by the competent authority in accordance with law and in the light of the prevailing circumstances. The impugned judgment will stand modified to the above extent. The Registry is directed to immediately send a copy of this judgment to the District Collector and the Superintendent of Police for information and compliance.

Judgment :-

Cyriac Joseph, J.

This appeal is filed against the judgment dated 10.12.2003 in W.P(C) No.38965 of 2003. The respondents in the writ petition are the appellants herein and the petitioner in the writ petition is the first respondent herein. The second respondent herein got himself impleaded as additional respondent No.2 in the writ appeal.

2. According to the averments in the writ petition, the petitioner (1st respondent herein) is the Secretary of the Diamond Arts and Sports Club, Cherur in Malappuram District. The said club is registered under the Societies Registration Act and its Registration No. is 412/89. The club was formed and promoted by the youngsters in the locality with a view to strengthen social welfare movement. The club has convened several sports and cultural events the income from which has been utilised for the well being of the Society. The first venture of the club was to construct a play ground for the G.M.U.P. School, Cherur. A play ground having 60 mtr. length and 50 mtr. width was constructed by the club in front of the school with the manual labour of the members of the club and spending about Rs.75,000/- Thereafter towards maintenance and development of the play ground the petitioner’s club has incurred an expense of Rupees Five Lakhs. The club has also done many other things for the benefit of the school like painting and maintenance of the school building, maintenance of the well, construction of the compound wall and gate, donation of motor pump set etc. After the construction of the play ground the club used to organise Sevens Foot Ball Tournament every year with the permission of the respondents in the writ petition. Initially Football Tournament was started for raising funds to meet the expenses for maintenance and development of the play ground. The third tournament was conducted in the year 2002 in the play ground of the school with the permission granted by the Headmaster of the school as per Ext.P2 order dated 29.11.2002. An amount of Rs.2500/- was paid as ground rent as demanded by the Headmaster. The tournament was conducted giving no room for complaint from any corner. It was also decided to construct a new Stage-cum-class room for the school in the place of the present damaged stage with the profit derived from the 3rd Football Tournament. On the basis of the said decision the Headmaster wrote Ext.P4 letter to the Deputy Director of Education, Malappuram, seeking permission to remove the old stage and to construct a new Stage-cum-class room with the profit from the Football Tournament as decided by the Executive Committee of the Parent-Teacher Association at its meeting held on 2.6.2003. The petitioner’s club decided to conduct the 4th All India Sevens Football Tournament from 5.12.2003 to 15.1.2004 in the playground of the G.M.U.P. School, Cherur. The tournament would be conducted only after 6.30 p.m. in the flood lit ground and there will be absolutely no disturbance to the functioning of the school. It was also decided to utilise the share of the profit from the tournament for the progress of the school, including installation of the computer system. The petitioner submitted Ext.P5 application dated 21.10.2003 to the Headmaster of the school seeking permission to conduct the tournament in the playground of the school. But as per Ext.P6 communication dated 25.10.2003 the Headmaster refused to grant permission on the ground that he had come to know from the newspapers and the Education Department that the Hon’ble High Court of Kerala had ordered that schools and their premises should not be allowed to be used for any purpose other than education purposes. The reason stated by the Headmaster is unsustainable and misconceived because the High Court has not said that school premises should not be granted for non-educational purposes under any circumstances. The High Court has only given some directions for ensuring smooth functioning of the schools and better atmosphere for the p

































1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top