2000 Supreme(Ker) 189
Judges : J.B.KOSHY
Leela - Appellant
Versus
Indira Gandhi National Open University - Respondent
Case No : O.P. No. 25436 of 1998
Decided On : 03/31/2000
Advocates Appeared :
Sergi Joseph Thomas For Petitioner P. Sukumaran Nair (Sr. Advocate) & P.MM. Najeeb Khan For Respondents
Headnote:
Constitution of India, Article 226 - Issued - Health - Service - Illegal - Report - After passing the ANM certificate course petitioner joined Kerala State Health Service as Junior Public Health Nurse in and has more than years experience in profession - Open University a Government aided institution has issued prospectus for admission Nursing degree programme - Above University is conducting courses to help economically backward persons who cannot afford studying in regular Universities to get higher education - Nursing course for in-service students was started for following objects as mentioned in Prospectus - Held, Decision reported in Central Board of Secondary Education also will not support respondent - When ineligible students were admitted as per Court order Supreme Court held that they should not be allowed to write examination - Reference was also made to decision reported in Admission Committee and another and another case there is no suppression of facts and after perusing application form and after satisfaction of eligibility conditions University itself gave admission and not by court order to admit the petitioner on provisional basis - Petition allowed
J.B. Koshy, J.
Petitioner is a scheduled caste student who completed B.Sc. Nursing programme in Indira Gandhi National Open University. Before joining B.Sc. Nursing course, she passed pre-degree course with science subjects as optionals (10+2) in the year 1987. She-also undergone Auxiliary Nurse Midwifery Certificate course conducted by the Kerala Nurses' and Midwifery Council in the year 1989. Duration of the above course is 18 months and is also recognized and accepted by the Indian Nursing Council. After passing the ANM certificate course petitioner joined the Kerala State Health Service as Junior Public Health Nurse in 1989 and has more than 81/2 years experience in the profession. Indira Gandhi National Open University, a Government aided institution has issued prospectus for admission to B.Sc. Nursing degree programme. The above University is conducting courses to help the economically backward persons who cannot afford studying in regular Universities to get higher education. B.Sc. Nursing course for the in-service students was started for the following objects as mentioned in the Prospectus:
"The preparation and launching of B.Sc. Nursing degree programme has been agreed upon by IGNOU, at the request of Indian Nursing Council. The need for this was felt as the current pace of providing higher education to working nurses is very slow due to shortage of colleges of Nursing and paucity of seats available in each. As per the New Policy on Education, the emphasis is on the need for making higher education available within the reach of all. Launching of B.Sc. Nursing programme through Open University will meet this objective. Further it also will contribute towards the growth of Nursing profession, promote nation's idea of accelerating women's education and uplifting the weaker sections of the society while ensuring better health care services for the country. The development of this programme has been undertaken with the involvement of nursing experts and scientists and educationists from related disciplines."
2. Main objective of the programme was to provide opportunity to a large segment of in-service nurses to upgrade their knowledge and skills. Eligibility criteria was mentioned in paragraph 2.2 of the prospectus which is as follows:
"2.2 Eligibility Criteria for Admission to the programme
The admission is open to in-service nurses working in the hospital and community.
i) Those who have passed 10+2 with three years Diploma in General Nursing and Midwifery or any other nursing course of 6-9 months duration lieu of midwifery with minimum of two years of experience in the profession; or
ii) Those who have passed 10th class (Matriculation) or its equivalent with three years Diploma in General Nursing and Midwifery or any nursing course of 6-9 months duration in lieu of midwifery with minimum of five years of experience in profession.
Only those candidates who satisfy the eligibility criteria fixed by the University will be considered for admission."
Since the petitioner had 10+2 educational qualification with certificate in nursing course of 18 months duration and more than eight years of experience and was an in-service candidate, she applied for admission to the B.Sc. Nursing programme. After going through the necessary documents, petitioners were admitted to the above course. Paragraph 2.2 of the prospectus states that only those candidates who satisfy the eligibility criteria fixed by the University will be considered for admission and they were considered and petitioner was given admission in 1995. She had undergone the course in the Centres and the agreed fee for the programme was also remitted.
3. She studied and completed both theory and practical of the first year course as well as second year course and remitted fee, for the third year and completed the course. Her practical examination was over. She attended 90% of the theory classes and cent percent of the practical classes. She attended the final year practi