1998 Supreme(Ker) 248
Judges : S.KRISHNAN UNNI
John - Appellant
Versus
Bishop of the Diocese of Palai - Respondent
Case No : A.S. No. 180 of 1988
Decided On : 06/26/1998
Advocates Appeared :
P.G. Parameswara Panicker & Ashok M. Cheriyan For Appellants Abdul Sammad C.S.,Legy Abraham, K.J. Arby, K.M. Joseph, John Joseph Vettikad & Jommy Tharian., For Respondents
Important Points
Subject
Property Law - Easements and Rights of Way
Act Referred
EASEMENTS ACT : S.60(b), S.60(a)
Headnote
Family Vault Rights - Church Cemetery - Indian Easements Act - The court found that the permission granted to the plaintiffs did not amount to an irrevocable licence under S.60(a) of the Easement Act. The plaintiffs failed to establish an irrevocable grant in their favor. The court held that the right to bury the dead in the family vaults was subject to the convenience of the Church and the larger interest of the community. The court dismissed the appeal, finding that the plaintiffs had failed to establish the right pleaded in the plaint.
Fact of the Case:
The plaintiffs, parishioners of St. Mary's Forane Church, sought a declaration that they and members of their families are entitled to permanent use of the vaults or graves allotted to them and the right to bury the dead there. They also sought an injunction against the defendants obstructing them from doing so or obliterating the vaults in any manner. The defendants, including the Bishop and Vicar of the Church, contested the claim, arguing that the Church had the right to shift the family vaults to accommodate the growing number of pilgrims visiting the cemetery.
Finding of the Court:
The court found that the permission granted to the plaintiffs did not amount to an irrevocable licence under S.60(a) of the Easement Act. The court held that the right to bury the dead in the family vaults was subject to the convenience of the Church and the larger interest of the community. The court dismissed the appeal, finding that the plaintiffs had failed to establish the right pleaded in the plaint.
Issues: The court considered whether the plaintiffs had an irrevocable grant in their favor and whether they were entitled to the reliefs claimed, including a declaration, injunction, and damages.
Ratio Decidendi: The court held that the right to bury the dead in the family vaults was subject to the convenience of the Church and the larger interest of the community. The court found that the permission granted to the plaintiffs did not amount to an irrevocable licence under S.60(a) of the Easement Act. The court also found that the plaintiffs had failed to establish the right pleaded in the plaint.
Final Decision: The court dismissed the appeal, finding that the plaintiffs had failed to establish the right pleaded in the plaint. The court held that the permission granted to the plaintiffs did not amount to an irrevocable licence under S.60(a) of the Easement Act.
S. Krishnan Unni, J.
Plaintiffs 1 to 9 and 11 in O.S.207 of 1984 of Additional Sub Court, Kottayam are the appellants.
2. First defendant is the Bishop of Diocese of Palai and 2nd defendant is the Vicar of St. Mary's Forane Church, Bharananganam.:. Defendants 3 to 5 are the Trustees of the said Church.
3. Plaintiffs prayed for a declaration that they and members, of their families are entitled to permanent use of the vaults or graves allotted to them and they are entitled to bury the dead there. They also sought an injunction against" the defendants obstructing them from doing so or obliterating the vaults in any manner. They also prayed that they may be allowed to transfer the mortal remains of trie-dead buried away from their family vaults to the family vault. They have further sought damages of Rs. 101/- each for the act of the defendants in preventing them from burying the dead in the family vault.
4. I will briefly state the contentions in the plaint. Plaintiffs are parishioners of St. Mary's Forane Church, Bharanaganam comprised in Palai Diocese. They sought permission to sue as representing the other members of their families. Plaint schedule property is that part of the cemetery attached to the Church where vaults are allotted to the families of plaintiffs for burial of the dead. It is a sacred place which cannot be put to any other use, nor can any one prevent its use, ie. to bury the dead. A number of vaults were constructed using the money advanced by members of the Church. Such vaults were allotted as family vaults on receipt of Rs. 2000/-. This was done in 1965-66. The family vaults were allotted on receipt of payment to those members of family for all time to come. This was done with the approval and consent of the Bishop. Usually persons who do not belong to the family who possessed the vaults will not be buried there. After the vault was allotted, plaintiffs spent their money and put up permanent slab over the grave. The obligation to preserve a grave is absolute and no grave in a cemetery duly blessed can be obliterated, converted or dealt with otherwise for secular or other uses. Defendants or the plaint parish had no right or authority to derogate from the grant made in perpetuity to the plaintiffs and the other members of their families. On 10.8.1984 Sri. Ulahannan Devassy, father of plaintiffs 1 to 4 expired. They wanted to bury him in the family vault allotted to them. Second defendant refused permission to bury him in the family vault, on the ground that the parish yogam had taken decision not to allow burials in the old cemetery and that future burials would be made in the new vaults constructed by the church. If there is any such resolution of the general body it is not approved by the Bishop. An appeal was made to the Bishop by plaintiffs 1 to 4 without any success. Plaintiffs 1 to 4 were forced to bury the body of the deceased in the place pointed out by the Vicar. Similarly, 9th plaintiffs father's brother who died on 23.9.1984 was also refused permission to be buried in the family vault and he was also buried in the new place. Plaintiffs had suffered mental agony and pain on account of such refusal on the part of the Vicar. Plaintiffs would allege that they are entitled to claim damages for the mental agony caused but they limited it to Rs. 101 each. It is understood that defendants intend to obliterate and demolish the plaint vaults in order to convert the site for other uses. They are doing so in the pretext of honour ing Sister Alphonsa who is buried in the cemetery.
5. Defendants had filed separate written statements, raising more or less the same contentions. According to them no vault as such was allotted to any parishioner but permission was granted to few members of the Parish to bury their relatives in the vault constructed by the Church in the chapel in the cemetery. Such permission would not create any right or interest in the land. Sr. Alphonsa was buried in this cemetery and lar