SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

1995 Supreme(Ker) 4

Judges : K.SREEDHARAN,B.N.PATNAIK
Hariharan - Appellant
Versus
State of Kerala - Respondent
Case No : W.A. No. 1690 of 1994
Decided On : 01/04/1995
Advocates Appeared :
R. Ramkumar For Appellant Govt. Pleader (Lai George) For State

Important Points

The main legal point established in the judgment is that the Deputy Director of Education had no jurisdiction to interfere with the permission granted by the headmistress of the school, and any violation of the Government order by the headmistress would not confer jurisdiction on the Deputy Director of Education to interfere with the permission granted.

Subject

Administrative Law - Jurisdiction

Act Referred

EDUCATION RULES : R.15(a)(1), R.15

Headnote

Jurisdiction - Government School - Rule 15, Rule 15A(1) of Chapter IV KER - The court held that the Deputy Director of Education had no jurisdiction to interfere with the sanction given to the petitioner for holding 'sibiram' in the school. The headmistress of the school, as the authority competent to accord the sanction under Rule 15(1) of Chapter IV K.E.R., was empowered to grant permission for the use of the building of the school for any purpose. The Government order issued under Rule 15A of Chapter IV K.E.R. binds the headmistress of the school, and any violation of it would entail disciplinary action. However, the violation by the headmistress would not confer any jurisdiction on the Deputy Director of Education to interfere with the permission granted. The court concluded that the action taken by the Deputy Director of Education in issuing the order to revoke the permission was without jurisdiction.

Fact of the Case:

The appellant, a writ petitioner, sought permission to conduct patanasibiram (Instructors Training Course) in a Government High School. The headmistress granted permission, but it was later revoked by the Deputy Director of Education without notice to the petitioner.

Finding of the Court:

The court found that the Deputy Director of Education had no jurisdiction to interfere with the permission granted by the headmistress, and the order to revoke the permission was issued without jurisdiction. The court also noted that the headmistress should have taken note of the Government order while granting permission and any violation of it would entail disciplinary action.

Issues: The main issue was whether the Deputy Director of Education had the jurisdiction to interfere with the permission granted by the headmistress, and whether the order to revoke the permission was issued in violation of the principles of natural justice.

Ratio Decidendi: The court held that the Deputy Director of Education had no jurisdiction to interfere with the permission granted by the headmistress, and any violation of the Government order by the headmistress would not confer jurisdiction on the Deputy Director of Education to interfere with the permission granted.

Final Decision: The Writ Appeal was disposed of with the observation that the Deputy Director of Education had no jurisdiction to interfere with the permission granted, and the order to revoke the permission was without jurisdiction.

Judgment :-

Sreedharan, J.

Heard counsel for the appellant and the learned Government Pleader, who advanced arguments after getting instructions from the Government.

2. Writ petitioner in O.P. 18131 of 1994 is the appellant. He applied- for permission to conduct patanasibiram (Instructors Training Course) in the Government High School, Pulamanthole. The headmistress of the school granted permission to conduct discussions and classes in the school as per Ext. P2 order dated 8-11-1994. That order was cancelled by the Deputy Director of Education, Malappuram by Ext. P3 dated 19-12-1994. According to the petitioner, Deputy Director of Education, the second respondent has no jurisdiction to interfere with Ext. P2 order passed by the headmistress of (lie school and that the order Ext. P3 is void in so far as it was issued without notice to the petitioner. Learned single judge came to the conclusion that the Deputy Director is not invested with any authority to revoke the order passed by the headmistress and that Ext. P3 order is bad for not giving an opportunity to the . petitioner of being heard in the matter. But the learned judge did not interfere with the order passed by the Deputy Director on the ground that the Deputy Director had in his mind that there would be some sort of communal disharmony or any other matters in the matter of granting permission to the petitioner to use the school premises. Consequently, the original petition was dismissed. Hence this appeal.

2. The short question that arises for consideration is whether the Deputy Director of Education, the second respondent had any jurisdiction to interfere with the sanction given to the petitioner for holding 'sibiram' in the school.

3. Rule 15 of Chapter IV of Kerala Education Rules provides that the premises of an educational institution (Government or private) shall ordinarily be used only for the purpose of functions conducted by such institution. But the executive authority of local body concerned in the case of an institution under the control of a local body, the District Educational Officer in the case of a Government School and the manager in the case of a Private school is empowered to grant permission for the use of the school building or the ground, for holding public functions arranged by the management or by a department of the Stale or the Government of India or for any other purposes. From this it is clear that in the case of a Government School, the District Education officer can grant permission for the use of the school premises for any purpose. This power vested with District Educational Officer under Rule 15(1), it is conceded, has now become vested in the headmasters of Government schools. It therefore follows that the third respondent before us namely the headmistress of the Government School, Pulamanthole is empowered to grant permission for the use of the building of the school for any purpose. Petitioner applied for permission to conduct 'patana sibiram' in the Government High School, Pulamanthole. Third respondent, the headmistress of the school, who is the authority competent to accord the sanction under Rule 15(1) of Chapter IV K.E.R. allowed the prayer as evidenced by Ext. P2 order.

4. Rule 15A(1) of Chapter IV KER states that notwithstanding anything contained in Rule 15, Government shall have power to issue directions that the school buildings and their properties (whether Government or private) shall not be used for any purpose specified in such directions. The directions so issued by Government shall be binding on the departmental authorities and the educational agencies. This shows that in case, Government has issued any direction contemplated by Rule 15A(1) of Chapter IV, provisions contained therein will be binding on all authorities which are to accord permission under Rule 15(1) of Chapter IV KER. In case the direction given by the Government under Rule 15A(1) is violated, the Government alone has got the power to take action to cance






1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top