1975 Supreme(Ker) 7
Judges : G.VISWANATHA IYER,G.BALAGANGADHARAN NAIR
M.CHANDA PILLAI AND OTHERS - Appellant
Versus
DANIEL MAR PHILAXINOSE AND OTHERS - Respondent
Case No : C. M. A. No. 159,169 of 1974
Decided On : 01/08/1975
Advocates Appeared :
M. C. Chagla; P. P. John; T. K. M. Nambiar; For Appellants K. Velayudhan Nair; M. Abraram; A. K. Chinnan; For Respondents
Important Points
Subject
Civil Law - Trusts and Estates
Act Referred
Headnote
Trust - Church Dispute - Canon Law - [Trust, Church Dispute, Canon Law] - The court discussed the trust and management of the church, the dispute between the parties, and the adherence to Canon law. The key legal provisions discussed include the trust on which the church properties are held, the authority and powers of the Patriarch of Antioch, and the adherence to the rules of Canon. The court's decision was influenced by the interpretation of the trust, the adherence to Canon law, and the authority of the Patriarch of Antioch.
Fact of the Case:
The case involved a dispute over the management of a church between two parties, each claiming authority over the church and its affairs. The plaintiffs sought an injunction to restrain the defendants from interfering with the church's affairs.
Finding of the Court:
The court found that the plaintiffs did not establish a prima facie case for the grant of an injunction against the defendants. The court also dismissed the appeal for the appointment of a Receiver for the management of the church's affairs.
Issues: The main contention was whether the defendants had deviated from the accepted faith and creed of the church, and whether they had the authority to manage the church's affairs independently.
Ratio Decidendi: The court held that the plaintiffs failed to establish a prima facie case for the grant of an injunction. It also found that there was no evidence to show that each party had the authority to manage their own affairs independently in the church.
Final Decision: The court dismissed the appeals and upheld the lower court's decision. It also emphasized the importance of adhering to the constitution and the book of Canon in religious affairs.
1. These two civil miscellaneous appeals arise out of two orders passed by the Sub Court, Pathanamthitta, in O.S. No. 69 of 1973. C M A No. 159/74 is against an order refusing to grant an injunction restraining the respondents and their agents and representatives from interfering with any of the affairs of the plaint church, viz., St. Thomas Valiya Palli at Omallur which is a Jacobite Syrian Church. Four plaintiffs, alleging themselves to be members of that Church and its Managing Committee, filed the suit for a declaration that the plaint church and the properties appertaining thereto are held by the parishioners upon trust and be managed as such and alternatively for a declaration that there are two independent sections in the plaint church known as Patriarch section represented by the plaintiffs and defendants 2, 5 and 7 and the Catholicose section represented by defendants 1, 3, 4 and 6, and that they are entitled to manage their own affairs in the plaint church. The said church was founded some 500 years ago for the worship of God according to the faith, doctrine and practice of the Jacobite Syrian Christian Church with the Patriarch of Antioch as its head. The original purpose of the foundation was to remain independent of any superior religious organisation and to be governed by its own members or by persons elected by them. According to the faith of the founders of the plaint church, the priests and the other religious dignitaries must have received spiritual grace from the Holy Throne of St. Peter and no other. It is their faith that the spiritual grace and apostolic succession can be obtained only from the Throne of St. Peter on which the Patriarch is seated The plaint church and the properties appertaining thereto are held subject to a trust that the same shall, at all times be used for the above purposes without any deviation. The practice and discipline of the plaint church enjoin that the Metropolitan thereof must be a Bishop consecrated by the hands or under the authority and commission of the Patriarch of Antioch who is the successor on the Throne of St. Peter and be accepted or elected by the people over whom he exercises power; that the Metropolitans, Kathanars, and Parishioners shall owe allegiance to and be obedient to the said Patriarch in all spiritual matters concerning the Jacobite Syrian Church; that all religious dignitaries in the Parish church including the Metropolitan shall at the time of their ordination take an oath of obedience and loyalty to the supreme spiritual head of the Church, the Patriarch of Antioch; and that the jurisdiction and powers of all religious dignitaries above the rank of Kathanars and Vicars are confined to purely spiritual matters only. The Jacobite Syrian Church including the plaint church adopted the book containing the rules of Canon which has been accepted by the Patriarch of Antioch. Subject to usage, these rules are followed in all ecclesiastical matters. The Malankara Jacobite Syrian Association or the Thumpamon Diocesan Council or any other body has no control over the administration of the plaint church which is an independent unit by itself. For long there were two parties in the Malankara Sabha, and after a decision of the Supreme Court in 1958, a union of the two parties was attempted. The differences between the parties regarding the correct version of the book of Canons, regarding the constitution and regarding the powers of the Patriarch. Catholicose and Metropolitans remained unsettled. In 1964 there was a further attempt for the union of the above parties when the Patriarch of Antioch ordained a Catholicose of the East. The two parties agreed to have the religious service in the plaint church conducted by their own priests on every alternate week. But, subsequent events have convinced the plaintiffs and those who go with them that the Catholicose party had no bona fides in their profession and are attempting to liquidate the Partiarch party. De