SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

1974 Supreme(Ker) 26

Judges : GEORGE VADAKKEL
XAVIER - Appellant
Versus
STATE OF KERALA AND OTHERS - Respondent
Case No : O. P. No. 2402 of 1973
Decided On : 02/12/1974
Advocates Appeared :
Petitioner; In person Government Pleader; N. Govinda Warrier; P. C. Chacko; For Respondents

Important Points

The judgment established the reasonableness of restrictions on legal practitioners' conduct in the interests of the general public, as provided in R.20 and 21 of the Bar Council Rules.

Subject

Civil Law - Legal Profession and Ethics

Act Referred

ADVOCATES ACT : S.49(c)
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA : Art.226

Headnote

certiorari - Land Acquisition Reference Case - Advocates' Act, 1961, Bar Council of India Rules, Kerala Civil Rules of Practice 1971 - The court discussed the petitioner's fundamental rights under Art.14 and 19(1)(g) of the Constitution, and also R.15, 23, 25, 26, 28, 29, 32, 33, 38 and 39 of the Bar Council of India Rules framed under S.49(c) of the Advocates' Act, 1961. The court also considered R.27 and 28 of the Kerala Civil Rules of Practice 1971, R.37 of the Advocates Fee Rules, 1963 and R.7(1) and 9 of the Rules framed by this Court under S.34(1) of the Advocates' Act, 1961. The court upheld the provisions of R.20 and 21 of the Bar Council Rules as reasonable restrictions on the conduct of legal practitioners in the interests of the general public.

Fact of the Case:

The petitioner, an advocate, sought to quash an order passed by the Subordinate Judge and another order passed by the High Court in a land acquisition reference case. The petitioner alleged violation of his fundamental rights and engaged in a dispute with the 5th respondent over the engagement and remuneration terms.

Finding of the Court:

The court found that the petitioner's invocation of Art.226 of the Constitution for resolution of disputes with the 5th respondent was not maintainable. The court also rejected the petitioner's contention regarding his fundamental rights and upheld the provisions of R.20 and 21 of the Bar Council Rules as reasonable restrictions.

Issues: The issues involved the petitioner's engagement and remuneration terms, violation of fundamental rights, and the maintainability of the petition under Art.226 of the Constitution.

Ratio Decidendi: The court held that the petitioner's invocation of Art.226 for resolution of disputes with the 5th respondent was not maintainable. The court also upheld the provisions of R.20 and 21 of the Bar Council Rules as reasonable restrictions on the conduct of legal practitioners.

Final Decision: The original petition was dismissed with costs as an abuse of the process of the court.

Judgment :-

1. An advocate practising in this Court is the petitioner before me. He moves for a certiorari to quash Ext. P1 order, an order passed by the Subordinate Judge, Parur (3rd respondent herein) in an interlocutory application in a land acquisition reference case, and Ext. P2 order passed by my learned brother Poti J in CRP. Nos. 555 and 556 of 1972. The petitioner has in the alternative asked for a writ of quo warranto or a writ of mandamus, and if found essential, all three writs. It is also prayed that the vakalath filed by the 4th respondent in L.A.R. No. 235 of 1969 be declared as invalid. There is also a prayer to issue a writ of prohibition prohibiting the 4th respondent from appearing as an Advocate on behalf of the 5th respondent. Further it is prayed that the petitioner's lien on the decree amount in L.A.R. No. 235 of 1969 'be kept alive'.

2. The short facts on which the petitioner has approached this Court with the prayers aforementioned are: The petitioner filed on behalf of the 5th respondent before me O. P. No. 918 of 1966 for compelling reference in certain land acquisition proceedings. He filed a similar original petition, O. P. No. 821 of 1966 on behalf of one Varghese also. These original petitions appear to have been allowed. In pursuance of the direction issued by this Court in the aforesaid writ petitions, the land acquisition officer referred the two cases to the Subordinate Judge's Court, Parur. That Court tried the same as L. A. R. Nos. 235 of 1969 and 21 of 1970. The above said reference cases were decided in favour of the persons interested in the land whereby the compensation amounts were enhanced. In execution proceedings they engaged the 4th respondent before me as their lawyer. It is the case of the petitioner that these engagements are violative of his fundamental rights under Art.14 and 19(1) (g) of the Constitution, and also R.15, 23, 25, 26, 28, 29, 32, 33, 38 and 39 of the Bar Council of India Rules framed under S.49(c) of the Advocates' Act, 1961. It is also contended before me that the engagement of the 4th respondent by the 5th respondent is violative of R.27 and 28 of the Kerala Civil Rules of Practice 1971, R.37 of the Advocates Fee Rules, 1963 and R.7(1) and 9 of the Rules framed by this Court under S.34(1) of the Advocates' Act, 1961. Presumably with these grounds in mind the petitioner filed applications for special leave to execute the two decrees. Ext. P1 is the order passed by the execution court on the application put in by the petitioner seeking leave for executing the decree in L.A.R. 235 of 1969. By that order the Subordinate Judge held that the petition is not maintainable and in consequence rejected the petitioner's application. Similar petition filed in L.A.R. No. 21 of 1970 also met with the same result. The two orders were taken up in revision to this Court in CRP. No. 555 and 556 of 1972. Ext. P2 is the common order passed by my learned brother Poti J. in the aforesaid revision petitions. The revision petitions were dismissed. Subsequent to the disposal of the civil revision petitions the petitioner filed two original petitions, O.P. No. 2343 of 1973 to redress his grievance in not being allowed to execute the decree in L.A.R. No. 21 of 1970 and this petition in respect of his grievance for not being allowed to execute the decree in the other L. A. R. case. O. P. No. 2343 of 1973 was dismissed by my learned brother Eradi J. by his judgment dated 23 71973. The 5th respondent has produced a true copy of that judgment marked Ext. RI along with his counter affidavit.

3. The main argument raised by the petitioner is that under Rules referred to earlier another counsel cannot enter appearance on behalf of a client without the consent and permission of the counsel already on record. In Para.2 of the counter affidavit the 5th respondent has stated that the petitioner's engagement was terminated by her. In answer thereto in the reply affidavit it is stated that there was no











1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top