SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Judicial Analysis Court Copy Headnote Facts Arguments Court observation
Listen Audio Icon Pause Audio Icon
judgment-img

1961 Supreme(Ker) 83

Judges : M.MADHAVAN NAIR
Kolavan - Appellant
Versus
Allu Acha Menon - Respondent
Case No : C. M. P. No. 2291 of 1961
Decided On : 05/12/1961
Advocates Appeared :
K. P. Gopalakrishnan; For Petitioner

The main legal point established in the judgment is that the Vacation Judge is empowered to hear urgent matters requiring immediate or prompt attention by the High Court and has the powers of a Single Judge of that Court. However, the Vacation Judge is only empowered to make provisional orders in urgent matters in suits, appeals, or other proceedings which normally lie in subordinate courts, and such provisional orders are of ad interim nature and are not to be made final by the Vacation Judge.

Headnote:

Vacation Judge - Powers of Vacation Judge - The court discussed the powers of a vacation judge as defined by the Kerala High Court Act and the Kerala Civil Courts Act. It clarified that the Vacation Judge is empowered to hear all matters requiring immediate or prompt attention by the High Court and has all the powers of a Single Judge of that Court. However, the Vacation Judge is only empowered to make provisional orders in urgent matters in suits, appeals, or other proceedings which normally lie in subordinate courts, and such provisional orders are of ad interim nature and are not to be made final by the Vacation Judge.

Fact of the Case:

The petition was to call up an interlocutory application in a subordinate civil court to be disposed of finally by the Vacation Judge. The interlocutory application was for the issue of a temporary injunction and had been ordered ad interim by the learned Munsiff.

Finding of the Court:

The court found that the petition for passing final orders on the interlocutory application, which was pending in a subordinate civil court, was misconceived as the Vacation Judge is not competent to do so. Therefore, the petition was dismissed.

Issues: The issue was whether the Vacation Judge had the authority to pass final orders on an interlocutory application pending in a subordinate civil court.

Ratio Decidendi: The court clarified that the Vacation Judge is empowered to hear urgent matters requiring immediate or prompt attention by the High Court and has the powers of a Single Judge of that Court. However, the Vacation Judge is only empowered to make provisional orders in urgent matters in suits, appeals, or other proceedings which normally lie in subordinate courts, and such provisional orders are of ad interim nature and are not to be made final by the Vacation Judge.

Final Decision: The petition for passing final orders on the interlocutory application pending in a subordinate civil court was dismissed as the Vacation Judge was not competent to do so.

Judgement Key Points

Key Points: - The Vacation Judge has all the powers of a Single Judge to hear matters requiring immediate or prompt attention by the High Court (!) (!) (!) . - The Vacation Judge may only make provisional orders in urgent matters in suits, appeals, or proceedings which ordinarily lie in subordinate courts, and such orders are ad interim and not final (!) (!) (!) . - Final orders cannot be passed by the Vacation Judge on interlocutory applications pending in subordinate civil courts; such petitions are misconceived and are dismissed (!) (!) (!) . - Provisional orders issued by the Vacation Judge remain in force until the matter is heard and decided by the subordinate court or until further order, and may be subject to modification on proper motion (!) . - The powers of the Vacation Judge are defined by S.8 of the Kerala High Court Act for High Court matters and S.3(11) read with S.19(2) of the Kerala Civil Courts Act for matters in subordinate courts (!) (!) (!) . - S.19(2) of the Kerala Civil Courts Act provides that during adjournment of a Civil Court, the High Court may make provisional orders in urgent matters and such orders remain in force until the matter is heard and decided by the competent court (!) .

How to determine the powers of a Vacation Judge in urgent matters?

What is the scope of provisional orders by the Vacation Judge vs. final orders in subordinate proceedings?

What are the statutory provisions governing the Vacation Judge's authority under the Kerala High Court Act and related Civil Courts Act?


Judgment :-

1. This is a petition to call up I.A. No. 909 of 1961 in O.S. No.171 of 1961, now pending disposal in the Munsiff's Court, Alathur, to be disposed of finally by the Vacation Judge. That I.A. is for the issue of a temporary injunction and it has been ordered ad interim by the learned Munsiff.

2. The powers of a vacation judge are defined by S.8 of the Kerala High Court Act (Act V of 1959) so far as matters which lie in the High Court, and by S.3(11) of the same Act read with S.19(2) of the Kerala Civil Courts Act (I of 1957) so far as matters which ordinarily lie in the subordinate civil courts, are concerned.

3. S.8 of the Kerala High Court Act provides: "8. Power of Vacation Judge.

(1) During the adjournment of the High Court the Chief Justice shall nominate a Single Judge of the High Court for the hearing of all matters which require to be immediately or promptly dealt with and such judge shall have all the powers of the High Court, except in cases in which such power must be exercised under the provisions of any law by more than one judge.

(2) It shall be competent for the Chief Justice during any such adjournment of the High Court to constitute a Bench of two or a Full Bench for the hearing of any case."

S. 3 of the Kerala High Court Act runs: "3. Powers of Single Judge.

The powers of the High Court in relation to the following matters may be exercised by a Single Judge, provided that the judge before whom the matter is posted for hearing may adjourn it for being heard and determined by a Bench of two Julges: -

(1)

(ii) exercise all the powers under sub-section (2) of S.19 of the Kerala Civil Courts Act, 1957. '

............................................

And S.19(2) of the Kerala Civil Courts Act reads:

"During the adjournment of a Civil Court, the High Court shall have the powers to make provisional orders in all urgent matters and for such purpose to receive appeals, plaints and petitions which would ordinarily be presented to such civil Court and any such order shall remain in force only until the matter has been heard and decided by the Court having jurisdiction."

4. By S.8 of the Kerala High Court Act the Vacation Judge is empowered to hear all matters requiring to be immediately or promptly dealt with by the High Court and has all the powers of the High Court exercisable by a Single Judge of that Court in disposing the same. Under the latter provisions the Vacation judge is empowered only to make provisional orders in urgent matters in suits, appeals or other proceedings which normally lie in subordinate courts and it is expressly provided therein that such provisional orders are to remain in force only until the matters have been heard and decided by the subordinate Courts concerned. It is clear therefore that such provisional orders are of ad interim nature & that the final orders thereon are not to be made by the Vacation Judge. The power to make provisional orders may imply the power to cancel the same on proper motion; otherwise the provisional orders will continue in force till the subordinate civil court having jurisdiction in the matter has heard and disposed of the same. This petition being one for passing final orders on an interlocutory application now pending in a subordinate civil court, which the Vacation Judge is not competent to do, is misconceived. It is accordingly dismissed.

Click Here to Read the rest of this document

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
logo-black

An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers

Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance

qr

Scan Me!

India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!

For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :

whatsapp-icon Back to top