IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA
P.N. RAVINDRAN, P.B. SURESH KUMAR, P. SOMARAJAN, JJ.
SHAJI SANJAYI NOTTITHODI - Appellant
Versus
MANAGING DIRECTOR - Respondent
WA. No. 302 of 2014
Decided On : 26-05-2017
P.B. SURESH KUMAR, J.
1. The above batch of writ appeals have been placed before this Full Bench on a reference by a Division Bench. The issue that falls for consideration is whether the employees of the Kerala State Road Transport Corporation ('the Corporation') who rejoin duty after availing Leave Without Allowances for taking up employment elsewhere would lose cadre seniority impairing their right to claim cadre promotion. The issue was answered in the affirmative by a learned Single Judge in a batch of writ petitions. Writ Appeal No.302 of 2014 is preferred by the employee concerned in one of the said writ petitions challenging the said decision of the learned Single Judge. The issue was answered in the negative by another learned Single Judge in another batch of writ petitions. Writ Appeal Nos.936, 1044, 1128, 1147, 1165, 1244, 1274, 1345, 1349, 1355, 1363, 1438, 1451, 1491 & 1617 of 2015 are preferred by the Corporation challenging the decision of the learned Single Judge in the said batch of cases. Writ Appeal No.566 of 2014 is one preferred by the Corporation challenging the decision of yet another learned Single Judge wherein also the issue was answered in the negative.
2. When the writ appeals came up for hearing, the Division Bench noticed that in Krishna Warrier v. Devendran [2005 (4) KLT short note 51] and in W.A.No.1810 of 2013, in the case of employees of the Corporation, Division Benches of this Court affirmed the view taken by the learned Single Judge in the batch of cases from which W.A.Nos.936 of 2015 and connected cases arise and in Abdul Razak v. State of Kerala [2006 (1) KLT 818], in the case of a Government employee governed by identical rules, another Division Bench took the view that merely for the reason that the seniority of a person who avails Leave Without Allowances is protected as against juniors who are not promoted to the higher cadre by virtue of the provisions contained in Appendix XIIA to Part I Kerala Service Rules (KSR), he is not entitled to reckon the said period for the purpose of claiming higher grades in the cadre. It was also noticed by the Division Bench that in State of Kerala v. Thomas [2015 (1) KLT 863], a Full Bench of this Court took the view that the period of Leave Without Allowances availed by private college teachers for taking up employment elsewhere cannot be reckoned for placement under the Scheme of the University Grants Commission ('UGC Scheme'). In the light of the conflicting views aforesaid, the Division Bench felt it appropriate to refer the issue for adjudication by a Full Bench. The reference aforesaid was made in the above background.
3. Heard the learned Senior Counsel Sri. Jaju Babu for the employees of the Corporation and the learned Standing Counsel Dr. Thushara James for the Corporation.
4. The facts of the cases are similar. The learned Single Judge has decided the issue in the writ petitions from which Writ Appeal No.936 of 2015 and connected cases arise, with reference to the facts in W.P.(C).No.7813 of 2014. As such, the facts and the documents in the said case are taken as the basis for deciding the issue in this batch of writ appeals as well. The petitioner in the said case was recruited as a Reserve Conductor in the service of the Corporation on the advice of the Kerala Public Service Commission. After completing probation, the petitioner had gone on Leave Without Allowances for the period from 15.11.2008 to 06.10.2010 for securing employment abroad. He rejoined duty on the expiry of the period of leave on 07.10.2010. When the petitioner rejoined duty after the leave period, his rank in the seniority list was re-fixed from the position 3002 to the position 3847A and the juniors of the petitioner have been promoted to the higher cadre superseding him. The petitioner approached this Court, in the circumstances, seeking among others, directions to restore his original seniority and rank and for promotion to the higher cadre with effect from the da
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.