2026 Supreme(Ker) 997
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
MOHAMMED NIAS C.P., J.
Prameela Varghese, W/o. Varghese Koshy - Appellant
Versus
Abraham Samuel, S/o. Samuel & Ors. - Respondents
RFA No. 173 of 2006 (F)
Decided On : 29-07-2026
Important Points
Subject
Civil Law - Recovery of Money
Act Referred
EVIDENCE ACT : S.43
Headnote
(B) Cheque - Execution vs. Signing - Execution requires voluntary delivery - Mere proof of signature is insufficient to invoke statutory presumptions if execution is specifically denied - Burden of proof remains on plaintiff to establish foundational fact of execution - Trial court incorrectly conflated signature with execution. (Paras 20-25)
Facts of the case:
The respondent filed a suit for recovery of money alleging the appellant issued a cheque for a debt. The appellant contested the suit, claiming the cheque was unauthorized and asserting that her husband had sole control over the relevant account. A prior criminal complaint for cheque dishonour resulted in the acquittal of the appellant. The trial court decreed the suit, ruling that the execution was proved.
Findings of Court:
The court found that while a signature was present on the cheque, the evidence provided by the plaintiff regarding the transaction and the voluntary delivery of the cheque was inadequate. The court rejected the argument that the acquittal in criminal proceedings bound the civil court but held that the plaintiff failed to discharge the foundational burden of proving the execution of the instrument.
Issues: Whether the acquittal in criminal proceedings bars the civil suit; whether the execution of the cheque was sufficiently established to invoke statutory presumptions of liability.
Ratio Decidendi: An acquittal in criminal proceedings does not bind a civil court, which must independently assess evidence. The execution of a cheque requires both signature and voluntary delivery. When execution is denied, the initial burden lies on the plaintiff to prove valid issuance before statutory presumptions can apply; proving a signature does not constitute proof of execution.
Result: Appeal allowed; suit dismissed.
For the Appellant : Shri. G. Sreekumar (Chelur).
For the Respondent: Sri. B.S. Swathi Kumar, Sri. Harisankar N. Unni, Smt. Anitha Ravindran.
JUDGMENT :
The defendant in a suit for realisation of money filed by the respondent/plaintiff is the appellant.
2. O.S. No.57/2003 was filed for recovery of an amount of Rs.3,31,100/- alleging that the appellant and her husband had approached the respondent/plaintiff and borrowed money for business purposes and that a cheque was issued by the defendant for repayment of the said amount.
3. The appellant contended that she had neither borrowed any amount nor issued any cheque, and that her husband, whose whereabouts are not known, may have handed over a cheque leaf from their joint account, leading to the fabrication of the cheque. It is alleged that there is a substantial difference in the signature.
4. The cheque was dishonoured when it was presented, and though a criminal complaint was filed, the appellant was acquitted. Thus, the suit was filed claiming the principal amount of Rs.2,15,000/- along with interest at the rate of 15% per annum, totalling Rs.3,31,100/-.
5. The trial court framed issues as to whether the plaintiff is entitled to get the plaint amount as alleged and whether the defendant has drawn the cheque towards the discharge of the amount as alleged.
6. On behalf of the plaintiff, Ext. A1, the alleged cheque, A2 Dishonour Memo and the post-acknowledgement to lawyer notice A3 were marked. The specimen signature card maintained by the bank was summoned and marked as Exhibit X1. On behalf of the plaintiff, PW1 to PW3 were examined. The defendant relied on Ext. B1 to B4 and examined DW1.
7. The trial court found that the defendant has no case that her husband had forged her signature in Ext.A1 and no circumstance has been brought out in evidence to show that the plaintiff is aware of the signature of the defendant. It is found that the defendant had drawn Ext.A1 cheque in favour of the plaintiff, and there is no case for the defendant that there were sufficient funds in her account to honour Ext.A1 cheque. It has been brought out through the testimony of PW3, the Bank Manager, that Ext.A1 cheque was returned dishonoured for want of sufficient funds in the account of the defendant. The defendant was held liable to pay the cheque amount along with interest to the plaintiff.
8. Learned counsel for the appellant, Sri. Sreekumar Chelur argues that though the nature of the proceedings under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act and the civil case, claiming money based on the said cheque, are different, this is a case where the Magistrate Court had clearly found that there was no execution of the cheque as alleged by the plaintiff, and that the transaction/borrowal itself was disbelieved. It is therefore argued based on the judgment in Hope Plantations Ltd. v. Taluk Land Board, Peermade and Another [(1999) 5 SCC 590] and Gopal Prasad Sinha v. State of Bihar [(1970) 2 SCC 905] that principles of issue estoppel will apply and a re-litigation on the same facts and evidence cannot be done. At any rate, it is submitted that there is nothing more that is produced in the civil case to prove the transaction and, in the absence of that, a decree could not have been granted.
9. Pointing to the evidence of PW1, who deposed that he had not seen the person who wrote the cheque, it is argued that there was no proof of execution of the cheque. PW2, the brother of the plaintiff, was confronted with his previous testimony made in the criminal case, wherein he had admitted that the money was paid to the defendant's husband and not to the plaintiff. Though the trial court found that there was some difference in the signature on the cheque, it held that the defendant had the habit of putting different signatures in different places and granted a decree. Since the execution of A1 cheque was not proved, the plaintiff had not discharged his burden of proving the transaction. Consequently, no presumption was possible under the Negotiable Instruments Act. He relied on the decision in Subanamma Ninan and others v. George Veeran [2019 (5) KHC 103 (D