2005 Supreme(Raj) 2142
High Court Of Rajasthan
Judgename : R.S. Chauhan
Dr.Vijay Balani - Appellant
Versus
State of Rajasthan - Respondent
S.B. Criminal Misc. Petition No. 741 of 2003
Decided On : 09/15/2005
Important Points
Subject
Criminal Law - Procedure and Evidence
Act Referred
INDIAN PENAL CODE : S.304(a)
Headnote
Section 258 CrPC - Criminal Proceedings - [Section 258 CrPC] - The court discussed the scope and ambit of Section 258 CrPC, emphasizing that it applies only to summons cases instituted otherwise than upon complaint and empowers the Magistrate to stop the proceedings at any stage without pronouncing any judgment. The court highlighted that the power to stop the proceeding and discharge/acquit the accused is vast and should be used judiciously and sparingly, in exceptional cases or unusual circumstances attending the case.
Fact of the Case:
The petitioner challenged orders dismissing his application under Section 258 CrPC for dropping criminal proceedings against him, related to the death of a patient under his care. The petitioner argued that there was an inordinate delay in lodging the FIR and that the Medical Board had opined no negligence on his part.
Finding of the Court:
The court found that the case did not fall under the exceptional circumstances warranting the use of Section 258 CrPC and upheld the dismissal of the petitioner's application. The court also directed the Magistrate to complete the trial within six months.
Issues: Delay in lodging the FIR, Medical Board's opinion on negligence, Application under Section 258 CrPC
Ratio Decidendi: The court emphasized that the power under Section 258 CrPC should be used judiciously and sparingly, in exceptional cases or unusual circumstances attending the case.
Final Decision: The petition was dismissed, and the Magistrate was directed to complete the trial within six months.
Mr. P.R. Choudhary, for the Petitioner. Mr. Vishnu Kachhawaha, Public Prosecutor. Mr. B.S. Rathore, for Complainant..
R.S. Chauhan, J.-The petitioner has challenged the orders dated 08.04.2002 and dated 25.06.2003. The petitioner had submitted an application under Section 258 CrPC for dropping the proceedings against him. However, after hearing both the parties, the learned Magistrate was pleased to dismiss the said application vide order dated 08.04.2002. Thereafter, the petitioner had filed a revision petition before the Sessions Court. However, vide order dated 25.06.2003, the learned Sessions Judge was pleased to dismiss the said revision petition and to confirm the order dated 08.04.2002. Hence, this miscellaneous petition before us.
2. The brief facts of the case are that one Narayan Singh, the respondent No. 2, had lodged a FIR at Police Station, Mahamandir on 29.05.1994. He had alleged that on 02.05.1994 his sister-in-law was suffering from fever. On 03.05.1994. She was hospitalized under the care of the petitioner, Dr. Balani. Till, 3 0 clock in the afternoon, the patient was quite well. However, around 3.30 P.M., the patient started bleeding not only from her mouth, but also from her ear. She became unconscious. Despite the repeated request made to the petitioner that he should come and immediately attend to the patient, he refused to do so. He did not attend the patient till 5.15 P.M. in the evening. Because of his negligence, the patient lost lot of blood. Because of the blood loss, the patient required blood transfusion. However, there was no facility available in the hospital for checking the blood group of the donors. Because of the negligence of the doctor and the hospital staff , by 7 0 clock the patient had died.
3. On the basis of this report, a formal FIR was registered for offence under Section 304-A and 201 IPC. However, after a thorough investigation, the police filed a final report in the case. Subsequently, the statement of the Complainant and his witnesses were recorded under Sections 200 and 202 CrPC. Vice order dated 31.03.1998, the Magistrate was pleased to take cognizance against the petitioner for offence under Section 304-A IPC. The petitioner submitted an application under Section 258 CrPC for dropping the criminal proceedings. However, vide order dated 08.04.2002 the same was dismissed by the learned Magistrate. The petitioner preferred a revision petition, which was also dismissed vide order dated 25.06.2003.
4. Mr. P.R. Choudhary, the learned Counsel for the petitioner has vehemently argued that while dismissing the application under Section 258 CrPC, the learned Magistrate and the Revisional Court have ignored the fact that the death had occurred on 03.05.1994, but the FIR was not lodged till 29.05.1994. Hence, there is an inordinate delay of twenty-six days in lodging of the FIR. He has further contended that twice the opinion of the Medical Board was taken. The Medical Board had opined that there was no negligence on the part of the petitioner. Thus, he contended that the learned Magistrate should have dropped the proceeding after exercising his jurisdiction under Section 258 CrPC.
.5. Mr. Vishnu Kachhawaha, the learned Public Prosecutor for the State and Mr. B.S. Rathore, the learned Counsel appearing for the complainant, have argued that the impugned orders are well considered. Hence, they are legally valid.
6. We have critically examined both the impugned orders.
7. In order to understand the controversy involved, it is pertinent to consider the scope and ambit
of Section 258 CrPC Section 258 reads as under: -"Power to stop proceedings in certain cases. - In any summons-case instituted otherwise then upon complaint, a Magistrate of the first class or, with the previous sanction of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, any other Judicial Magistrate, may, for reasons to be recorded by him, stop the proceedings at any stage without pronouncing any Judgment and where such stoppage of proceedings is made after the evidence of the principal witnesses has been recorded, pronounce a Judgment of acquittal, a