High Court Of Rajasthan
Judgename : Wanchoo,Bhandari
STATE - Appellant
Versus
BABULAL - Respondent
Criminal Ref. 93 Of 1953
Decided On : 02/17/1956
POLICE ACT, 1861 - ENFORCEMENT IN RAJASTHAN - ACT 5 OF 1861, S. 46 - CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, ARTS. 372, 385, 212-A - RAJASTHAN ADAPTATION OF CENTRAL LAWS ORDINANCE, 1950 (4 OF 1950), S. 4 - VALIDITY OF NOTIFICATION BRINGING THE ACT INTO FORCE - TECHNICAL DEFECT IN NOTIFICATION - SUBSTANCE OF THE MATTER - POWER OF STATE GOVERNMENT TO BRING THE ACT INTO FORCE BY NOTIFICATION.
Fact of the Case:
The Rajasthan Adaptation of Central Laws Ordinance (4 of 1950) was promulgated on 24-1-1950, adapting various Central acts to Rajasthan. The Police Act (5 of 1861) was not included in the Schedule initially. On 18-7-1950, the Rajpramukh added the Police Act to the Schedule, omitting the second paragraph of Section 21. The question arose whether the Police Act was legally enforced in Rajasthan.
Finding of the Court:
The court held that the Police Act of 1861 was validly enforced in Rajasthan. The notification of July 1950, though issued under the wrong section of the wrong law, was effective in bringing the Act into force in Rajasthan. The State Government had the power to do so under Section 46 of the Act itself.
Issues: 1. Whether the Police Act (5 of 1861) was legally enforced in Rajasthan. 2. Whether the notification of July 1950, issued under Section 4 of the Rajasthan Adaptation of Central Laws Ordinance (4 of 1950), was valid in bringing the Act into force.
Ratio Decidendi: 1. The Police Act of 1861 is a piece of legislation that does not come into force in any area by itself. It has to be brought into force by virtue of the provision of Section 46 of the Act, which empowers the State Government to extend the Act to any presidency, province, or place by notification. 2. The Constitution of India came into force on 26-1-1950. Article 372 (1) of the Constitution saves all laws in force, subject to other provisions of the Constitution. The Police Act of 1861 was a law in force when the Constitution came into force and was saved by Article 372 (1). 3. The State Government, therefore, could bring the Police Act of 1861 into force by a notification under Section 46 of the Act. 4. The notification of July 1950, though issued under the wrong section of the wrong law, was effective in bringing the Act into force in Rajasthan. The State Government had the power to do so under Section 46 of the Act itself.
Final Decision: The court held that the Police Act of 1861 was validly enforced in Rajasthan.
WANCHOO, C. J.
( 1 ) THIS is a reference by the Sub-Divisional Magistrate of Fatehpur under Section 432, Criminal P. C. The question raised before him was that the Police Act (5 of 1861) was not legally enforced in Rajasthan. He has, therefore, referred the question whether the Police Act (5 of 1861) is legally enforced in Rajasthan and is thus a valid piece of legislation in Rajasthan.
( 2 ) A preliminary objection has been taken on behalf of the State that the reference is invalid as the Sub-Divisional Magistrate has not said in so many words that his opinion is that the Act is not legally enforced and is not a valid piece of legislation so far as Rajasthan is concerned. There is no doubt that he has not said so in so many words, but a reading of his reference order shows that he was inclined that way and under these circumstances, we over-rule the preliminary objection.
( 3 ) THE manner in which the Police Act (5 of 1861) came to be applied to Rajasthan is this : On 24-1-1950 the Rajasthan Adaptation of Central Laws Ordinance (4 of 1950) was promulgated by His Highness the Rajpramukh. A number of Central acts were adapted to Rajasthan by virtue of Section 3 of the Ordinance read with the Schedule. The Police Act (5 of 1861) was, however, not included in the Schedule when this Ordinance was passed. Section 4 of the Ordinance gave power to the Rajpramukh by order notified in the rajasthan Gazette, to add to, amend or vary the schedule to this Ordinance. Subsections (2) and (3) of Section 4 of this Ordinance provided what would be the effect of additions, amendments and variations in the Schedule. On 26-1-1950 the constitution of India came into force in Rajasthan. On 18-7-1950, the Rajpramukh purporting to act under Section 4 of the Rajasthan adaptation of Central Laws Ordinance (4 of 1950) added the Police Act of 1861 in the Schedule to the Ordinance as No. 10a, with the notification that the second paragraph of Section 21 was omitted. The question that falls for consideration is whether by this notification the Police Act came into force from the date of tiie notification in Rajasthan.
( 4 ) THE main argument on behalf of Babulal in this connection is that after the coming into force of the Constitution, Section 4 of the Rajasthan Adaptation of central Laws Ordinance (4 of 1950) was impliedly repealed as the Constitution provided specifically the manner in which laws would be enacted in Part b States in Article 385 read with Article 212-A. As in fact this notification of July, 1950 was enacting a law, it could not be done by virtue of the power conferred under Section 4 of the Ordinance and it could only be done in the manner provided Articles 385 and 212-A of the Constitution. There is, in our opinion, force in this argument that after the Constitution came into force, laws could only be enacted in the manner provided in Articles 385 and 212a of the Constitution and could not be enacted by virtue of the power conferred by section 4 of the Ordinance. However if the matter stood there, it could be said that the Police Act of 1861 was not properly enacted and therefore could not be enforced in Rajasthan. But we find that the Police Act of 1861 is a piece of legislation which though in existence, does not come into force in any area by itself. It has to be brought into force by virtue of the provision of Section 46 of the Act. That section reads as follows:
"this Act shall not by its own operation take effect in any presidency, province, or place. But the State Government by an order to be published in the official Gazette may extend the whole or any part of this act to any presidency, province or place and the whole or such portion of this Act as shall be specified in such order shall thereupon take effect in such Presidency, State or place. "
Thus the Police Act of 1861 can be brought into force by any State by means of a notification and it is open to the State making the notification to apply the whole of it or
AI
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.