RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT
Milap Chandra Jain, J.
State of Rajasthan - Appellant
Versus
Smt. Bhanwar Kanwar - Respondent
S.B. Civil Restoration Application No. 431 of 1989.
Decided On : 15-01-1991
LIMITATION ACT - SECTION 5 - CONDONATION OF DELAY - APPLICATION FOR RESTORATION OF APPEAL DISMISSED FOR DEFAULT OF APPEARANCE OR WANT OF PROSECUTION - DELAY OF ABOUT TWO YEARS IN MOVING THE APPLICATION NOT EXPLAINED - NO SUFFICIENT CAUSE SHOWN - APPLICATION DISMISSED.
Fact of the Case:
An appeal was filed under Section 30 of the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923 against the order of the Workmen's Compensation Commissioner awarding compensation to the respondents on the death of their husband/father. The appeal was dismissed for default of appearance and prosecution. An application for restoration of the appeal was moved under Order 41 Rule 19, Civil Procedure Code with a delay of about two years. An application under Section 5, Limitation Act was also filed for condoning the delay in submitting the notices beyond the stipulated period.
Finding of the Court:
The court found that the delay of about two years in moving the application for restoration of the appeal was not explained. The court also found that the office of the Government Advocate, Jodhpur was not functioning in the manner in which it is required to function and no follow up action was taken.
Issues: Whether the delay of about two years in moving the application for restoration of the appeal was sufficiently explained.
Ratio Decidendi: The court held that the delay of about two years in moving the application for restoration of the appeal was not sufficiently explained. The court also held that the office of the Government Advocate, Jodhpur was not functioning in the manner in which it is required to function and no follow up action was taken.
Final Decision: The application for restoration of the appeal was dismissed.
"Hon'ble Shri N.C. Sharma, J.
Mr. B.C. Bhansali for the appellant.Learned counsel for the appellant wants time to file notices for Ghanshyam Singh and Sampat Singh, legal representatives of deceased respondent No. 1. He should do so within 5 days. In default whereof this miscellaneous appeal shall stand dismissed without reference to the court."
"In continuation of the Application under Order 41, Rule 19, Civil Procedure Code dated 29.4.87 the State-appellant most respectfully submits this Application Under Section 5 Limitation Act with the prayer that the aforesaid previous Application dated 29.4.89 along with its Affidavit may kindly be treated as part of this Application and the delay so caused in submitting the notices beyond the stipulated period may kindly be condoned and the case may kindly be ordered to be listed at its original number as the delay so caused is due to rush of work without any ulterior motive."
It is thus clear that this application was moved for the condonation of delay occasioned in filing notices in compliance with the order dated August 25, 1987 and not for explaining the delay of about two years in moving the said application under Order 41 Rule 19, Civil Procedure Code.
"3. That only on 28.4.1989 it came to my notice through the Controller, Litigation, Joghpur that the aforesaid appeal has been dismissed for not filing the notices as ordered by the Hon'ble Court on 25.9.87 and immediately thereafter I brought this matter in the knowledge of the Government Advocate, Jodhpur and the restoration application was filed on 29.4.89 i.e. only after one day of the date of knowledge. Thus the delay in filing the restoration application is bonafide one and not an intentional one and deserves to be condoned."
The limitation under Article 122, Limitation Act, 1963 for moving an application for restoring an appeal dismissed for default of appearance or for want of prosecution or failure to pay costs of service of process in 30 days from the DATE OF DISMISSAL. Under Section 5, Limitation Act such an application may be admitted after presc
AI
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.