2003 Supreme(Raj) 1485
RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT
Bhagwati Prasad, J.
Satya Prakash - Appellant
Versus
Madan Lal - Respondent
S.B. Civil Revision Petition No. 254 of 1996.
Decided On : 23-09-2003
Important Points
The tenant's obligation to pay rent continues even during the pendency of a suit for eviction, and the landlord has the right to file a second suit for the same period of default.
Subject
Civil Law - Landlord-Tenant Dispute
Act Referred
RAJASTHAN PREMISES CONTROL OF RENT AND EVICTION ACT : S.13(3)(a)(i)
Headnote
Revision Petition - Landlord-Tenant Dispute - Rajasthan Premises (Control of Rent & Eviction) Act - Section 13(3), (4), (5) and (6) - The court discussed the determination of rent, depositing rent, and consequences of non-payment under the Act. The interpretation of these provisions influenced the court's decision in favor of the landlord.
Fact of the Case:
The petitioner, a tenant, was sued for ejectment by the landlord for default in rent payment. The petitioner argued that the rent had been determined in a previous suit and no default was found. The landlord filed a second suit for the same period of default, which the petitioner contested.
Finding of the Court:
The court held that the tenant's obligation to pay rent continues even during the pendency of a suit for eviction. The court emphasized the importance of regular rent payment and rejected the tenant's argument that no liability exists until the court determines the rent.
Issues: The main issue was whether the tenant's failure to pay rent during the pendency of a suit could be the basis for a second suit by the landlord.
Ratio Decidendi: The court interpreted the provisions of the Rajasthan Premises (Control of Rent & Eviction) Act, particularly sections 13(3), (4), (5) and (6), to emphasize the tenant's ongoing obligation to pay rent and the consequences of non-payment.
Final Decision: The court dismissed the revision petition, upholding the landlord's right to file a second suit for the same period of default, and emphasizing the tenant's obligation to pay rent regularly.
Advocates:
For the Petitioner:Mr. J.R. Patel, Advocate.
For the Respondent:Mr. B.M. Bhojak, Advocate.
JUDGMENT :
1. - Present revision petition arises out of an order by the trial court deciding issue No. 2 and certain applications. The trial court has held issue No. 2 against the petitioner defendant. Petitioner defendant was a tenant in two shops owned by plaintiff respondent in terms of rent deed executed on 1.3.85. He was inducted as a tenant but after May, 1992, the petitioner tenant discontinued to pay the rent personally. The tenant wrote a letter to the landlord on 27.8.1992. By this letter, the petitioner sought information regarding Bank account number of the landlord. The landlord respondent informed the tenant about his Bank account number on 4.9.92. The landlord on 31.10.92 terminated the tenancy of the petitioner defendant. Consequent thereto he filed a suit for ejectment of the petitioner on the basis of default and other grounds on 10.12.92. The petitioner filed an application under Order 7 Rule 11 C.P.C. on 7.2.94 alleging that the plaintiff has filed a suit earlier on the basis of first default, the rent had not been determined in that suit and, therefore, no second suit can be maintained on the ground of default, therefore, the suit is liable to be dismissed. This application under Order 7 Rule 11 C.P.C. was dismissed by the trial court and it was held that there was cause of action available to the plaintiff and, therefore, maintainability of the second suit was upheld. Such order was not challenged by the petitioner. The order dated 16.4.94 having not been challenged by the petitioner has become final.
2. The petitioner defendant filed written statement in the suit on 18.8.94. On 29.3.95 issues were framed. Another issue being number 4 was decided against the defendant, which relates to admissibility of the rent note. After that evidence of the plaintiff was being recorded. On 7.10.95 petitioner defendant moved an application before the court under section 151 CPC. In this application it was averred that in the order where rent was determined in earlier suit, it has been held by the court that there is no rent due for the time in question. The second suit for default was, therefore, not maintainable. This application remained pending and the petitioner filed an application under Order 14 Rule 2 C.P.C. By the order impugned, the trial court disposed of issue No. 2. In view of the decision on issue No. 2, no findings were given on the application under Order 14 Rule 2 C.P.C. As regards the application u/s. 151, it was dismissed. Issue No. 2 as decided by the trial court by the order impugned reads as under:-
D;k oknh izFke okn djkus fjDr ifjlj v/khu fdjk;snkj cvk/kkj O;frdze pqdkus fdjk;k izfroknhds fo:) yfEcr jgrs gq, izfroknh }kjk iqu% O;froe dj nsus ds vk/kkj ij ;g nwljk okn ykus ds vf/kdkjh gS A
3. Learned counsel for the petitioner supported his case and submitted that the trial court had determined the rent in the previously instituted suit on 28.1.94 and came to the conclusion that no rent was due. Since the court came to a definite conclusion that no rent was due, the question of holding the tenant as defaulter did not arise and ultimately, the previously instituted suit was dismissed on 14.11.2000. Against this order, an appeal was preferred by the landlord, which was dismissed on 7.1.2003. The second appeal in this regard is alleged to be pending before this Court. It is also claimed that notices have been issued in that appeal.
4. While the first suit was having its sequence of events as aforesaid, the landlord filed a second suit on the ground of default of payment of rent on 4.11.93. In this suit, it was alleged that the tenant had not paid the monthly rent from November, 1992 to October, 1993. The allegations in the suit were denied by the petitioner and it was submitted that the landlord had already filed a suit, on a ground contained in section 13(i)(a) of the Rajasthan Premises (Control of Rent & Eviction) Act (for short `the Act'). It was claimed by the petitioner that during the pendency of