RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT AT JAIPUR BENCH
Arun Madan, J.
Dr. G.S. Bali - Appellant
Versus
Babulal Jain And Anr. - Respondent
S.B. Civil Revision No. 309 of 1998.
Decided On : 7-02-2000
Companies Act - Dispute between Directors - Section 284 of the Companies Act 1956 - The court held that the petitioner's suit against the other two Directors of the company did not fall within the ambit of the Companies Act, 1956 but within the jurisdiction of the civil courts. However, the court found that the petitioner was not entitled to agitate the issue by way of a suit for injunction before the trial court as the Act provides adequate mechanism for removal of directors and safeguards to a director of a company against whom a resolution has been drawn up by the Board. The civil courts could not interfere in matters relating to the internal management of the company.
Fact of the Case:
The petitioner, a retired Lt. Colonel, established a tannery in partnership with an NRI. Dispute arose when the NRI attempted to dispose of the factory and drive out the petitioner.
Finding of the Court:
The court found that the petitioner's suit against the other two Directors of the company did not fall within the ambit of the Companies Act, 1956 but within the jurisdiction of the civil courts. However, the court held that the petitioner was not entitled to agitate the issue by way of a suit for injunction before the trial court as the Act provides adequate mechanism for removal of directors and safeguards to a director of a company against whom a resolution has been drawn up by the Board. The civil courts could not interfere in matters relating to the internal management of the company.
Issues: Dispute between Directors, Jurisdiction of Civil Courts, Application of Companies Act 1956
Ratio Decidendi: The court held that the dispute between the directors fell within the jurisdiction of the civil courts and not the Companies Act, 1956. However, the petitioner was not entitled to seek relief through a suit for injunction as the Act provides a mechanism for removal of directors and safeguards to a director of a company against whom a resolution has been drawn up by the Board. The civil courts could not interfere in matters relating to the internal management of the company.
Final Decision: The revision petition was dismissed.
1. IDBI DUES-Rs. 88 lacs to be paid TTPL in 14 half yearly instalments, with interest @ 15% from the start up of production with one year moratorium.
2. Bank of Baroda-Rs. 75 lacs to be paid as above.
3. Other Creditors-Other creditors including Government of Rajasthan and labour etc. Rs. 30.15 lacs.
(A) Government agrees to transfer the entire share holding of Rajasthan State Tanneries Ltd. of the face value of Rs. 194.16 lacs at a token consideration of Rs. 1000/- in favour your newly formed Company M/s. Tonk Tanneries Pvt. Ltd. (TTPL) on their terms and conditions are set out below:
(a) an agreement to transfer shall be entered between the State Government, Rajasthan State Tanneries Ltd. and M/s. Tonk Tanneries Pvt. Ltd. for the implementation within a period of 90 days of the date of agreement.
(b) a security of Rs. 5 lacs (inclusive of Rs. 50,000/- already received the earnest money) shall be given by M/s. Tonk Tanneries Pvt. Ltd. to the State Government. The security shall be liable to be forfeited in case of non compliance of the agreement within the stipulated time. Time could be extended on reasonable grounds by the State Government on the request of M/s. Tonk Tanneries Pvt. Ltd. after enhancing the security to a reasonable limit as decided by the Government.
(c) M/s. Tonk Tanneries Pvt. Ltd, will settle outstanding liabilities of IDBI to their entire satisfaction, Government shall, however, assist for getting the relief from IDBI as far as possible. Government shall not be responsible for any controversy in finalisation of the agreement between IDBI and M/s. Tonk Tanneries Pvt. Ltd. The Government shall not be responsible for any outstanding liability towards IDBI.
(d) M/s. Tonk Tanneries Pvt. Ltd. will settle outstanding liabilities of Bank of Baroda to their entire satisfaction as stipulated in para (c) above.
(e) M/s. Tonk Tanneries Pvt. Ltd. will pay Rs. 30.15 lacs to the State Government against current liabilities. Rs. 10.00 lacs will be paid by the Tonk Tanneries Pvt. Ltd. at the time of agreement and remaining Rs.
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.