1974 Supreme(Raj) 259
RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT
S.N.Modi, J.
Radha Kishan - Appellant
Versus
Teekamdas - Respondent
S.B. Civil First Appeal No. 196 of 1972.
Decided On : 19-02-1974
Important Points
Subject
Civil Law - Partnership Dispute
Headnote
partnership accounts - appeal - The court allowed the appeal, set aside the decree, and remanded the case back to the trial court for a fresh decision, giving the parties one more opportunity to produce partnership account books possessed by them.
Fact of the Case:
The plaintiff appealed in a suit for rendition of partnership accounts. The Commissioner failed to submit the report, and the court dismissed the suit. The plaintiff appealed against this decision.
Finding of the Court:
The court found that the defendant was the accounting party and possessed the account books. It allowed the appeal, set aside the decree, and remanded the case back to the trial court for a fresh decision, giving the parties one more opportunity to produce partnership account books possessed by them.
Issues: Parties' failure to submit partnership account books, negligence of the plaintiff, and compensation for the defendant.
Ratio Decidendi: The defendant was the accounting party and possessed the account books. The plaintiff was negligent, but the defendant could be compensated by awarding suitable costs from the plaintiff.
Final Decision: The court allowed the appeal, set aside the decree, and remanded the case back to the trial court for a fresh decision, giving the parties one more opportunity to produce partnership account books possessed by them.
"It is declared that this partnership firm had been dissolved on 7-3-65. It is ordered that Shri Baijnath is appointed as Commissioner to take the accounts of the above business into consideration from 19-1-63 to 7-3-64 and submit his report, Further it is ordered that the Commissioner shall take the following accounts into consideration:
1. An account of the credits, property and effects now belonging to the said partnership.
2. An account of the debts and liabilities of the said partnership.
3. An account of all dealings and transactions between the plaintiff and defendant.
It is ordered that the above accounts be taken & all other acts required to be done by the Commissioner be completed within a period of one month and the Commissioner shall submit his report and the result of the accounts and the result of all other acts."
In pursuance of the above preliminary order, Shri Baijnath was asked to submit the report but he failed to do so. Subsequently he resigned and Shri Ratanlal Patwa was appointed Commissioner is his place. The Commissioner served notices on the learned Counsel for the parties to submit partnership account books but none of the parties cared to submit the partnership accounts books. Ultimately, Shri Ratanlal Patwa submitted his report on 25-7-70 mentioning therein that the parties have failed to submit partnership account books in spite of service of notice. The court on receipt of the said report directed the parties to file objections. After several adjournments, the learned Counsel for the plaintiff submitted two applications on 7-8-71. In the first application it was requested that the Commissioner be directed to submit his report on the basis of the copies of the account books produced by the defendant along with the written statement. In the second application, the plaintiff submitted that the defendant himself in his written statement gave full partnership accounts and also admitted that a sun Rs. 7000/- stands credited to the plaintiff in the account books. Separate replies were filed on behalf of the defendant to the aforesaid two application filed by the plaintiff.' The significant point to be noted is that the defendant did not deny that Rs. 7000/- did not stand credited to the plaintiff as mentioned in his own written statement. The learned Additional District Judge dismissed both these applications and ultimately dismissed the suit. Aggrieved by the said judgment and decree, the plaintiff has come up in appeal.