M. L. Jain and 7 others vs State of Rajasthan

Judicial Analysis Court Copy Headnote Facts Arguments Court observation

1991 Supreme(Raj) 804

M.B.SHARMA, FAROOQ HASAN
M. L. Jain and 7 others – Appellant
Versus
State of Rajasthan – Respondent

JUDGMENT

1. - In each of the above numbered writ petitions the dispute is in respect of inter se seniority of the petitioners and the respondents No. 4 and 5, namely Ram Ballabh Sharan Sharma and Kailash Chand Sharma respectively. The facts are almost identical and therefore, we proceed to dispose of all these write petitions by this common order.

2. To understand the controversy between the parties in respect of their seniority, it will be proper at the outset to give their dates of initial appointment, promotions and confirmations etc in tabular form in the following table :

S. No.

Name of Petitioner/Respondent

Post and Date of Initial Apptt. with merit Position

Date of Confirmation

Promotion as Inspector Gr. I

Date of confirmation

Promotion as Asstt. Registrar

Date of Confirmation

Promotion as D.R.

PETITIONERS

Atma Singh (DBCW698/89)

20.2.57 (Insp. Exe.)(4)

1.7.59.

21.11.60.

21.11.61.

2.5.75

6.10.79.

18.11.83

K.K. Nagpal (DBCW-696/89)

20.5.57. (Insp. Exe.) (19)

1.7.59

19.9.61

19.9.62

25.5.76

23.5.78

18.11.83

T.N

Click Here to Read the rest of this document

1991 Supreme(Raj) 804

M.B.SHARMA, FAROOQ HASANM. L. Jain and 7 others – AppellantVersusState of Rajasthan – Respondent

M.B.SHARMA, FAROOQ HASAN
M. L. Jain and 7 others – Appellant
Versus
State of Rajasthan – Respondent